1. CHAPTER 1 LIBERAL DEMOCRACY IN CISIS
CHAPTER 1
“Liberal Democracy in Crisis”
If liberal democracy once appeared to be the inevitable future of humanity, why does it now appear to be in crisis?
1. The moment when liberal democracy seemed destined to win
Acemoglu begins the chapter with two quotations. The first is from Francis Fukuyama, who famously argued that the great ideological struggle of the twentieth century had effectively ended with the triumph of Western liberal democracy. The second is from the song “Wind of Change” by the Scorpions, which became associated with the political transformation taking place in Eastern Europe and the collapse of Soviet domination. These two references immediately establish the historical atmosphere in which Acemoglu's story begins: the late 1980s and early 1990s, when many people genuinely believed that liberal democracy had finally won.
Acemoglu then takes us to 16 June 1989 in Budapest, Hungary. This is not simply a historical date for him; it represents a moment when an entire political order appeared to be collapsing and a new one seemed ready to emerge. Six coffins were placed beneath the monumental steps of the Műcsarnok, a major art museum. Five of them contained the remains of Prime Minister Imre Nagy and his companions, who had been executed by the Soviet authorities in 1958 because they had led the Hungarian uprising against Soviet rule. Their graves had been kept secret for years, and their remains were only discovered much later. The sixth coffin was deliberately empty. It symbolized the many unnamed people who had died during the failed revolution.
Around a quarter of a million Hungarians gathered there. Their emotions were mixed. They were hopeful because they believed that Hungary might finally become free, but they were also afraid because they remembered what had happened during the uprising of 1956–58. In other words, the crowd was standing between memory of repression and hope for democracy.
This is important because Acemoglu wants us to understand that democracy was not originally experienced merely as an abstract constitutional arrangement. For people living under authoritarian or communist rule, democracy meant something very concrete: freedom from political domination, national independence, the right to choose one's government, and the possibility of living without fear.
2. Viktor Orbán's first political message
The last speech of the ceremony was delivered by a young politician representing Fidesz, the Alliance of Young Democrats: Viktor Mihály Orbán. At that time, Orbán was a young democratic activist. His message was extremely different from the political position for which he later became famous.
He told the Hungarian people that if they believed in their own strength and remained determined, they could end communist dictatorship. He called for free elections and demanded the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Hungary. At that time, approximately 70,000 Soviet troops were still stationed in Hungary. Orbán therefore represented a politics of freedom, democracy and national independence.
This historical contrast is one of the most powerful devices Acemoglu uses in the opening pages. The same person who later became one of the most prominent advocates of what he called an “illiberal state” originally stood before a huge crowd demanding liberal democracy.
Acemoglu is therefore preparing a puzzle for us:
How did a young politician who once demanded freedom from authoritarianism eventually become a politician associated with the weakening of liberal institutions?
This question is not only about Orbán. Orbán becomes a symbol of a much larger transformation that Acemoglu wants to explain.
3. From the victory of democracy to the beginning of the crisis
Orbán's speech came at a time when the Soviet system was beginning to collapse. Hungary was moving away from Soviet control, and Orbán would eventually become one of Europe's youngest prime ministers.
This was exactly the kind of historical development that encouraged Francis Fukuyama to argue that history had reached a decisive turning point. Fukuyama's famous idea was that the ideological struggle between competing political systems had essentially ended because liberal democracy had emerged as the ultimate successful model.
Many others shared this optimism. They believed that democracy and liberty were not merely gaining ground temporarily but that humanity had entered a historical period in which the movement toward greater freedom was almost unstoppable.
The collapse of the Soviet Union in the early 1990s seemed to provide enormous evidence for this belief. The world appeared to be moving in one direction: away from dictatorship and toward democracy.
The song “Wind of Change” by the Scorpions captured this atmosphere emotionally. It became associated with the collapse of Soviet power and the feeling that an entirely new political era was beginning.
But Acemoglu immediately tells us that this optimism did not last.
4. The extraordinary reversal of Viktor Orbán
The author now brings us back to Orbán, but this time several decades later.
By 2014, Orbán was again in power, but his political language had completely changed. The young man who once demanded freedom from communist dictatorship now openly declared that he was building an “illiberal state” and a “work-based society.” He also presented himself as defending European Christianity.
According to Acemoglu, Orbán concentrated executive power in his own hands, restricted freedom of speech, and closed or weakened media organizations and universities. His political model subsequently became influential among other politicians who were critical of liberal democracy, including politicians in the United States.
The significance of Orbán's transformation is therefore much larger than Hungary. Acemoglu uses it to show that the historical movement toward liberal democracy is not irreversible.
A country can move toward democracy and later move away from liberalism.
A politician can once fight for freedom and later restrict freedom.
A political system that once seemed victorious can later become fragile.
This leads directly to the central question of the book:
If liberalism and liberal democracy once inspired the world and delivered many of the things people wanted, what happened to them?
5. What exactly does “liberalism” mean?
Acemoglu now pauses the historical story and says that there is an important problem: the word “liberalism” does not have one universally accepted meaning.
In ordinary political language, the word can mean different things in different places.
In the United States, “liberalism” generally refers to a left-leaning or progressive political position.
In much of Europe, however, liberalism can refer more strongly to free markets and limited government, which are often associated with the political right.
So when someone says “liberal,” we first have to ask:
Liberal in what sense, and in which country?
Acemoglu also explains that liberalism can mean several different things simultaneously. It can mean a political philosophy, the institutions created from that philosophy, or the political movements and activists who try to put its principles into practice.
This explains why arguments about liberalism often become confusing. Different people may use the same word while referring to different political traditions.
6. The common core of liberalism
Despite these differences, Acemoglu argues that different forms of liberalism share a common foundation.
The first element is individual rights and freedoms. People should have the freedom to speak, practice religion, associate with others, make choices and, importantly, live without being subjected to arbitrary coercion.
The second element is limiting political power. Government cannot simply do whatever it wants. Political authority must be constrained because concentrated power can threaten individual freedom.
The third element is equality before the law. People should not receive different legal treatment simply because they belong to a particular social, political or economic group.
The fourth element is the belief that progress is possible and desirable. Liberals may disagree about what progress means, but they generally believe that society can improve.
Acemoglu then adds an important point about the left side of the liberal tradition. Many left liberals believe that society also has an obligation to help its weakest and most vulnerable members.
So liberalism, in Acemoglu's understanding, is not simply:
“Leave everyone alone and let the market decide.”
It contains a broader political commitment to freedom, rights, limits on power, equality before law, progress and, in many versions, protection of vulnerable people.
19.8.26 — Page 4
7. Why Acemoglu connects liberalism with democracy
Acemoglu makes an important philosophical argument here. He does not treat democracy as something externally attached to liberalism, as though we first have liberalism and then simply add elections to it.
For him, democracy is part of the liberal idea itself.
Why?
Because if individuals are free and possess political rights, they must also have some ability to participate in governing themselves. Liberalism therefore requires self-government, along with the responsibilities that come with it.
This is why Acemoglu speaks of liberal democracy rather than treating liberalism and democracy as two completely separate concepts.
The liberal part protects people from arbitrary power.
The democratic part gives people a role in exercising political power.
Together, they create a political system in which power is both exercised by citizens and constrained by rights and institutions.
8. Why Acemoglu focuses particularly on left liberalism
Acemoglu says that his book is concerned with liberalism in three interconnected senses: liberalism as a political philosophy, liberalism as a political movement, and liberal-democratic institutions created under its influence.
However, he says that he will often concentrate on the left-leaning side of liberalism, such as New Deal liberalism in the United States and social democracy in Europe.
The reason is historical.
According to Acemoglu, this version of liberalism played an especially important role in producing material and social progress. It helped expand political and economic rights beyond narrow elites and contributed to the development of modern liberal democratic institutions.
It helped expand rights to working-class people, women, ethnic minorities and other previously excluded groups.
This is an extremely important point for understanding the rest of the book.
Acemoglu is not defending liberalism simply because it sounds attractive as a political philosophy. He is arguing that a particular form of liberalism historically actually expanded people's capabilities, rights, security and participation.
9. What is NOT liberalism?
Acemoglu draws a fairly firm boundary around the concept.
If a political movement abandons the basic liberal commitments to freedom from coercion, freedom of expression, freedom of religion, freedom of association and freedom of individual choice, then Acemoglu says that movement cannot properly be called liberal.
He therefore distinguishes liberalism from political systems and ideologies such as fascism, authoritarianism, Marxism, communism and identity-based ideologies of both the left and the right, when these reject those fundamental freedoms.
The larger point is that the word “liberal” cannot simply be attached to a political movement because that movement uses democratic elections or claims to represent the people.
For Acemoglu, there are substantive principles that must remain intact.
19.8.26 — Page 5
10. The historical success of liberal democracy
Acemoglu now turns from definition to evidence.
He says that the left-leaning liberal tradition successfully raised people's aspirations and influenced political movements across the political spectrum. More importantly, it contributed to the creation of institutions that expanded rights and opportunities.
But this same form of liberalism is now in crisis.
The crisis exists at two levels.
First, liberalism as a political movement has weakened.
Second, the liberal democratic institutions themselves are under pressure.
Acemoglu then gives us some evidence, particularly from the United States.
11. People are losing faith in democracy
Over approximately the last three decades, people in the United States have increasingly become reluctant to say that democracy is the best form of government.
The change is particularly strong among Americans between 18 and 35 years old.
This is deeply significant.
A democracy becomes vulnerable not only when politicians attack democratic institutions, but also when ordinary citizens stop believing that democracy is valuable.
If citizens begin to think that democracy does not deliver what they need, they may become willing to support political alternatives that promise order, efficiency or material improvement even at the cost of democratic freedoms.
12. The collapse of trust in democratic institutions
Acemoglu next discusses trust.
As of June 2023, only about one-quarter of Americans said that they had a great deal or quite a lot of trust in either the presidency or the Supreme Court.
The figure for Congress was only 8 percent.
The media and newspapers were also suffering from very low levels of public confidence. This is particularly striking because historical polling shows that Americans once had substantially greater confidence in these institutions.
The problem therefore is not merely that people dislike a particular politician.
The deeper problem is that people are losing confidence in the institutions through which democracy is supposed to operate.
13. Polarisation is becoming another danger
Acemoglu then describes the growing political division in the United States.
When the Pew Research Center asked Americans in 2023 to describe the condition of their country's politics in one word, common answers included “bad,” “corrupt,” “divisive,” “chaos,” “messy,” and “polarized.”
The word “polarized” is especially important.
In the 1990s, approximately half of Americans surveyed described themselves as holding a mixture of left and right political views. There was therefore a considerable amount of ideological overlap.
That common ground has declined.
Republicans and Democrats now hold much more negative opinions of one another. More importantly, people in both parties are becoming less willing to accept political compromise.
So the crisis of liberal democracy has at least three connected dimensions:
people trust democracy less; they trust democratic institutions less; and they increasingly distrust one another politically.
19.8.26 — Page 6
14. Why did democracy become so attractive in the first place?
Acemoglu now asks us to consider an important question.
Perhaps people are losing faith in liberal democracy because liberal democracy itself has failed to fulfil the promises that originally made it attractive.
He therefore takes us back to the period when democracy became widely accepted.
During the 1990s, democracy combined with liberal principles such as individual freedom and equality before the law became, in Acemoglu's words, almost the “only game in town.”
Even authoritarian governments felt pressure to present themselves as democratic or to dress themselves in democratic language. This tells us how powerful the idea of democracy had become.
But why did people want democracy?
Acemoglu says that its acceptance rested on three major promises.
These three promises become one of the most important conceptual frameworks for understanding the entire book.
15. First promise: SHARING
The first promise was shared prosperity.
Democracy promised that economic growth and technological progress would not benefit only a small privileged group. The gains from economic development were supposed to be distributed more broadly.
In simple language, democracy promised:
“If the country becomes richer, ordinary people should also become better off.”
This idea was so deeply connected with democracy that British workers campaigning for voting rights in the nineteenth century argued that universal suffrage was essentially a question of bread and cheese.
In other words, political rights were not seen as something separate from everyday economic life.
People wanted the right to vote because they wanted a political system that would respond to their material needs.
16. Democracy and economic dignity
Acemoglu gives Brazil as an example.
During Brazil's difficult transition from military dictatorship to democracy in the 1980s, workers' organizations and the Workers' Party demanded democratic rights partly because democracy was expected to produce higher wages and better working conditions.
The same connection existed in Eastern Europe.
People wanted to escape Soviet political oppression, but they were also attracted to democracy because they hoped it would allow them to achieve the higher standards of living they saw in Western countries.
This is crucial for Acemoglu's larger argument.
People do not support democracy only because they love elections.
They support it when they believe democracy will make their actual lives better.
Therefore, if democracy stops delivering economic security and shared prosperity, people's attachment to democracy may weaken.
17. Second promise: DRAINS
The second promise is expressed through the amusing but powerful phrase “Democracy and Proper Drains.”
Acemoglu uses this phrase to make a simple point: democracy promised not only political rights but also good public services.
People expected governments to provide things such as:
healthcare, education, roads, sanitation and other basic public infrastructure.
This mattered enormously because many nondemocratic governments had neglected these services.
Acemoglu gives nineteenth-century Britain as an example. Before democratization, conditions in major industrial cities were extremely poor. Life expectancy at birth in some industrial centres was below thirty years. Manchester had an average life expectancy of around twenty-five years, Liverpool around twenty-six and Bristol around twenty-nine. Sewage flowed through streets, making ordinary urban life extremely unhealthy and unpleasant.
As democracy developed, politicians increasingly had reasons to respond to the needs of ordinary citizens.
So democracy was not merely about who gets to vote.
It was also about what governments do with public power.
18. Brazil: when political participation changed public services
Acemoglu gives another particularly useful example from Brazil.
In 1998, poor and less-educated Brazilians became much more effectively enfranchised because new electronic voting machines made it possible for people to select candidates using pictures rather than complicated written forms.
This was especially important in a country where nearly one-quarter of the population was illiterate.
Before this change, complicated electoral procedures had effectively excluded many poor people from meaningful political participation. Political parties therefore had relatively little incentive to respond to their needs, including education, healthcare and welfare.
Once voting became easier, political participation among poorer citizens increased dramatically.
Political parties began competing for their support, and several parties promised improvements in infant and maternal healthcare and other public services.
The lesson is powerful:
When previously excluded people gain an effective political voice, politicians have stronger incentives to serve them.
Democracy therefore becomes meaningful not merely when people are formally given voting rights, but when they can actually exercise those rights.
19. The three promises introduced here
Although the discussion of the third promise continues on page 6, Acemoglu's framework is already becoming clear.
The historical attraction of liberal democracy rested on three expectations:
Sharing meant that economic prosperity should be broadly distributed rather than captured by elites.
Drains meant that government should provide useful public goods and services that improve ordinary people's lives.
Voice means that people should have genuine political participation and the ability to influence decisions affecting their lives.
These are not three unrelated benefits. They reinforce one another.
If people have voice, they can demand better public services.
If public services improve, people experience the practical value of democratic government.
If prosperity is shared, people develop a stronger reason to believe that democracy works for them.
Thus, liberal democracy historically gained legitimacy because it promised economic inclusion, effective government and political agency simultaneously.
20. The deeper argument emerging from Pages 1–6
The most important thing to understand from these six pages is that Acemoglu is not yet explaining the entire crisis. He is establishing the question and giving us the historical standard against which the later crisis will be judged.
His argument begins with a striking contradiction.
In 1989, a young Viktor Orbán stood before hundreds of thousands of Hungarians and demanded democracy, freedom and the removal of Soviet power. In the following decades, liberal democracy appeared to triumph globally. Fukuyama could therefore speak about the “end of history.”
Yet several decades later, Orbán himself became a symbol of illiberal politics.
At the same time, citizens in established democracies began losing faith in democratic institutions. Political polarisation increased. Trust declined. Compromise became harder. The question therefore is not simply why one politician changed.
The deeper question is:
Why did a political system that once promised freedom, prosperity, public services and political voice gradually lose its ability to fulfil those promises?
That is the central problem Acemoglu is going to investigate throughout the book.
And this gives us an especially useful way to remember Pages 1–6:
Liberal democracy became powerful because people believed it would give them three things: a share in prosperity, effective public goods, and a genuine voice in governing themselves. Its present crisis begins when people no longer believe that these promises are being fulfilled.
The remaining pages will build on this foundation by examining what happened to these promises, why liberal democracy succeeded for a period, why its relationship with economic power and technology changed, and how the system might be rebuilt.
1. Liberalism contains a broader political commitment to freedom, rights, limits on power, equality before law, progress and protection of vulnerable people.
2. Democracy is part of the liberal idea itself because if individuals are free and possess political rights, they must also have some ability to participate in governing themselves. Liberalism therefore requires self-government, along with the responsibilities that come with it.
The liberal part protects people from arbitrary power.
The democratic part gives people a role in exercising political power.
Together, they create a political system in which power is both exercised by citizens and constrained by rights and institutions.
3. “If the country becomes richer, ordinary people should also become better off.”
This idea is so deeply connected with democracy that the political rights arw not seen as something separate from everyday economic life.
People want the right to vote because they wanted a political system that would respond to their material needs. People support support when they believe democracy will make their actual lives better.
Therefore, if democracy stops delivering economic security and shared prosperity, people's attachment to democracy may weaken.
4. Democracy promises not only political rights but also good public services.
People expect governments to provide things such as:
healthcare, education, roads, sanitation and other basic public infrastructure.
5. When people gain an effective political voice, politicians have stronger incentives to serve them. Democracy therefore becomes meaningful not merely when people are formally given voting rights, but when they can actually exercise those rights.
6. Thus, liberal democracy historically gained legitimacy because it promises economic inclusion, effective government and political agency simultaneously.
Yes. In the book, printed pages 7–9 are the pages immediately before the section “Promises Broken.” They are important because Acemoglu is first establishing a historical proposition: liberal democracy did not merely promise freedom in the abstract; for a substantial period after World War II, it actually delivered material improvements, public services, regulation, and political voice. The later crisis therefore cannot simply be explained by saying that democracy never worked. His argument is more demanding: it worked for a period, and then something changed.
1. Page 7: The meaning of “shared prosperity”
On page 7, Acemoglu begins by examining the first of the three democratic promises introduced earlier: sharing. His point is not that post-war America became equal. Inequality continued across regions, education, race, gender, and between employers and workers. What is remarkable, he argues, is that economic growth was sufficiently broadly distributed that almost every major social group experienced substantial gains from it. Workers benefited along with managers, people with less education saw their wages rise rapidly, women’s employment and relative earnings increased, and the racial wage and opportunity gap between Black and white Americans narrowed significantly. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
This is a crucial distinction. Shared prosperity does not mean equality of outcome. Acemoglu is describing a situation in which economic growth produces improvements across classes rather than concentrating almost all of its benefits at the top.
That distinction becomes extremely important for understanding his later argument. His question is essentially: What happens to democracy when economic growth continues but the ordinary citizen no longer experiences growth as an improvement in their own economic life?
He then widens the argument beyond the United States. Germany, France and Japan experienced very rapid post-war growth, partly because they were rebuilding after the devastation of war. But European growth was, in his account, more equitable than American growth, helped by Scandinavian-style social democracy and, particularly, by strong labour unions and the post-war political settlement. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
So the first lesson of page 7 is:
Democracy gained legitimacy not simply because people could vote, but because ordinary people could see democracy improving their material lives.
⸻
2. Page 7–8: “Drains” means much more than drains
Acemoglu then moves to the second democratic promise, which he calls “Drains.” The word is deliberately almost humorous, but the idea is profound. Democracy was expected to produce public goods: sanitation, roads, hospitals, schools, transportation and other infrastructure that markets alone did not reliably provide to everyone. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
The phrase comes from John Betjeman’s line, “Democracy and proper drains.” Acemoglu uses it to make a larger point: political democracy became meaningful to ordinary people when governments began responding to problems that directly affected everyday existence.
The historical comparison is striking. In Britain in 1947, more than half of houses lacked bathrooms, and as late as 1960, four-fifths lacked refrigerators. By the 1970s, indoor plumbing had become almost universal in the United States and Britain, transportation infrastructure had expanded, rural areas were increasingly connected to highways, and economic opportunities consequently expanded. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
This is important for your own well-being–agency–freedom framework because Acemoglu is implicitly showing that formal political freedom is strengthened by material conditions that make freedom usable.
A person who has the right to participate politically but has no access to education, health care, transportation, sanitation or economic security possesses a formal right, but their effective capacity to exercise that right is constrained.
⸻
3. Page 8: Democracy and the expansion of health
Acemoglu next uses health care to demonstrate how democracy became materially meaningful.
In the United States of the 1950s, hospital access was highly unequal. Major cities had hospitals, but rural Americans often had virtually no access to them, with some people in the Midwest and South having to travel hundreds of miles for medical treatment. The Hill-Burton Act of 1946 helped trigger a major expansion of hospital infrastructure. By 1975, the United States had approximately 1,500 more hospitals than it had in 1948, including many in smaller cities and rural areas. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
Again, the underlying argument is bigger than the example.
Democracy becomes credible when political inclusion is converted into institutional responsiveness.
People acquire the vote, but the vote matters because governments begin responding to needs that were previously ignored. This is why Acemoglu keeps connecting democracy with public services. The democratic state becomes an instrument through which previously neglected populations can make their needs politically visible.
⸻
4. Page 8: Education as democratic mobility
Education provides his next example.
In the 1940s, only about half of American children graduated from high school. By the end of the 1960s, that figure had risen to 77 percent, and illiteracy among American children had essentially disappeared. More importantly, the probability that children whose parents had not completed high school would themselves graduate increased substantially. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
Notice the conceptual progression.
Acemoglu is not merely saying:
Democracy → more schools.
He is saying something closer to:
Democratic inclusion → political pressure → public investment → expanded education → greater social mobility.
Education therefore becomes part of the democratic promise because it changes the opportunities available to people who were born without economic privilege.
This connects very strongly with your recurring distinction between resources and opportunity. A school building is a resource. But the real democratic achievement lies in whether that resource enables someone born into a disadvantaged household to acquire greater freedom over the course of their life.
⸻
5. Page 8: Democracy also became a protective institution
The second half of page 8 introduces another dimension that is particularly important: regulation.
Acemoglu reminds us that industrial capitalism historically produced dangerous workplaces, unsafe products, misleading advertising and harmful medicines. His example of laudanum, an opium-based preparation that was prescribed even to children, illustrates how weak regulation could expose ordinary people to serious dangers. The 1906 Pure Food and Drug Act required products containing substances such as opium, cocaine, heroin, morphine and alcohol to be properly labelled. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
The deeper argument is that freedom cannot be understood simply as freedom from government intervention.
Sometimes government regulation is what makes freedom possible.
A worker who is formally free to accept employment is not necessarily substantively free if the workplace can kill them without consequence. A consumer is formally free to choose between products, but that choice is meaningless if producers are allowed to conceal lethal ingredients.
So Acemoglu’s liberalism here contains an important paradox:
The state sometimes has to constrain private power in order to preserve individual freedom.
That is a very important idea for understanding his later criticism of contemporary liberalism.
⸻
6. Page 8–9: Upton Sinclair and the political discovery of invisible suffering
He then turns to Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle.
Sinclair secretly investigated conditions inside a Chicago meatpacking plant and exposed the terrible conditions faced by poor, immigrant and largely uneducated workers. Acemoglu uses this episode to demonstrate how information can transform political action. Once conditions that had remained largely invisible became publicly known, political pressure produced regulatory intervention. The Federal Meat Inspection Act of 1906 followed, along with other protections. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
There is a very interesting connection here with your “Information Bias” work.
The workers were suffering before the public knew about the suffering. Their condition existed materially, but it was politically weak because it lacked sufficient public visibility.
Sinclair converted private suffering into public information.
Public information then became political pressure.
Political pressure became regulation.
Regulation changed material conditions.
That is almost a complete information → agency → institution → well-being chain.
And this is why the passage is more important than merely being a history of labour regulation.
⸻
7. Page 9: The third promise — “Voice”
Acemoglu now returns to the third promise of liberal democracy: voice.
Democracy promised people not only prosperity and public services, but the ability to participate in governing their own lives. People could attend town halls, discuss public affairs, communicate with representatives, stand for office and vote. Their opinions were supposed to enter the decision-making process. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
He invokes Alexis de Tocqueville’s observation of American democracy in the 1830s to emphasise that democracy was not simply an institutional arrangement in which people periodically cast ballots. It involved ordinary people participating in the governance of their communities.
This is particularly important because Acemoglu is defining democracy much more broadly than elections.
Democracy means:
having a voice, being heard, participating, influencing decisions and possessing some degree of collective control over the conditions of one’s life.
That is very close to an agency-centred conception of democracy.
⸻
8. The British example: democracy as the power to change priorities
Acemoglu then gives a powerful example from Britain after World War II.
British working-class voters voted Winston Churchill out of office despite his enormous prestige as the wartime leader. They elected a Labour government committed to implementing the principles of the Beveridge Report, which proposed a welfare state, stronger labour unions, wider public services, national health insurance and social security. Similar programmes were adopted elsewhere in Western Europe. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
This demonstrates what Acemoglu means by voice.
Democracy gave people the capacity to say:
We do not merely want a government that protects the nation; we want a society that protects ordinary people.
And crucially, the political system responded.
Therefore, voice was connected to sharing and drains.
People used political voice to demand redistribution, public services and security.
This creates the three-part architecture of his argument:
Sharing = economic inclusion.
Drains = public provision.
Voice = political agency.
Together, these made liberal democracy credible.
⸻
9. The central point immediately before “Promises Broken”
At the end of page 9, Acemoglu says something extremely important: democracy was never perfect. It sometimes violated liberal principles and sometimes failed to protect freedoms. Nevertheless, across the industrialised world, liberal democracy gradually advanced and delivered on these three promises, particularly after World War II, when left-liberal ideas became more influential. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
And then comes the transition.
He asks us to look at liberal democracy’s track record, beginning with shared prosperity. He starts with the extraordinary post-war decades and shows that growth was broadly shared, public services expanded, regulation improved, and ordinary citizens acquired greater political voice. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
Then, at the bottom of page 9, comes the heading:
“Promises Broken.”
That transition is crucial.
Acemoglu is deliberately constructing a before-and-after argument.
The “before” is not a utopia. It is a period in which liberal democracy had enough institutional capacity to convert economic growth into broad improvements in people’s lives.
The “after” begins when that conversion starts breaking down.
And the very first evidence he gives under “Promises Broken” is revealing: after the mid-1970s, economic growth no longer produced the same wage gains for ordinary Americans. Median inflation-adjusted wages had grown by more than 2.5% annually between 1948 and 1973, but from 1980 onward wage growth averaged only about 0.45% annually. WHAT HAPPENED TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY.pdf
So the intellectual bridge between pages 7–9 and “Promises Broken” is this:
Acemoglu first establishes that liberal democracy earned legitimacy by delivering. He then asks what happens when it continues to possess democratic institutions but increasingly stops delivering the material and political outcomes that made those institutions meaningful.
That, I think, is the key to reading the next section. The crisis he is about to describe is not primarily a crisis of voting procedures. It is a crisis of the relationship between democratic voice, economic distribution, public goods and people’s lived experience of freedom.
Page 9 — “Promises Broken”
Page 9 is a turning point in Acemoglu’s argument. The upper part of the page still describes what liberal democracy had achieved, but with the heading “Promises Broken,” the argument changes direction. Acemoglu now asks what happened when the earlier promise of liberal democracy—to improve ordinary people’s lives and give them an effective political voice—began to weaken.
The first part of the page completes the earlier discussion of the material achievements of liberal democracy. Acemoglu points to the 1906 Federal Meat Inspection Act, which followed Upton Sinclair’s exposure of dangerous conditions in the meat industry. This is an example of democratic institutions responding to social problems and protecting ordinary people. Over time, workplace deaths fell dramatically, showing that democratic government could translate public concern and political pressure into concrete improvements in people’s lives.
He then turns to the second major promise of democracy: political voice. Democracy was not merely about periodically choosing rulers. Ordinary Americans participated in town meetings, discussed politics with neighbours, governed their local communities and voted. Acemoglu uses Robert Dahl’s study of New Haven in the 1950s to make an important point. Dahl had asked who actually governed the city, and the answer was not simply an established political party or a fixed elite. Ordinary citizens had meaningful influence over local politics. In other words, democracy worked partly because people experienced themselves as participants in governing their shared political world.
Acemoglu then widens the argument beyond the United States. After World War II, British working-class voters demonstrated that their democratic voice could fundamentally change the direction of government. They voted Winston Churchill out of office despite his extraordinary wartime leadership and brought the Labour Party to power. This was not simply a change of personalities. Labour promised to implement the principles associated with William Beveridge’s wartime report: a welfare state, greater economic fairness, stronger labour unions, wider access to public services, national health insurance and social security.
This is crucial to understanding what Acemoglu means by the promise of liberal democracy. Democracy had historically created an expectation that political participation could produce a society in which ordinary citizens were safer, healthier, economically more secure and more capable of influencing government. Similar promises brought governments to power throughout Western Europe.
Then comes the dramatic transition:
“By the 2000s, the tide had turned.”
This sentence marks the beginning of the broken-promise argument. Acemoglu is not saying that democracy suddenly disappeared. Elections continued, institutions continued to exist, and democratic procedures remained formally intact. What changed was the substantive performance of democracy for ordinary citizens.
The first broken promise he identifies is economic progress. Economic growth after the mid-1970s no longer resembled the broad-based prosperity of the 1950s and 1960s. The oil crises of 1973 and 1979 produced severe economic contractions and stagflation, combining high inflation with unemployment. Although productivity began to recover during the 1980s, the recovery did not translate into comparable improvements in workers’ wages.
Acemoglu gives a particularly important statistic. Between 1948 and 1973, U.S. median inflation-adjusted wages had grown by more than 2.5 percent per year. From 1980 onward, wage growth slowed to only about 0.45 percent per year.
The significance is deeper than the numbers themselves. The earlier democratic settlement had created an implicit social contract: if the economy grows, ordinary people should share in that growth. Economic growth was therefore not merely a statistic about national production. It was connected to the legitimacy of liberal democracy. When productivity and the economy recovered but ordinary workers no longer experienced comparable wage growth, the connection between economic progress and popular prosperity began to break down.
So, on page 9, Acemoglu is beginning to establish a fundamental distinction:
Liberal democracy had once promised not merely political freedom, but a better material life and meaningful political participation. By the late twentieth century, both promises were becoming increasingly difficult to sustain.
The page therefore provides the bridge between the success story of postwar liberal democracy and the later crisis of liberal democracy. The crisis does not begin, in Acemoglu’s argument, because people suddenly stopped believing in democracy for abstract ideological reasons. It begins because many people increasingly experienced a gap between what democracy had promised and what democratic institutions were actually delivering.
And that gap—between promise and lived experience—is the central idea to carry forward into pages 10–15.
Yes. Pages 10–15 should now be read not merely as a list of American failures, but as a theoretical sequence. Acemoglu is showing how the promise of liberal democracy can become separated from lived democratic experience through several connected stages: first, unequal economic outcomes; then deterioration of public goods; then declining state capacity; then excessive procedural barriers; and finally the feeling that political participation itself no longer changes what government does. At that point, people may still formally possess the right to participate, but participation loses its substantive meaning.
I will therefore keep the discussion page-wise, while within each page separating the distinct theoretical arguments and illustrating each from the text.
Page 10 — Economic inequality: when economic citizenship begins to disappear
1. Economic growth ceases to be shared prosperity
Page 10 begins by extending the argument from page 9. Acemoglu says that even average wages, which can be artificially raised by the high earnings of the richest people, did not perform much better than median wages. The theoretical point is important: economic performance cannot be judged simply by looking at aggregate or average income. If the benefits of growth are concentrated at the top, national prosperity can increase while the lived economic experience of ordinary citizens stagnates.
This creates the first important separation between democracy's promise and democratic experience. A democratic society may continue to report economic growth, but if ordinary citizens do not experience that growth as an improvement in their own lives, the legitimacy of the economic order begins to weaken.
2. Inequality becomes structurally embedded in occupation and education
Acemoglu then makes the argument more precise. Manual workers and people without college degrees saw their wages decline, while professionals, managers and technical workers continued to enjoy rapid growth.
The theoretical argument here is that inequality is no longer merely a difference between individual incomes. It becomes connected to position within the economic structure. Education, occupation, managerial status and technological skills increasingly determine who benefits from economic transformation.
This means that the promise of equal citizenship begins to encounter an unequal economic reality. Formally, citizens may possess equal political rights, but their economic capacity to live securely and influence society becomes increasingly unequal.
3. Wealth concentration creates a distance between the economic elite and the majority
Acemoglu gives the striking example of the richest 1 percent. Their share of national income increased from around 10 percent in 1980 to 19 percent in 2019, while their share of total wealth reached about 35 percent.
The theoretical significance is not simply that "the rich became richer." It is that economic power becomes concentrated in a small part of society. Once economic resources become highly concentrated, the conditions under which citizens participate in public life also become unequal.
The citizen who possesses time, money, education, professional networks and access to decision-makers does not participate in the political world under the same conditions as someone struggling with stagnant wages and insecure employment.
Thus, formal political equality can coexist with substantive inequalities in political capacity.
4. Inequality becomes multidimensional
Acemoglu explicitly says that disparities transcend the familiar divisions of managers versus workers, the very rich versus everyone else, or postgraduates versus high-school graduates. Inequality appears across metropolitan versus smaller and rural areas and between capital and labour.
The theoretical point is that inequality becomes a socially distributed pattern rather than a single economic gap. Different groups begin to experience the same democracy differently because they occupy different economic and geographical positions.
This is important for understanding democratic fragmentation. People do not merely disagree politically; they increasingly inhabit different material experiences of the same political system.
5. The American Dream breaks as an intergenerational promise
One of the deepest arguments on page 10 concerns the "American dream." Acemoglu says that for people born in 1940, around 90 percent earned more than their parents. For those born in the 1980s, however, progress had essentially stopped, with about half doing worse than their parents.
This transforms inequality into something more profound: the loss of intergenerational mobility.
The democratic promise was not simply that people would have freedom today. It also carried an expectation that their children would have better opportunities tomorrow. When that expectation disappears, democracy is experienced not as a vehicle of progress but as a system under which social advancement has stalled.
6. The perception of failure becomes politically important
Acemoglu then cites the Pew finding that nearly three out of four Americans believe today's children will be financially worse off than their generation.
This introduces an important theoretical transition: lived experience is not only what objectively happens; it also includes what citizens reasonably perceive about their future.
Once people lose confidence that the next generation will do better, democratic legitimacy becomes fragile. The problem is no longer merely present income. It becomes the loss of a future-oriented democratic expectation.
Page 11 — Public services: when citizenship no longer produces common goods
7. Shared prosperity gives way to unequal provision
Page 11 begins by saying that the decline of shared prosperity occurred elsewhere too, although less dramatically than in the United States. Acemoglu identifies weak unions, a low minimum wage and weak norms against workplace inequality as important causes.
The theoretical argument is that institutions which once helped translate economic growth into broadly shared benefits weakened.
This matters because democracy requires more than elections. It also requires institutions capable of mediating between economic power and social welfare.
8. Public services are another test of democratic performance
Acemoglu then shifts from income to public services.
This is a major theoretical move. Democracy is experienced by citizens not only through voting but through ordinary encounters with schools, hospitals, transport, roads, administration and public institutions.
Therefore, when public services deteriorate, citizens experience democratic failure in their everyday lives.
The state may remain constitutionally democratic, but the citizen asks a much more immediate question:
What does this system actually do for me and my community?
9. Education reveals the difference between spending and capability
Acemoglu observes that American education spending per pupil increased substantially, from roughly $6,500 in the 1970s to almost $17,000 in 2019, in inflation-adjusted terms. Yet educational performance deteriorated, and by the late 2010s only about one-third of fourth-graders were reading at the expected proficient level.
The theoretical argument is extremely important: resources are not the same as outcomes.
A democratic government can spend more and still fail to create the capability that citizens actually need.
This distinction is especially important for your broader framework: the formal provision of a service is different from the substantive capability generated by that service. A school building, a budget or a programme does not automatically produce education.
10. The pandemic exposes the failure of institutional responsiveness
Acemoglu says the situation deteriorated further during the pandemic. Parents wanted their children back in classrooms but were often ignored, followed by further declines in reading and quantitative proficiency.
The theoretical issue here is responsiveness.
Democratic participation becomes meaningful only when institutions can hear social demands and translate them into timely action. If citizens express a demand but the institutional system does not respond, the chain connecting voice → response → outcome begins to break.
This is a crucial stage in the erosion of participation.
11. Health exposes a contradiction between expenditure and human welfare
Acemoglu calls health the field where the failure of American democracy is "in a league of its own." The United States spent roughly three times as much per person on health care as countries such as France, Britain and Japan, yet Americans were less healthy and shorter-lived.
The theoretical argument parallels education: institutional expenditure is not equivalent to democratic delivery.
A democratic system may possess enormous resources and sophisticated institutions, yet if citizens cannot convert those resources into actual health, the lived experience is one of institutional failure.
12. “Deaths of despair” reveal social failure beyond medical provision
Rising mortality among middle-aged white Americans, alongside opioid addiction and alcoholism, becomes an especially powerful example.
Acemoglu's point is that public health cannot be reduced to medical treatment. These deaths reflect deeper failures in social, economic and institutional conditions.
Thus, democracy's failure is experienced through the body itself.
When citizens cannot obtain basic preventive health care and one in four lacks access to a primary-care physician, the abstract democratic promise of equal citizenship encounters the concrete reality of unequal access to life's necessities.
Page 12 — Infrastructure: when the state becomes incapable of delivering ordinary things
13. Democratic failure becomes visible in mundane everyday life
Page 12 takes the argument into an even more interesting territory. Acemoglu says democracy faltered in areas that attract less attention: worsening roads, public-service interruptions and long delays in repairs.
This is theoretically significant because democratic legitimacy is not produced only by great constitutional achievements. It is also produced through mundane competence.
A citizen does not experience the state only while voting. They experience it while travelling on a road, crossing a bridge, obtaining a permit, repairing a house or using public transportation.
The ordinary functioning of infrastructure therefore becomes a form of everyday democratic performance.
14. Comparison with other countries intensifies the perception of failure
Americans could see China building bridges quickly while simple American repairs took years. By the 2000s, Italy had better and faster trains than the United States.
The theoretical point is comparative. Citizens do not evaluate institutions in isolation. They compare their lived reality with what they can see elsewhere.
Once citizens observe that other political systems appear capable of delivering certain public goods more effectively, the question becomes:
Why can't our democracy do this?
This is potentially dangerous because it creates an opening for authoritarian or populist arguments claiming that democratic procedures are themselves the source of inefficiency.
15. Infrastructure projects demonstrate the separation between intention and implementation
Acemoglu uses the Big Dig in Boston as the major example. The project was initially estimated at $2.6 billion and expected to finish in 1998. It was still in the planning stage in 1991 and was finally completed in 2007, nine years late, at about three times the original projected cost.
The theoretical argument is that political intention does not equal institutional capacity.
A government may identify a legitimate public need, allocate resources and announce a democratic policy, yet the institutional machinery may be incapable of converting that decision into timely results.
Thus, democratic failure can occur between decision and implementation.
16. The problem is not simply lack of money
Acemoglu says the inflation-adjusted cost of building a mile of highway tripled from the late 1960s to the 1980s, and argues that this was largely connected to regulation rather than simply more expensive labour or materials.
The important theoretical distinction is between protective regulation and institutional over-complexity.
Regulation can protect citizens from environmental damage, unsafe construction or discrimination. But when layers of regulation accumulate without an effective mechanism for coordination, regulation can become a barrier to collective action.
The problem therefore is not "democracy regulates too much" in a simple sense. It is that democratic institutions can create procedural structures that become incapable of coordinating their own purposes.
Page 13 — Bureaucratic self-enforcement: when participation itself becomes a burden
17. Democratic procedures can become obstacles to democratic action
Page 13 continues the Longfellow Bridge example. A relatively small bridge repair required approvals from numerous federal, state and local bodies, historical-preservation reviews, environmental reviews and public consultations.
Here Acemoglu introduces a deeper paradox.
Democracy requires participation, consultation and accountability. But participation can become so procedurally multiplied that collective action becomes almost impossible.
This is not an argument against participation itself. Rather, it is an argument about institutional design.
When every legitimate interest acquires its own veto point, the sum of legitimate procedures can produce an illegitimate outcome: nothing gets done.
18. Participation becomes procedural rather than substantive
The Longfellow Bridge project required four years of planning and approval followed by five years of actual repairs.
This allows us to distinguish between having a voice and having an effective voice.
Citizens may be consulted repeatedly. Meetings may be held. Reports may be prepared. Agencies may review documents. Stakeholders may submit objections.
Yet if all this participation produces no timely collective decision, participation becomes procedural rather than substantive.
This is very close to your point about the fundamental requirement of participation sinking: the problem is not that people have literally lost every opportunity to participate. The deeper problem is that participation ceases to produce agency.
19. Housing shows how procedural failure becomes a social crisis
Acemoglu then connects excessive regulation to housing. Federal and local rules increased construction costs and made new housing increasingly difficult to build even while homelessness increased.
San Francisco becomes the example: population growth greatly outstripped housing supply, while homelessness rose by 50 percent between 2000 and 2018.
The theoretical argument is that institutional failure can become self-reinforcing.
A society creates rules intended to protect citizens. Those rules make collective provision more difficult. Scarcity increases. Social problems become worse. Citizens then become more dissatisfied with government. Yet government may respond by creating further procedures rather than improving its capacity to act.
Thus the democratic system can become trapped in a cycle of:
problem → procedure → delay → worsening problem → public frustration → more distrust.
20. The Kafkaesque state destroys the meaning of ordinary citizenship
Acemoglu's examples of repairing a faucet, licensing hairdressers and massage therapists, and obtaining routine public services are theoretically powerful because they bring the crisis down to the smallest scale.
The citizen does not necessarily encounter democracy as "constitutional democracy." They encounter it as bureaucracy.
If ordinary activities require disproportionate permits, licences, approvals and paperwork, citizens begin to experience government as something standing between them and their ability to act.
The phrase “messy democracy” therefore acquires a deeper meaning. Democracy becomes identified not with collective self-government but with institutional friction.
21. The Biden infrastructure example reveals self-defeating democracy
Acemoglu then turns to Biden's infrastructure programme. The administration wanted to invest in infrastructure, but its own regulatory requirements and paperwork slowed the projects.
This creates perhaps the clearest institutional paradox of these pages:
A democratic government can undermine its own democratic objectives through the very rules it creates.
The state wants to build infrastructure, but the administrative system makes construction extraordinarily difficult.
So the gap between political promise and lived experience is no longer merely economic. It becomes a gap between what government says it will do and what government is institutionally capable of doing.
Page 14 — The collapse of effective political voice
22. When government cannot deliver, citizens begin to question whether their voice matters
Page 14 moves explicitly from public-service failure to democratic voice.
Acemoglu says that democratic voice has declined in both the United States and Europe. He returns to Robert Dahl's earlier finding that ordinary citizens once had meaningful influence in New Haven.
Now, he says, nobody would expect Dahl to find the same level of ordinary influence.
This gives us a very important historical contrast:
Earlier democracy: participation → influence → governance.
Later democracy: participation → limited influence → frustration.
The institutional form remains, but the lived relationship between citizen and government has changed.
23. Perceived political powerlessness becomes measurable
Acemoglu cites the striking finding that more than 85 percent of Americans believe elected officials do not care what people like them think.
This is a crucial theoretical threshold.
A democracy does not require every citizen to get what they want. Democracy necessarily involves disagreement and losing elections.
The deeper problem arises when citizens begin to believe that their preferences are irrelevant before the political process even begins.
At that point, electoral participation can survive formally while democratic agency declines substantively.
24. Political representation becomes economically unequal
Acemoglu says researchers have found that elected officials vote in accordance with the preferences of their richest constituents while largely ignoring the policy preferences of the bottom two-thirds.
This is arguably the most important theoretical claim on pages 10–15.
If citizens are formally equal but political responsiveness is systematically weighted toward wealthier citizens, then political equality becomes detached from actual political influence.
The citizen can vote, campaign, attend meetings and express opinions, yet the structure of representation may still systematically privilege some citizens over others.
Thus:
Equal vote ≠ equal influence.
That distinction is fundamental to understanding Acemoglu's crisis argument.
25. When voice fails, citizens experience the system as silencing
Acemoglu says many Americans therefore came to feel that their voices did not matter and that they were being actively silenced.
The word “silenced” should be understood carefully.
He is not necessarily saying that the state literally prohibited them from speaking. Rather, citizens can experience political silence without literal censorship.
A person may be perfectly free to speak, post, protest or vote, but if institutions repeatedly fail to respond to their concerns, they may conclude:
“I can speak, but speaking changes nothing.”
That is a much deeper democratic problem.
26. Immigration becomes an example of the representation gap
Acemoglu uses immigration to show how this feeling developed. A substantial portion of Americans had concerns about immigration, especially illegal immigration, but mainstream politicians paid limited attention to these concerns for much of the period.
The theoretical argument is not that every public concern must automatically become government policy. Democracy cannot work that way.
The issue is whether persistent and substantial preferences of citizens are represented in political competition.
When large numbers of citizens repeatedly express a concern and perceive that mainstream politics refuses to engage seriously with it, they can conclude that the political system is closed to them.
27. Suppressed voice can produce reaction rather than democratic withdrawal
The subsequent rise of identity politics, debates over racism and gender in school curricula intensified these perceptions.
This is where Acemoglu's argument becomes particularly subtle. The reaction against these issues cannot simply be dismissed as irrational or manufactured propaganda. He explicitly says that falsehoods and propaganda played a role, but he also says there was “a grain of truth” behind the feeling of political exclusion.
The theoretical lesson is crucial:
Political misinformation can become powerful when it attaches itself to an underlying experience of genuine institutional disconnection.
People may be manipulated, but manipulation works more effectively when there is already a real gap between citizens and institutions.
Page 15 — From political exclusion to democratic alienation
28. Cultural conflict becomes a substitute arena for lost political agency
Page 15 continues the discussion of race, gender, critical race theory and transgender issues in schools. Acemoglu says many Americans came to feel that schools, civil servants, politicians and activists were advancing cultural agendas they opposed.
The deeper theoretical argument is that when people feel excluded from ordinary political decision-making, cultural issues can become the arena through which they attempt to recover political agency.
The conflict therefore cannot be understood merely as disagreement over curriculum.
It is also about the question:
“Who decides the social world in which we live?”
When citizens believe that institutions are imposing values without adequately responding to them, cultural politics becomes a substitute battleground for the larger problem of democratic voice.
29. The European example shows that the problem is not uniquely American
Acemoglu then moves to Europe, particularly Germany. The rise of the AfD is presented as another example of citizens who believe their concerns about immigration and culture are not being adequately represented.
Again, Acemoglu does not endorse the AfD. He calls it a violently anti-immigrant movement and recognises the importance of protecting minorities and immigrants.
But his theoretical point is that excluding a political movement does not necessarily eliminate the grievances that produce support for it.
If millions of citizens feel that their democratic voice has been denied, suppressing the political expression of those grievances may actually deepen the perception of exclusion.
30. Protecting liberal rights and representing popular preferences can come into tension
This is one of the most difficult theoretical problems in the pages.
Democracy must protect minorities and fundamental liberties. At the same time, democracy must remain responsive to citizens.
Therefore, democracy cannot simply say:
“The majority wants X, therefore X must happen.”
Nor can it permanently say:
“Certain popular preferences are unacceptable, therefore they need not be represented.”
Liberal democracy requires a difficult institutional balance between popular responsiveness and constitutional protection of individual rights.
When that balance breaks down, both sides can experience the system as illegitimate: minorities may fear majoritarian domination, while majorities may feel that their preferences are being systematically excluded.
31. The crucial distinction: democracy is still superior, but its performance has deteriorated
Acemoglu is careful not to conclude that authoritarian alternatives are better.
He explicitly says that democracy remains more responsive than other regimes, handles instability better and generally produces better health and education outcomes. He also points to evidence that democracies tend to produce faster economic growth.
This qualification is essential.
His argument is not:
Democracy has failed, therefore authoritarianism is preferable.
His argument is:
Democracy remains the superior political system, but its recent performance has failed to live up to its own historical promise.
That distinction protects the argument from becoming an anti-democratic critique.
32. The final theoretical movement: the failure of democracy's raison d'être
The final paragraph of page 15 contains the deepest conclusion of this entire sequence.
Acemoglu says there are technological and social reasons for democratic underperformance in the postindustrial era, which he will explain later. But these explanations provide little consolation because the raison d'être of democracy—its reason for existing—is the promise of better economic, living and political conditions for the masses.
And that promise has foundered.
This brings us back to the central theoretical structure we began with on page 9.
The theoretical progression from Page 9 to Page 15
What Acemoglu is constructing across these pages can therefore be understood as a progressive separation between formal democracy and lived democracy.
First, democracy historically delivered material improvements: safer work, welfare, health protection, public services and greater political participation.
Second, economic growth became less broadly shared. Wage growth weakened, inequality increased, wealth concentrated and intergenerational mobility declined.
Third, the deterioration moved into public goods. Education spending increased without producing comparable educational outcomes; health expenditure increased without producing comparable health; infrastructure became slower and more expensive.
Fourth, institutional procedures themselves became obstacles to collective action. Regulation, permits, overlapping jurisdictions and endless approvals made government increasingly unable to transform public decisions into timely outcomes.
Fifth, citizens began to experience this institutional incapacity as powerlessness. They could formally participate, but increasingly felt that their participation did not influence government.
Sixth, political representation itself appeared unequal. The preferences of wealthier citizens received greater attention than those of ordinary citizens.
Seventh, when ordinary political channels appeared ineffective, citizens moved their frustrations into cultural, identity and immigration conflicts.
Finally, democracy reached a dangerous paradox: the right to participate remains, but the belief that participation matters begins to disappear.
And this is perhaps the most important conceptual point for your reading:
The deepest democratic crisis does not begin when people lose the formal right to participate. It begins when they lose the lived experience that participation can make a difference.
That is why your formulation—“the fundamental requirement of participation by any mode is sunk”—captures something important, but I would refine it slightly. In Acemoglu's pages 10–15, participation is not literally abolished. Rather, participation is progressively emptied of substantive efficacy. Voting, speaking, protesting, attending meetings, consulting, organising and expressing preferences may all remain available, while the citizen increasingly experiences the system as one in which voice does not become influence, influence does not become decision, and decision does not become effective public outcome.
That is the real drift from democracy as a formal institutional arrangement to democracy as a disappointing lived experience.
From Democratic Promise to Lived Democratic Experience: Participation, Public Goods and the Dissolution of Democratic Agency
Introduction: From Public Concern to Shared Democratic Life
Public concerns, political pressures, activities of pressure groups, voluntary organizations, trade unions, professional associations, civic associations and other forms of collective action provide democratic governments with opportunities to translate social concerns into improvements in public life. These activities are not external to democracy; they are among the principal ways through which a society discovers what its members need, what they fear, what they aspire to change and what they consider to be a common problem. A democratic government therefore receives from society not merely votes but a continuous stream of claims, experiences, demands, criticisms, proposals and collective pressures. Democracy works most meaningfully when these social expressions enter institutions, are deliberated upon, are converted into public decisions and finally return to citizens in the form of improvements that they can experience in their everyday lives. The democratic process is therefore not exhausted by the act of voting; it is a continuing movement from lived experience to public concern, from public concern to political pressure, from political pressure to institutional action and from institutional action back to lived experience.
Democracy works when people experience themselves as participants in governing their shared political world. This experience of participation is phenomenologically important because citizenship is not merely a legal status possessed by an individual; it is also an experience of belonging to a world whose conditions can, at least to some meaningful extent, be influenced through collective action. A person experiences democracy when they can recognise a problem in their surroundings, articulate that problem with others, find an institutional channel through which it can be expressed, observe that the concern has entered public consideration and eventually see some relationship between collective action and public outcome. The experience need not mean that every demand is accepted or that every citizen wins every political contest. It means that citizens can reasonably believe that their concerns are capable of becoming part of the process through which the shared world is governed.
Historically, liberal democracy created precisely such an expectation. Political participation could produce a society in which ordinary citizens became safer, healthier, economically more secure and more capable of influencing government. The improvements in workplace safety, welfare provision, public health, education, social security, labour rights and local political participation that Acemoglu describes are therefore not merely historical achievements; they formed part of the experiential foundation upon which democratic legitimacy was built. Similar promises brought governments to power throughout Western Europe and, in different historical circumstances and through different institutional arrangements, to a significant extent in India as well. Security, health, education, commutation, telecommunication, financial security, housing, public infrastructure and civic voice are all dimensions of a society's shared life, and democracy is expected to create opportunities for citizens to participate in achieving these shared goals rather than merely allowing them to observe governments pursuing them from a distance.
Democracy consequently creates an implicit social contract: when the economy grows, ordinary people should have a reasonable opportunity to share in that growth. Economic growth should therefore not remain merely a statistic describing national production, productivity or aggregate income; it becomes democratically meaningful only when citizens experience its consequences in wages, employment, security, mobility, education, health, housing and the prospects available to their children. When productivity and economic output recover while ordinary people no longer experience comparable material improvement, the connection between economic progress and popular prosperity begins to break down. Liberal democracy had promised not merely political freedom but a better material life and meaningful political participation, and democracy begins to falter when both promises become increasingly difficult to sustain.
It is therefore imperative to understand how the promise of liberal democracy can become separated from lived democratic experience through several connected stages: unequal economic outcomes, deterioration of public goods, declining state capacity, excessive procedural barriers and, finally, the feeling that political participation itself no longer changes what government does. At that point, people may still formally possess the right to participate, but participation loses its substantive meaning because their shared dreams fail to find an effective space within the formation of shared goals. The central theoretical question is consequently not simply whether democracy continues to exist institutionally, but whether citizens continue to experience themselves as effective participants in the creation and maintenance of the world they share.
1. Public Concern as the Beginning of Democratic Agency
The phenomenological starting point of democracy is the experience of a problem as something that matters not only to oneself but potentially to others who inhabit the same world. A dangerous workplace, an inadequate school, an inaccessible hospital, a polluted river, an unreliable road, unaffordable housing or insecure employment initially appears as an individual or local difficulty, but collective recognition can transform it into a public concern. Pressure groups, voluntary organizations, trade unions, community associations and civic movements perform the crucial function of converting dispersed experiences into publicly recognisable claims. The theoretical proposition that follows is that democracy begins not with government action but with the social capacity to make lived experience visible as a matter of common concern.
2. Political Pressure as the Translation of Experience into Public Demand
When individual experiences become collectively articulated, they generate political pressure, and this pressure provides democratic institutions with information about conditions that may otherwise remain invisible to government. The citizen therefore does not merely transmit a preference at election time; the citizen participates in a continuing process of communicating the condition of society. The theoretical proposition is that democratic responsiveness depends upon the capacity of institutions to translate social pressure into public reasoning and public action. Where such translation works, political institutions become connected to the lived world of citizens; where it fails, citizens begin to experience government as distant from the realities they inhabit.
3. Democratic Government as an Institution of Translation
The democratic government has a distinctive responsibility because it possesses the authority and resources to transform collectively articulated concerns into public goods, regulations, rights and services. The phenomenological experience of a functioning democracy therefore occurs when citizens can see some connection between what they collectively raise and what public institutions eventually provide. The theoretical proposition is that democratic legitimacy depends partly upon a successful translation mechanism connecting social experience, political demand, governmental decision and material outcome. Elections alone cannot sustain this legitimacy if the translation mechanism between citizen concern and public result becomes ineffective.
4. Participation as Experience Rather Than Mere Legal Entitlement
A person may possess the legal right to vote, speak, associate, protest or petition without necessarily experiencing themselves as politically effective. The phenomenological distinction is therefore between the possession of participatory rights and the experience of participation as consequential action. The theoretical proposition is that substantive democratic participation exists when formal opportunities for participation are accompanied by a credible possibility that participation can influence collective outcomes. When the possibility of influence disappears, participation survives legally but begins to disappear experientially.
5. The Shared Political World as the Object of Democratic Participation
People participate in democracy because they inhabit a world whose conditions are shared even when their interests within that world differ. Roads, schools, hospitals, public transport, communications systems, financial institutions, environmental conditions, public safety and legal institutions constitute parts of this shared world. The phenomenological experience of citizenship therefore involves recognising that one's own life is embedded in conditions produced collectively. The theoretical proposition is that democracy is fundamentally a mode through which a population attempts to govern the conditions of its shared world rather than merely selecting a temporary group of rulers.
6. The Historical Democratic Promise
The historical development described by Acemoglu demonstrates that democracy acquired legitimacy because participation could produce visible improvements in ordinary life. Workplace safety legislation following public concern over industrial conditions, the expansion of welfare states in Europe, stronger labour institutions and wider access to health and social security demonstrated that political pressure could become material improvement. The theoretical proposition is that democratic legitimacy is historically cumulative: once citizens have experienced democracy as a mechanism capable of producing improvements, those improvements become part of what future citizens reasonably expect democracy to provide.
7. Economic Growth as a Democratic Expectation
The phenomenological experience of economic progress is not simply the perception that national output has increased but the sense that one's own life and the lives of one's children are becoming more secure and capable. The postwar experience of rising wages and broad-based prosperity helped establish an implicit expectation that economic growth should improve ordinary lives. The theoretical proposition is that economic growth becomes a component of democratic legitimacy when its benefits are sufficiently distributed for citizens to recognise themselves as participants in collective prosperity rather than spectators of national wealth.
8. The Separation of Growth from Popular Prosperity
When productivity and aggregate wealth rise while wages for large sections of the population stagnate or decline, citizens experience a contradiction between the language of prosperity and the reality of their own lives. Acemoglu's contrast between wage growth before the mid-1970s and the much slower growth after 1980 illustrates this phenomenon. The theoretical proposition is that democratic legitimacy weakens when economic indicators continue to describe progress while the lived experience of ordinary citizens describes stagnation, because the citizen begins to question whether the economic system represented by democratic government is actually organised for shared prosperity.
9. Inequality as Unequal Experience of the Same Democracy
The growth of inequality means that citizens increasingly inhabit different economic realities within the same political system. Professionals, managers and technically skilled workers may benefit from economic transformation while manual workers and people without college degrees experience declining opportunities. The phenomenological consequence is that democracy ceases to appear as a common economic experience. The theoretical proposition is that extreme inequality can fragment the shared world of citizenship because people increasingly encounter different versions of the same political and economic order.
10. Concentrated Wealth and Unequal Political Capacity
The concentration of income and wealth at the top has implications beyond distribution because wealth provides access to time, information, networks, expertise and political influence. The phenomenological experience of the citizen without such resources can consequently differ sharply from that of an affluent citizen who can organise, lobby, contribute resources and gain direct access to decision-makers. The theoretical proposition is that formal political equality becomes fragile when economic inequality produces systematically unequal capacities to exercise political influence.
11. The Breakdown of the Intergenerational Promise
The American Dream represented a particularly powerful form of democratic expectation because it linked present citizenship with the future prospects of one's children. Acemoglu's comparison between people born in 1940, most of whom earned more than their parents, and those born in the 1980s, among whom roughly half did worse, illustrates the erosion of this expectation. The theoretical proposition is that democracy loses part of its legitimacy when it can no longer credibly sustain the belief that each generation can transmit an improved set of opportunities to the next generation.
12. Future Insecurity as a Democratic Experience
When large numbers of citizens believe that their children will be financially worse off than themselves, the crisis becomes psychological and temporal as well as economic. Citizens no longer experience democracy as a system opening the future; they begin to experience it as a system under which the future is closing. The theoretical proposition is that democratic legitimacy depends not only upon present outcomes but also upon the credibility of a shared future. A society that cannot offer believable improvement to succeeding generations gradually loses the experiential foundation of political optimism.
13. Public Services as Everyday Democracy
The decline of public services demonstrates that democracy is experienced in ordinary encounters with institutions rather than only during elections. A child entering a school, a patient seeking treatment, a commuter travelling to work and a family seeking a home all encounter the state through the quality and accessibility of public systems. The theoretical proposition is that public services constitute an everyday interface between citizens and democracy. When these systems work, democratic government becomes materially present in people's lives; when they fail, democratic institutions become present primarily as obstacles, expenses or disappointments.
14. Education and the Difference Between Provision and Capability
The rise in American educational expenditure alongside deteriorating educational outcomes illustrates the distinction between supplying resources and producing substantive human capability. A school building, a budget or a formal entitlement does not by itself guarantee that a child acquires the ability to read, reason, calculate or participate confidently in society. The theoretical proposition is that democratic provision must be evaluated by the capabilities it creates rather than merely by the resources it allocates. This principle applies equally to India and Europe, where expanding formal access to education does not automatically eliminate differences in the actual quality and capability generated by educational institutions.
15. Health as the Embodied Experience of Democratic Success or Failure
Health provides an especially powerful phenomenological test because institutional success or failure becomes embodied in the citizen. Acemoglu's comparison between American health expenditure and health outcomes shows that enormous expenditure can coexist with inadequate access, preventable deaths and shorter life expectancy. The theoretical proposition is that democracy ultimately becomes credible through the conditions of embodied human existence; when citizens cannot obtain basic healthcare despite enormous collective resources, the distance between institutional capacity and lived welfare becomes visible in the body itself. Similar questions arise in India when citizens encounter sharp differences between sophisticated private healthcare and inadequate or inaccessible public provision.
16. Deaths of Despair and the Loss of Social Belonging
The rise of opioid addiction, alcoholism and mortality among sections of the American population illustrates a form of suffering that cannot be explained merely by the availability of medical treatment. These phenomena indicate deeper experiences of economic insecurity, social dislocation and loss of meaningful prospects. The theoretical proposition is that democratic failure can become visible through forms of despair in which citizens cease to experience themselves as securely located within a society whose institutions offer them meaningful futures. Public health therefore cannot be separated completely from the social and economic conditions through which citizens experience belonging.
17. Infrastructure as Material Evidence of State Capacity
Roads, bridges, railways, water systems and other infrastructure are among the most immediate physical manifestations of collective capacity. When roads deteriorate, repairs take years and public transport becomes unreliable, citizens encounter the declining ability of institutions to maintain their shared environment. The theoretical proposition is that state capacity is not an abstract administrative characteristic; it is materially experienced through the reliability of the infrastructures that organise everyday life. The same principle applies across the United States, Europe and India, even though the institutional causes and levels of provision differ substantially.
18. Comparative Experience and the Loss of Institutional Confidence
Citizens increasingly compare their own public institutions with those of other societies because modern communications make foreign institutional performance visible. Acemoglu's comparison between American infrastructure delays and China's ability to construct bridges rapidly, as well as his observation about Italian trains, demonstrates how comparison can intensify dissatisfaction. The theoretical proposition is that democratic legitimacy is relational as well as internal: citizens evaluate their institutions not only against past expectations but also against visible alternatives elsewhere. When another society appears capable of providing a public good more effectively, domestic institutional shortcomings become more politically salient.
19. The Gap Between Political Intention and Institutional Execution
The Big Dig demonstrates that governments may identify legitimate public needs and possess substantial financial resources while still failing to execute projects efficiently. The phenomenological experience of citizens is therefore shaped not by governmental intention but by the eventual outcome. The theoretical proposition is that democratic performance depends upon the conversion of political intention into institutional execution. A policy promise that never becomes an effective public outcome creates a credibility gap between what democratic institutions announce and what citizens experience.
20. Regulation and the Paradox of Democratic Protection
Regulation is necessary to protect citizens from unsafe products, environmental damage, discrimination and exploitation, but Acemoglu shows how accumulated procedures can also obstruct collective action. The theoretical proposition is not that regulation is inherently anti-democratic; rather, democratic regulation must remain capable of serving the public purpose for which it was created. When protective institutions multiply without coordination, the means of protecting the public can become an obstacle to providing public goods, producing a paradox in which democratic safeguards undermine democratic capacity.
21. Procedural Multiplication and the Dissolution of Agency
The Longfellow Bridge example demonstrates how numerous legitimate approvals, reviews and consultations can collectively produce extraordinary delay. Each individual procedure may appear reasonable, yet their cumulative effect can be dysfunctional. The phenomenological experience of the citizen changes because government no longer appears as a mechanism through which collective action becomes possible; it appears as a sequence of hurdles through which action must struggle. The theoretical proposition is that procedural legitimacy requires proportionality and coordination, because procedures cease to enhance democracy when their accumulation destroys the capacity for collective decision and implementation.
22. Participation Can Become Procedural Without Remaining Effective
This is perhaps the central conceptual point emerging from pages 10–15. A citizen may attend meetings, submit representations, participate in consultations, vote and organise, while still discovering that none of these activities substantially changes the outcome. The theoretical proposition is that participation has two dimensions: procedural participation, in which citizens are given opportunities to express themselves, and substantive participation, in which their expressions possess some meaningful capacity to influence collective outcomes. Democracy begins to lose its lived meaning when procedural participation survives while substantive participation disappears.
23. Housing as the Consequence of Institutional Inability
The housing example demonstrates how institutional complexity can become a direct social crisis. When regulation and administrative barriers make construction excessively costly while population continues to grow, housing scarcity and homelessness can increase. The theoretical proposition is that democratic legitimacy is affected by the consequences of institutional processes even when those processes were created with legitimate intentions. Citizens ultimately experience the housing shortage, not the regulatory justification behind it, and therefore judge the political system according to the conditions in which they are forced to live.
24. The Kafkaesque Transformation of the State
Acemoglu's examples of repairing a faucet, licensing occupations and completing routine public works reveal how citizens can encounter government as an intricate maze of permissions. The theoretical proposition is that when administrative complexity becomes disproportionate to the social problem being addressed, the citizen's relationship with government changes from cooperation to navigation. Instead of experiencing public institutions as extensions of collective agency, citizens experience them as obstacles that must be overcome before ordinary action becomes possible.
25. Self-Enforcing Bureaucracy and Institutional Self-Defeat
The Biden infrastructure example demonstrates a deeper phenomenon in which the rules established by government can impede the very public objectives that government seeks to accomplish. The theoretical proposition is that institutions can become self-defeating when their internal procedures are no longer evaluated against their capacity to achieve the public purposes for which they exist. Democracy then becomes caught in an institutional paradox: government responds to public demands by creating programmes, but the administrative architecture surrounding those programmes prevents them from becoming effective public outcomes.
26. The Decline of Local Democratic Influence
Acemoglu's return to Robert Dahl's New Haven study establishes a historical contrast between an earlier period when ordinary people could exercise meaningful influence over local politics and a later period in which such influence is far less evident. The phenomenological change is from the experience of being a participant in governing one's community to the experience of being a spectator of decisions made elsewhere. The theoretical proposition is that democratic vitality depends upon citizens encountering institutions at a scale and through channels where their participation can plausibly affect decisions.
27. Equal Voting Does Not Guarantee Equal Political Influence
The finding that elected officials respond more closely to the preferences of wealthy constituents than to those of the bottom two-thirds exposes a fundamental distinction between formal and substantive political equality. Every citizen may possess one vote, but citizens do not necessarily possess equal influence over what follows from those votes. The theoretical proposition is that democracy requires not merely equality in the formal act of choosing representatives but sufficient equality in political responsiveness for citizens to believe that their preferences enter the governing process on reasonably equal terms.
28. Political Powerlessness as a Phenomenological Condition
When more than 85 percent of Americans believe that elected officials do not care about what people like them think, the important phenomenon is not simply dissatisfaction with politicians but a collective experience of political irrelevance. A citizen may still be legally free to vote and speak but may cease to believe that these activities matter. The theoretical proposition is that political alienation begins when citizens lose the expectation of efficacy, because the motivational foundation of participation depends upon some belief that participation can influence the world shared with others.
29. The Difference Between Silence and Being Silenced
Citizens can experience themselves as silenced even when they retain freedom of expression. Acemoglu's discussion of immigration and cultural issues illustrates this distinction because citizens may believe that mainstream political institutions refuse to take their concerns seriously even though they can publicly express them. The theoretical proposition is that democratic silencing can be substantive rather than literal: a voice may remain audible in society while becoming ineffective within the institutional process that determines collective decisions. This distinction is essential because it prevents democratic analysis from reducing the problem of voice to censorship alone.
30. Cultural Conflict as a Displacement of Political Agency
When citizens feel that economic and political institutions do not respond to their concerns, cultural conflicts surrounding immigration, race, gender, education and identity can become substitute arenas through which political agency is sought. Acemoglu's discussion of American and European developments illustrates how these conflicts can become intensified by misinformation while still drawing upon underlying experiences of exclusion. The theoretical proposition is that political movements often become powerful not merely because they create grievances but because they attach themselves to pre-existing experiences of institutional disconnection. Manipulation can therefore intensify a genuine democratic deficit rather than create every element of the deficit from nothing.
31. The Liberal Democratic Paradox of Representation and Rights
The European discussion, particularly the German example, reveals a difficult tension between protecting minorities and maintaining responsiveness to citizens who hold controversial preferences. Liberal democracy cannot simply transform every majority preference into policy because constitutional rights and equal citizenship must protect individuals and minorities; yet it cannot permanently dismiss substantial sections of the population without creating a perception that democratic representation is selectively available. The theoretical proposition is that liberal democracy requires institutions capable of simultaneously protecting fundamental rights and maintaining meaningful channels through which unpopular or politically inconvenient concerns can be represented, debated and transformed rather than simply excluded.
32. From Participation to Alienation: When Voice No Longer Becomes Agency
The final theoretical conclusion of pages 10–15 is that the democratic crisis reaches its most serious stage when the chain connecting participation to agency breaks apart. Economic inequality separates citizens from the benefits of growth; declining public goods separate citizens from the material achievements expected of government; declining state capacity separates governmental intention from implementation; excessive procedures separate public decisions from timely outcomes; and unequal political responsiveness separates citizens' preferences from governmental decisions. At the end of this sequence, citizens may still possess the formal right to participate, but they no longer experience participation as a meaningful form of collective agency. The theoretical proposition is therefore that the deepest crisis of democracy is not the disappearance of the right to participate but the disappearance of the lived belief that participation can alter the shared world.
The General Theory: From Democratic Participation to Democratic Alienation
Taken together, these thirty-two points suggest that the crisis described by Acemoglu should not be understood simply as a decline in voter turnout, an increase in populism, a rise of misinformation or a loss of trust in politicians. Those are visible manifestations of a deeper phenomenological transformation. The citizen originally experiences a shared problem, recognises others who experience it, joins or creates a collective expression of concern, brings that concern into public institutions, observes governmental deliberation, receives an institutional response and finally experiences some improvement in the shared world. This sequence creates a sense of agency because the citizen can perceive a relationship between experience, participation, institution and outcome.
The democratic crisis develops when each link in that sequence becomes weaker. Economic inequality means that citizens do not participate from comparable material positions. Declining public services mean that institutional action produces less visible improvement. Administrative complexity means that political decisions take longer to become material outcomes. Unequal political responsiveness means that some preferences travel more effectively through institutions than others. Cultural polarisation then provides alternative forms of political identification through which citizens attempt to recover a sense of agency. Eventually, the citizen can arrive at the most corrosive democratic conclusion: “I am permitted to participate, but my participation does not materially alter the world in which I live.”
This conclusion can apply, in different forms and with very different historical conditions, to the United States, Europe and India. The institutional structures, levels of economic development, social inequalities and histories of citizenship are not identical, and therefore the empirical manifestations cannot simply be equated. Yet the theoretical question is common. In the United States, the problem may appear through stagnant wages, inequality, inadequate public services, infrastructure delays and perceived political capture. In Europe, it can appear through concerns about immigration, cultural representation, bureaucratic complexity and the perceived distance between citizens and European or national institutions. In India, the question can arise through unequal access to education, health, housing, employment, transport, digital connectivity, financial security and administrative justice, as well as through the varying capacity of citizens and voluntary organisations to make local concerns visible to institutions. In each case, however, the decisive question is not whether citizens possess formal democratic rights but whether those rights enable them to participate meaningfully in the production of the conditions under which their shared lives unfold.
The theory therefore reaches beyond the conventional distinction between democracy and authoritarianism. A society can remain constitutionally democratic while its citizens gradually experience a decline in substantive democratic agency. Elections may continue, legislatures may function, political parties may compete, courts may operate and citizens may retain extensive freedoms, yet the lived experience of citizenship can become increasingly passive if economic structures, public-service failures, institutional incapacity and unequal responsiveness prevent participation from becoming effective collective action. Democracy then becomes formally present but phenomenologically distant.
The ultimate issue is therefore the relationship between participation and shared goals. Security, health, education, communication, transportation, financial security, housing, dignity and civic voice are not merely separate policy sectors. They are dimensions through which citizens experience whether they belong to a society capable of governing its shared world. If democratic participation repeatedly fails to influence the achievement of these shared goals, citizens may gradually stop seeing themselves as co-authors of the public world. They become observers, complainants, consumers of government services or opponents of government rather than participants in collective self-government.
This is why the deterioration described by Acemoglu is ultimately more serious than a simple decline in governmental efficiency. Efficiency concerns how quickly an institution produces an outcome; democratic agency concerns whether people can experience themselves as participants in determining the outcome at all. A democracy can therefore be administratively imperfect and remain democratically alive if citizens believe that their participation matters and that institutions can respond and correct themselves. Conversely, a democracy can retain extensive formal procedures while becoming democratically fragile if citizens repeatedly experience a gap between what they collectively express and what institutions actually do.
The deepest theoretical proposition emerging from pages 9–15 is consequently this: liberal democracy survives not merely through institutions that permit participation but through a continuing lived relationship in which citizens can recognise their own concerns, activities and collective efforts in the changing conditions of their shared world. Once that relationship weakens, the democratic citizen begins to experience a separation between the world they inhabit, the goals they share with others, the institutions that supposedly govern that world and the outcomes those institutions produce. The resulting condition is democratic alienation, because the citizen remains formally included within democracy while becoming experientially separated from the power to shape the common world.
In this sense, the movement from democratic promise to broken promise is ultimately a movement from participation to ineffective participation, from ineffective participation to frustration, from frustration to political alienation and from political alienation to the search for alternative forms of agency. The central danger is therefore not that citizens suddenly stop caring about democracy. It is that they continue to care deeply about the conditions of their lives while increasingly believing that democratic participation is incapable of changing those conditions. At that point, the crisis is no longer merely a crisis of government performance; it becomes a crisis of the citizen's relationship with the shared world itself.
You are right. I had started from the first paragraph of page 17, whereas your requested unit is the argument beginning on page 16 and continuing into the first paragraph of page 17, ending with “liberal philosophies.” That entire passage should be treated as one continuous argument.
Has Liberalism Failed Because It Has Succeeded?
Pages 16–17: From the success of liberal democracy to its present crisis
The central argument of these two pages is that what we are witnessing is not simply a failure of democracy, but a crisis of liberal democracy specifically. Acemoglu begins by reminding us that liberal democracy had made promises that were unusually concrete: it promised not only political freedom and democratic participation but also shared prosperity, public services, and a free political voice. For a considerable period, particularly in the postwar era, liberal democracy actually delivered many of these things. This is important because Acemoglu does not begin his explanation by saying that liberal democracy was always defective or that its promises were always empty. His starting point is almost the opposite: liberal democracy had genuine historical successes, and precisely because it succeeded, the nature of its present failure becomes more complicated.
1. Why the crisis is a crisis of liberal democracy, not democracy alone
Acemoglu makes a distinction between democracy in the broad sense and liberal democracy as a particular combination of democratic government and liberal principles. Democracy provides the possibility that citizens can participate in governing themselves, while liberalism adds commitments to individual freedom, political voice, constraints on power, equality before the law, and protection against arbitrary authority. Acemoglu's concern is that the current breakdown cannot be understood simply as people becoming dissatisfied with elections or democratic procedures. The deeper problem is that the political system that once connected political participation, individual freedom, public services, and broadly shared economic advancement is no longer functioning in the same way.
A useful real-world example is the difference between merely having elections and having a political order in which citizens also experience meaningful political voice and economic inclusion. A country may continue to hold competitive elections while large sections of its population feel that government decisions are increasingly shaped by wealthy interests, professional elites, bureaucratic institutions, or highly educated groups that are socially distant from them. In such a situation, democracy in the narrow procedural sense may survive, while the broader liberal-democratic promise of voice, freedom, and shared prosperity becomes weaker.
2. Patrick Deneen's paradox: “liberalism has failed because it has succeeded”
Acemoglu then introduces Patrick Deneen's famous formulation from Why Liberalism Failed: “Liberalism has failed—not because it fell short, but because it was true to itself. It has failed because it has succeeded.” Acemoglu immediately clarifies that Deneen is not using “success” in the ordinary sense of asking whether liberalism produced good social or economic outcomes. Deneen's claim is instead that liberalism succeeded in imposing its values upon society. In other words, liberalism transformed society so deeply that the consequences of that transformation eventually produced conditions in which liberalism itself could be attacked.
This is a paradox worth understanding carefully. If a political philosophy succeeds in changing society according to its own principles, the society that results may be very different from the society in which that philosophy originally emerged. Liberalism helped expand individual choice, individual rights, markets, education, mobility, and freedom from traditional forms of authority. But once those principles became deeply embedded in society, they also altered communities, social relationships, economic structures, and political identities. Deneen therefore interprets liberalism's present difficulties as the consequences of its own success.
Acemoglu, however, does not accept Deneen's diagnosis as sufficient. His interest is not in proving that liberalism destroyed society simply by succeeding. Instead, he wants to understand what actually changed inside liberal democracy and why those changes have produced today's crisis.
3. The rise of antiliberal explanations
Acemoglu observes that Deneen was neither the first nor the last right-wing critic to condemn the entire liberal project. What is especially significant for Acemoglu is that these criticisms became increasingly influential during the last two decades, at precisely the time when dissatisfaction with liberal democracy was growing. Older ideas that had once been marginal or largely forgotten began to reappear in new forms, including ethnocentric conceptions of politics, authoritarianism, and monarchism.
The important point is that political dissatisfaction does not automatically produce a liberal reform movement. When citizens become convinced that the existing liberal order has failed them, they may become receptive to alternatives that promise stronger authority, greater national or ethnic unity, or a rejection of liberal constraints altogether. The rise of populist and authoritarian movements in several democracies can therefore be understood as part of the larger crisis Acemoglu is investigating.
For example, the political transformation of Hungary under Viktor Orbán illustrates how dissatisfaction with liberal institutions can be converted into a political argument for a different conception of democracy, one in which national identity and strong executive authority are given greater importance while liberal checks and pluralistic constraints become weaker. The example is useful because it shows that the crisis of liberal democracy is not simply an intellectual debate among philosophers; it can become a transformation of actual political institutions.
4. Why Acemoglu rejects both the antiliberal diagnosis and the liberal self-defence
Acemoglu then makes a particularly important claim: the antiliberal alternatives have not correctly diagnosed what has gone wrong, but neither have liberals themselves. This means that he is positioning his argument between two inadequate explanations. The antiliberals are wrong if they interpret every contemporary problem as evidence that liberalism itself was fundamentally misguided, while liberals are also inadequate if they simply defend the existing liberal order without asking why it has stopped delivering what it once delivered.
This matters because diagnosis comes before prescription. If we misunderstand the cause of the crisis, we cannot know whether liberal democracy can be repaired, whether it has suffered only a temporary injury, or whether its institutional foundations have been permanently damaged. Acemoglu therefore says that without a correct diagnosis it is impossible to determine whether liberalism and liberal democracy are “permanently maimed”, and it is equally impossible to formulate a convincing way for liberalism to renew itself.
A real-world analogy would be a failing institution whose members argue either that the institution itself should be abolished or that nothing fundamental is wrong and only its critics are mistaken. Neither position necessarily explains the actual mechanism of failure. Acemoglu is looking for something more demanding: he wants to identify what changed, why the previous system worked better, and why the existing political order failed to adapt.
5. Liberalism “started strong”
Acemoglu's own thesis begins with the assertion that liberalism started strong. He is deliberately resisting the idea that liberalism was merely an ideological project that never worked in practice. According to him, liberalism gradually succeeded in putting its ideals into practice, initially indirectly, when other political actors responded to liberal aspirations, and later directly, when liberals themselves acquired political power and constructed liberal democratic institutions.
This distinction between the indirect and direct realization of liberal ideals is important. Liberal ideas did not necessarily become influential because liberal thinkers immediately controlled governments. Their principles could influence political developments by changing what citizens demanded, by challenging arbitrary authority, by encouraging movements for political rights, or by forcing existing regimes to respond to demands for greater freedom and equality. Eventually, however, liberal principles became embodied in actual democratic institutions, laws, rights, and public policies.
The historical experience of the expansion of political rights provides a useful illustration. The gradual extension of voting rights, freedom of expression, equality before the law, labour protections, and representative institutions did not occur through one single liberal government suddenly implementing a complete philosophical programme. Different political movements and institutions pushed, resisted, modified, and eventually incorporated these principles into political life. Liberalism therefore became successful not merely as an idea but as an institutional reality.
6. Success produced establishment liberalism
But the very success of liberalism created a new problem. Once liberalism had become broadly accepted, it ceased to be merely a challenging political movement and became the establishment. Acemoglu says that it became embraced by most politicians, bureaucrats, and activists.
This transformation is crucial. A movement that begins by challenging existing power has a different relationship with society from an ideology that becomes the dominant framework of government and public institutions. When liberalism was struggling against arbitrary rulers, authoritarian power, and concentrated economic privilege, its political energy came partly from opposition. Once liberalism became embedded in government, bureaucracy, universities, civil society, and economic institutions, it had to confront a different question: how should liberal principles operate when liberalism itself has become powerful?
Acemoglu argues that establishment liberalism did not adequately adjust to new realities. The world changed, particularly with the transition from an industrial to a postindustrial economy, but the liberal establishment did not sufficiently reconsider how its institutions and policies should respond to those changes. This is the beginning of the causal chain that will occupy the rest of the chapter.
7. “Liberals lost the plot”
Acemoglu's phrase that “liberals lost the plot” is particularly significant because it is not merely an accusation of policy incompetence. He adds that liberals lost some of liberalism's values along with it.
The metaphor of “losing the plot” means losing sight of the larger purpose of the political project. Liberalism had once been connected with a broader democratic project in which individual freedom existed alongside political voice, self-government, social cooperation, and shared prosperity. When liberalism became establishment ideology, some of its representatives increasingly focused on particular dimensions of liberalism while losing sight of the larger political and social purposes that had made liberal democracy successful.
This is why Acemoglu's argument should not be reduced to “liberalism became too economically liberal” or “liberalism became too elitist.” His argument is broader. Liberalism became detached from some of the values that had previously connected liberal freedom to democratic participation and collective prosperity.
8. The postindustrial economy changes the conditions of liberal democracy
Acemoglu then identifies one of the major forces behind this derailment: the postindustrial economy made it much harder for liberal democracy to deliver on its promises.
This is a major turning point because Acemoglu is not claiming that the political failure happened independently of economic transformation. The industrial economy had provided a relatively favourable environment for liberal democracy because economic growth generated large-scale employment, workers could organize collectively, wages could rise, and democratic governments could use taxation and public institutions to provide social protection and public services. The emerging postindustrial economy disrupted many of those relationships.
The later pages explain that digital technologies increased the demand for highly educated and cognitively skilled workers, while automation reduced demand for many manual skills. Globalization and offshoring further weakened parts of traditional manufacturing. Thus, the economic foundation that had helped connect growth with mass employment and mass prosperity became much less reliable.
A contemporary example can be seen in the contrast between a technology-intensive metropolitan economy and a declining manufacturing town. The metropolitan economy may generate enormous wealth through software, finance, biotechnology, professional services, and highly skilled employment, while a town whose economic life once depended on a factory may experience plant closures, declining wages, population loss, and weakening local institutions. The national economy may still be growing, but the connection between economic growth and the material security of ordinary citizens becomes much weaker.
9. The educated segment becomes more dominant
The second part of Acemoglu's causal explanation is that liberalism itself changed as the college-educated segment of society became more dominant. This is where economic transformation and political transformation begin to reinforce each other. The new economy increasingly rewarded education and cognitive skills, and consequently people possessing those skills became more economically valuable and socially influential.
This is not simply a story about people acquiring degrees. It is a story about the changing distribution of social power. When the economy increasingly depends upon specialized knowledge, those who possess that knowledge gain greater influence over companies, government agencies, universities, media organizations, professional institutions, and civil society. The educated become not merely one social group among others but increasingly occupy the commanding positions through which society is organized.
The later discussion on page 23 makes this development explicit by showing how the number of college graduates expanded dramatically and how college-educated experts came to occupy critical positions in management, government, education, health, media, and nongovernmental organizations. The passage on pages 16–17 is therefore laying the foundation for that later analysis.
10. The political consequence: the problems of the less educated receive less attention
Once the educated segment became more dominant, Acemoglu argues, liberal democracies became less likely to seek solutions to the postindustrial challenges that heavily afflicted the less educated. This is what he calls the “sin of omission.”
The crucial causal connection is therefore this: the economy changed; the educated became more socially and politically powerful; and the political system became less responsive to the problems disproportionately experienced by those who did not benefit from the new economy. The omission is not simply that politicians forgot one particular policy. It represents a broader failure of political responsiveness.
For example, if automation destroys a large number of routine manufacturing jobs, a liberal-democratic government has several possible responses. It can invest in education and retraining, strengthen labour institutions, support affected communities, provide social insurance, encourage new industries in declining regions, or create new mechanisms through which affected workers participate in economic decision-making. If those responses are weak while policy remains heavily oriented toward the interests and assumptions of the rapidly expanding knowledge economy, the less educated can experience the political system as increasingly distant from their lives.
11. The second failure: the “sin of commission”
But Acemoglu does not stop at saying that liberal democracy failed to respond adequately. He identifies a second and deeper failure, which he calls the “sin of commission.” Here the educated elite did not merely fail to address the problems of others; they abandoned important principles of liberalism themselves. Acemoglu identifies three particularly important principles: self-government, community, and shared prosperity.
This distinction is essential. The sin of omission means that something necessary was not done. The sin of commission means that something politically or philosophically damaging was done. Acemoglu therefore sees two simultaneous developments: liberal democracy became less responsive to the less educated, while influential educated elites increasingly moved away from some of the values that had previously made liberal democracy successful.
The two failures can reinforce each other. If educated elites become less concerned with shared prosperity and community, they may also become less motivated to develop institutions that respond to people who are losing economic security. Conversely, if institutions increasingly serve the interests and assumptions of the educated elite, those institutions can further strengthen the dominance of that group.
12. Self-government, community, and shared prosperity as the lost connection
The three values named by Acemoglu are especially important because together they describe a conception of liberal democracy that is much richer than simply individual freedom plus elections. Self-government means that citizens should participate meaningfully in governing their common political world. Community means that citizens should understand themselves as connected through social relationships and shared institutions rather than merely as isolated individuals pursuing private interests. Shared prosperity means that economic development should create sufficiently broad benefits to maintain both social inclusion and democratic legitimacy.
Consider a society in which citizens formally possess equal voting rights but where important decisions are increasingly made by professional experts, where people move away from declining communities because economic opportunity is concentrated elsewhere, and where economic growth disproportionately benefits those with highly specialized education. Such a society may retain the formal institutions of liberal democracy while losing some of the social substance that makes democratic citizenship meaningful. This is the problem Acemoglu is beginning to identify.
13. From a political movement to institutions and philosophies
The final sentence of the paragraph brings the entire argument together. Acemoglu says that although these two sins may have begun with liberalism as a political movement, they eventually affected liberal democratic institutions and liberal philosophies as well.
This means that Acemoglu is tracing a movement from ideas and political actors → social and economic transformation → changing political power → institutional change → transformation of political philosophy itself. What begins as a failure among political actors can eventually become embedded in the institutions through which democracy operates and in the ideas through which people understand what liberalism is supposed to mean.
This is why the passage from page 16 through the first paragraph of page 17 is so important for the whole chapter. Acemoglu is not yet giving the complete explanation of the crisis. Rather, he is establishing the framework of explanation that the following pages will develop. The old liberal-democratic model had achieved genuine success under industrial conditions. The economic environment then changed. The educated population became increasingly dominant. Liberalism became establishment liberalism. The political system became less responsive to those most damaged by the transformation. At the same time, influential educated elites increasingly detached liberalism from self-government, community, and shared prosperity. The result was that the failures became embedded not merely in political behaviour but also in liberal-democratic institutions and liberal philosophies.
The central chain of argument across pages 16–17
The entire passage can therefore be read as one continuous causal sequence rather than as several unrelated observations. Liberal democracy initially succeeded because liberal ideals were translated into institutions that provided political voice, public services, and shared prosperity. Liberalism then became established and widely accepted. Meanwhile, the economy moved from an industrial to a postindustrial structure, making the old democratic bargain much harder to sustain. The college-educated became increasingly dominant economically and politically, while many less-educated citizens became more vulnerable to the new economic transformation. Liberal democracies consequently became less responsive to the problems of these groups, producing the “sin of omission.” At the same time, sections of the educated elite abandoned the commitments to self-government, community, and shared prosperity that had been central to liberalism's earlier success, producing the “sin of commission.” These two failures eventually reached liberal democratic institutions and liberal philosophies themselves. That is the complete argument running from page 16 into the first paragraph of page 17.
In one deeper formulation, Acemoglu is asking us to confront a paradox: liberal democracy is now in crisis not because it never worked, but because a system that once successfully connected freedom, democratic voice, economic growth, public provision, and shared prosperity became an established system that failed to adapt when the economic and social conditions underlying that success changed. The crisis therefore requires neither a simple rejection of liberalism nor a simple defence of the existing liberal order; it requires understanding what was lost when liberalism itself became established.
WHEN LIBERAL DEMOCRACY LOSES ITS SOCIAL PURPOSE
Economic Transformation, Educated Elites, Political Disconnection, and the Crisis of Shared Prosperity
1. Introduction: The crisis is deeper than the failure of elections
The contemporary crisis of liberal democracy cannot be understood simply as a decline in elections, political parties, or constitutional institutions, because a democracy may continue to conduct elections while becoming progressively less capable of giving citizens a meaningful experience of political voice, equal citizenship, social belonging, and shared prosperity. Liberal democracy historically acquired its legitimacy from a broader promise in which political freedom was connected with the ability of ordinary people to participate in governing their common world, while economic development, public services, social protection, and legal equality provided the material conditions under which that participation could become meaningful. The present crisis emerges when these connections begin to break apart, because citizens may continue to possess formal political rights while increasingly experiencing the economy, the state, and public institutions as systems over which they have little influence and from whose benefits they are increasingly separated.
The problem is therefore not that liberal democracy has simply stopped functioning in a mechanical sense. The deeper problem is that the social contract connecting freedom, political voice, economic opportunity, public provision, and shared prosperity has weakened. A political system can preserve the outward structure of democratic government while losing the substantive relationship through which citizens understand themselves as participants in a common political order. This distinction becomes particularly important when economic transformation produces very different experiences for different sections of society, because a society in which some groups experience technological and economic progress as liberation while others experience the same transformation as insecurity, displacement, and loss can gradually develop a crisis of democratic legitimacy.
2. Liberal democracy originally represented a broad promise
The historical strength of liberal democracy rested partly on the fact that it offered more than protection from arbitrary government. It promised that people would possess a political voice, that power would be constrained, that individuals would enjoy important freedoms, that the law would apply equally, and that economic progress could eventually be converted into a broadly shared improvement in living conditions. The significance of this historical promise lies in the connection among these elements, because freedom without political voice can become merely formal, political voice without economic security can become difficult to exercise effectively, and economic growth without social inclusion can generate wealth without producing a stable democratic community.
The postwar development of many Western democracies provides a powerful illustration of this broader bargain. Industrial expansion created employment on a large scale, labour organizations acquired bargaining power, governments developed social insurance systems, public education and health provision expanded, and democratic institutions increasingly incorporated working-class interests into political decision-making. The resulting system was far from perfect, and large exclusions remained, particularly in relation to race, gender, colonial populations, and other marginalized groups, but the general direction demonstrated that economic growth and democratic inclusion could reinforce each other when institutions were deliberately constructed to connect them.
The important lesson is that democracy became legitimate not merely because people could vote but because political participation could be connected to improvements in everyday life. When citizens could see that their political organization helped produce safer workplaces, better wages, public education, health services, infrastructure, social insurance, and greater equality before the law, democracy acquired a practical meaning in their lives.
3. The paradox of success
There is a profound paradox at the centre of the contemporary crisis, because a political philosophy can become a victim of its own success when the society it helped create becomes fundamentally different from the society in which it originally developed. Liberal ideas contributed to the expansion of individual freedom, personal choice, education, mobility, markets, legal equality, and limitations on arbitrary authority. As these principles became increasingly institutionalized, they transformed social relationships and economic structures. The resulting society became more individualistic, more educated, more mobile, more technologically sophisticated, and more dependent upon specialized knowledge.
The paradox becomes visible when the institutions created under one set of historical conditions continue operating after those conditions have changed. A system that worked well when large numbers of workers were employed together in factories, organized collectively, and shared relatively similar economic experiences may not automatically work equally well when production becomes automated, employment becomes more individualized, communities become geographically fragmented, and highly educated specialists occupy an increasing proportion of influential positions. Success can therefore create new circumstances that require institutional adaptation, and failure to adapt can eventually turn yesterday's strengths into today's weaknesses.
This does not mean that liberalism necessarily destroys itself through success. Rather, it means that successful political institutions must continually reinterpret their principles in response to changing social realities. When they fail to do so, their historical achievements may become insufficient for the new world they helped create.
4. From a challenging movement to an establishment
A political philosophy behaves differently when it is challenging established power from the way it behaves when it becomes established power itself. Liberalism historically gained much of its political energy from resistance to arbitrary rulers, inherited privilege, religious coercion, unchecked economic power, and other forms of domination. Once liberal principles became embedded in constitutions, governments, bureaucracies, universities, courts, markets, civil society organizations, and political parties, liberalism acquired a new responsibility because it now had to answer not only the question of how power should be restrained but also the question of how power should be exercised responsibly when liberal institutions themselves possess considerable authority.
This transition from opposition to establishment creates a danger of complacency. A movement that once asked whether ordinary people possessed sufficient voice may eventually become more concerned with administering existing institutions than with asking whether those institutions remain responsive to ordinary citizens. A movement that once challenged concentrated power may become comfortable with new concentrations of expertise, professional authority, economic wealth, and institutional influence if those concentrations emerge within formally liberal structures.
This is one of the deepest problems in contemporary liberal democracy, because being liberal does not automatically prevent a liberal institution from becoming socially distant. A government can remain committed to civil liberties while becoming increasingly remote from the material concerns of particular communities. A university can defend intellectual freedom while becoming socially detached from citizens who do not participate in its educational culture. A media organization can support freedom of expression while becoming increasingly disconnected from the experiences of people outside its professional and educational environment. The preservation of liberal principles therefore requires continuous democratic self-examination.
5. The transformation from industrial to postindustrial society
The economic transformation from an industrial to a postindustrial society fundamentally altered the conditions under which the earlier democratic bargain had operated. Industrial production required enormous numbers of workers in factories, transportation systems, offices, warehouses, construction, and related occupations. When demand for labour was high, workers acquired greater bargaining power, and when workers were concentrated together geographically and occupationally, they could organize collectively. Economic growth could therefore translate relatively directly into employment, wages, worker organization, and political influence.
The postindustrial economy changed this relationship. Digital technologies increased the value of specialized knowledge and cognitive skills, while automation reduced the demand for many forms of routine manual labour. Globalization and offshoring further transformed manufacturing employment, while services, administration, education, health, technology, finance, and professional occupations became increasingly important. The result was not simply that some industries disappeared and others appeared; the social structure of economic power itself changed.
The contrast can be seen in the difference between an industrial city organized around large factories and a contemporary technology-oriented metropolitan region. In the industrial city, thousands of workers may have shared similar working conditions, belonged to the same unions, lived in neighbouring communities, and possessed a common economic interest. In the contemporary knowledge economy, highly skilled workers may be dispersed across specialized occupations and may have very different relationships to capital, employers, and public institutions. The social basis for collective political organization therefore becomes more complicated.
6. When economic growth stops producing shared prosperity automatically
During the industrial era, economic growth often generated a relatively visible pathway toward broader prosperity because expanding production required large numbers of workers. When firms expanded production, they needed more employees, and when labour demand increased, wages could rise, particularly when workers possessed strong organizations capable of bargaining over the distribution of economic gains. The relationship was never automatic, but democratic institutions, labour movements, regulation, taxation, and social policy could reinforce it.
The digital economy weakened this pathway. A highly productive company can now generate enormous economic value without employing anything close to the number of workers that a comparable industrial enterprise once required. A software company, automated factory, financial platform, or technology enterprise may create enormous output with relatively small numbers of highly skilled employees. Productivity can therefore increase without producing proportional increases in mass employment or bargaining power.
The practical consequence is that economic growth and mass prosperity can become separated. A country's economy may expand while many communities experience stagnant wages, insecure employment, declining industrial opportunities, or reduced prospects for their children. This creates a particularly dangerous political condition because national economic statistics can indicate success while individual citizens experience economic decline. When citizens hear that the economy is progressing but cannot see that progress reflected in their own lives or communities, they may conclude that the political system is serving someone else.
7. The rise of the educated society
The transformation of the economy simultaneously increased the social importance of education. As production became more dependent upon information, technology, specialized knowledge, administration, and cognitive skills, educational qualifications became increasingly valuable. People with advanced skills could enter expanding sectors, command higher salaries, and occupy influential positions in corporations, government agencies, universities, media organizations, professional associations, and civil society.
This development produced enormous benefits. The expansion of higher education opened opportunities that had previously been restricted to much smaller sections of society, while scientific, technological, medical, legal, and administrative expertise became essential for managing increasingly complex societies. The problem therefore does not lie in education itself. The problem arises when educational advantage becomes simultaneously an economic advantage, a social advantage, and a political advantage, thereby allowing one increasingly influential social group to acquire disproportionate influence over the direction of public life.
The transformation of the United States provides an especially clear illustration. Over the second half of the twentieth century, higher education expanded enormously, and college graduates increasingly occupied positions in management, government, professional services, technology, education, health, media, and other influential sectors. This created a society in which educational attainment became strongly connected with occupational position, income, cultural influence, and political outlook. The growth of education was therefore not merely an educational phenomenon; it altered the distribution of social power.
8. The emergence of an educated elite
The phrase “educated elite” should not be understood simply as meaning that every college graduate is rich or politically powerful, because the educated population itself is internally divided. Some graduates possess highly specialized and highly rewarded skills, while others have ordinary professional occupations and may themselves experience economic insecurity. Nevertheless, the expansion of higher education means that people with educational credentials increasingly occupy many of the institutional positions through which modern society makes decisions.
Managers, administrators, lawyers, academics, doctors, engineers, technology professionals, journalists, policy specialists, civil servants, consultants, and other highly educated professionals often possess influence that is not captured merely by their personal income. Their influence comes from their institutional location. They participate in designing policies, managing organizations, interpreting information, producing public narratives, and deciding which problems deserve institutional attention.
This creates a new democratic challenge because a society can become formally more educated while simultaneously becoming less politically balanced if educational groups acquire disproportionate control over the institutions through which public priorities are defined.
9. The sin of omission: when democracy fails to respond
The first major failure occurs when the political system does not adequately respond to the people most affected by economic transformation. This is the problem of omission, because the failure lies partly in what government and democratic institutions do not do. When automation, deindustrialization, globalization, or technological change damages particular occupations and communities, democracy has to create new mechanisms for adjustment. If it simply allows the transformation to proceed while concentrating public attention on the sectors that are succeeding, those who are losing from the transformation may gradually disappear from the centre of political concern.
The omission can take many forms, including insufficient investment in declining regions, inadequate worker retraining, weak labour institutions, limited social protection, poor access to education, inadequate public transportation, insufficient health services, and the absence of meaningful mechanisms through which affected communities can participate in economic restructuring. Each individual failure may appear technical or administrative, but together they can produce a profound political message: the system sees the winners of economic transformation more clearly than it sees the losers.
The decline of manufacturing regions in parts of the United States and Europe demonstrates this problem. Communities that had once been central to national economic life could experience factory closures, population decline, weakened local businesses, and declining social institutions. Meanwhile, political attention increasingly focused on metropolitan centres associated with technology, finance, higher education, and professional services. Even when governments did not deliberately intend to abandon these communities, the cumulative experience could still be one of abandonment.
10. Omission becomes alienation
When economic exclusion is combined with political invisibility, dissatisfaction can become democratic alienation. A person who loses employment may initially think that the problem is economic, but if they repeatedly discover that their concerns receive little political response, the conclusion can become broader: perhaps the political system itself no longer represents people like them. The emotional transition from “the economy is failing me” to “democracy does not hear me” is therefore politically significant.
This helps explain why economic grievances can eventually become cultural and political grievances. Citizens who experience declining economic security may begin to question not only economic policy but also the institutions, experts, media organizations, political parties, and cultural elites associated with the existing order. Political anger can then become directed toward “the establishment” as a whole.
The danger is especially high when citizens perceive that the same people who benefit from the new economic system are also the people who design, interpret, and defend it. In such circumstances, economic inequality can become intertwined with epistemic inequality, because some citizens feel not only that they have less wealth but also that their understanding of reality is dismissed by people who possess greater educational and institutional authority.
11. The sin of commission: when liberalism abandons its own purposes
The second failure is more profound because it concerns not merely what democratic institutions failed to do but what influential sections of the liberal order increasingly ceased to value. The three principles of self-government, community, and shared prosperity are especially important because they connect liberal freedom to democratic citizenship.
Self-government means that citizens should not merely be governed efficiently; they should have meaningful opportunities to participate in determining the conditions under which they live. Community means that citizens should not be understood merely as isolated individuals competing for personal advancement, because democracy requires relationships of mutual recognition, trust, responsibility, and shared belonging. Shared prosperity means that economic development should create opportunities and security sufficiently broadly distributed to prevent democracy from becoming a political system in which some citizens continually advance while others experience permanent decline.
When these principles weaken, liberalism can become excessively identified with individual choice, market opportunity, professional expertise, and procedural rights while losing sight of the social conditions required to make those freedoms meaningful to everyone.
12. The weakening of self-government through excessive reliance on expertise
Modern societies unquestionably require expertise. Climate policy, public health, financial regulation, artificial intelligence, infrastructure, energy systems, monetary policy, and many other areas involve technical questions that cannot be resolved through popular opinion alone. The democratic problem begins when technical expertise is allowed to substitute for democratic participation rather than being placed within a democratic framework.
A technically competent expert may know more about a particular policy instrument than an ordinary citizen, but that does not mean the expert possesses a superior democratic authority to decide what kind of society citizens should live in. There is a fundamental difference between knowing how to achieve a particular objective and deciding whether that objective should be pursued.
Consider the redevelopment of an industrial region. Experts may be able to calculate that an old factory is economically inefficient and that resources should be redirected toward services and technology. Yet the people living in that region have legitimate questions that cannot be answered by economic efficiency alone. They may ask what happens to their community, their local institutions, their occupational identity, their children's prospects, and their ability to remain where their families have lived for generations. Self-government requires that these questions enter the political process rather than being treated as irrational obstacles to modernization.
13. Community and the erosion of the shared social world
Community becomes especially important when economic transformation produces geographical and social separation. Highly educated young people often possess greater geographical mobility because their skills are transferable across regions and countries. They can move toward universities, technology centres, financial centres, or other places where opportunities are concentrated. Such mobility can be liberating at the individual level, but when large numbers of talented people leave declining communities, those communities can lose not only population but also institutional capacity and social leadership.
The result can be a widening distance between prosperous metropolitan centres and declining towns. One part of the country may become associated with universities, innovation, international connections, cultural diversity, and professional employment, while another becomes associated with industrial decline, unemployment, demographic ageing, and political resentment. The two groups may continue to live under the same constitution and vote in the same national elections, yet their everyday experiences of society become increasingly different.
This creates a danger for democracy because democratic citizenship requires more than coexistence. It requires some sense that people who live differently still belong to the same political community. If citizens begin to see one another primarily as members of hostile social categories, the common world necessary for democratic disagreement becomes progressively weaker.
14. Shared prosperity and the moral meaning of economic inequality
Shared prosperity does not require everyone to possess exactly the same income, nor does it require the elimination of all economic differences. Its democratic significance lies in the belief that economic growth should produce broadly distributed opportunities and that citizens should not be permanently divided into groups whose economic trajectories move in opposite directions.
Extreme inequality becomes politically dangerous when it is accompanied by unequal power and unequal opportunities. If wealthy and highly educated citizens possess greater influence over government, better access to institutions, better educational opportunities for their children, and greater ability to move away from declining communities, inequality can become self-reinforcing. The resulting society may retain legal equality while developing significant inequalities in practical political influence.
This is why the question of inequality cannot be separated from democracy. When citizens believe that their political voice carries less weight because they lack wealth, education, institutional connections, or cultural legitimacy, formal equality before the law may no longer be sufficient to sustain democratic confidence.
15. The danger of confusing individual success with social success
One of the most important distinctions in understanding the contemporary crisis is the difference between individual advancement and collective progress. A person who acquires an excellent education, obtains a high-paying job, moves to a successful city, and benefits from technological transformation may quite reasonably feel that society is becoming more open and prosperous. From their personal perspective, the transformation may represent genuine liberation.
Another person whose factory closes, whose occupation becomes obsolete, whose children leave the community because there are no opportunities, and whose local institutions decline may experience exactly the same historical transformation as social destruction. Neither experience is necessarily false. They represent different positions within the same transformation.
The democratic problem arises when the political system treats the first experience as evidence of general progress and the second as evidence of individual failure. Once structural changes are interpreted primarily through the language of personal merit, citizens who lose from those changes can be blamed for failing to adapt rather than recognized as people whose economic environment has been transformed. Such an interpretation can deepen resentment because it communicates not merely that some citizens are economically disadvantaged but that their disadvantages are somehow evidence of their own inadequacy.
16. When merit becomes a new hierarchy
The expansion of education can also generate a new form of social hierarchy when educational credentials become a principal measure of competence, status, and even moral worth. In such a system, highly educated people may gradually come to regard their own achievements as evidence that they are more deserving of influence, while people with less formal education may increasingly feel that their experiences are treated as less legitimate.
This is particularly dangerous for liberal democracy because the principle of political equality does not say that citizens possess equal levels of technical expertise. It says that citizens possess equal political standing. A person without a university degree may know less about econometric modelling than an economist while possessing equally legitimate interests in employment, housing, community, dignity, taxation, education, and the future of their children.
The challenge for liberal democracy is therefore to combine expertise with political equality rather than allowing expertise to become a justification for political hierarchy.
17. The institutionalization of the divide
The division between educated and less-educated citizens becomes especially serious when it is no longer merely an economic difference but becomes embedded within institutions. If universities increasingly recruit from particular social groups, professional occupations increasingly require expensive educational credentials, government increasingly relies upon specialized experts, media increasingly reflects metropolitan professional cultures, and economic opportunities become geographically concentrated, then the same social group can acquire influence across multiple institutions simultaneously.
At that point, political inequality can become difficult to correct because the institutions that might ordinarily respond to inequality are themselves shaped by the unequal distribution of social power. The problem becomes circular: education creates economic opportunity, economic opportunity creates institutional influence, institutional influence shapes public policy, and public policy can then reinforce the educational and economic advantages of the same groups.
This is why democratic renewal cannot be achieved merely by telling disadvantaged citizens to acquire more education. Education is important, but education alone cannot solve a problem that also involves regional inequality, labour-market power, political representation, public institutions, community decline, and the distribution of economic rewards.
18. Real-world politics and the backlash against liberal establishments
The political consequences of these developments can be observed in the rise of populist and anti-establishment movements across established democracies. In the United States, the political appeal of Donald Trump's movement drew considerable support from communities and voters who believed that globalization, technological change, immigration, political elites, and economic restructuring had produced an America in which traditional working-class interests were insufficiently represented. In Britain, the Brexit referendum revealed a profound geographical and educational divide, with many communities outside prosperous metropolitan centres expressing dissatisfaction with political and economic arrangements associated with the established order.
These developments should not be interpreted as proving that every supporter of populism is economically disadvantaged or that every liberal elite is responsible for social decline. The political reality is much more complex. Nevertheless, these cases illustrate a broader mechanism in which economic dislocation, cultural distance, institutional distrust, and perceived political exclusion can converge into opposition to liberal establishments.
The rise of Viktor Orbán's Hungary provides another form of this development, because political dissatisfaction with liberal institutions can be redirected toward a more nationalist and centralized conception of political authority. Once citizens become convinced that liberal institutions represent distant elites rather than themselves, the promise of strong leadership can become attractive even when it involves weakening some of the institutional constraints traditionally associated with liberal democracy.
19. The danger of antiliberal alternatives
The failure of liberal democracy can create space for alternatives that are not necessarily democratic solutions. When citizens become disappointed with political institutions, they may seek stronger leaders, greater national unity, ethnic or cultural homogeneity, or political systems that promise decisive action without the constraints of liberal pluralism.
This is precisely why democratic self-correction matters. If legitimate grievances are ignored, they do not disappear merely because the political establishment regards them as irrational or dangerous. They can instead be appropriated by movements that offer explanations based upon nationalism, ethnic exclusion, conspiracy theories, authoritarian leadership, or rejection of pluralistic institutions.
The appropriate response cannot therefore be to dismiss every criticism of liberal democracy as inherently antidemocratic. A healthy liberal democracy must be capable of distinguishing between legitimate criticism of democratic failures and movements that seek to destroy democratic freedom itself. If the legitimate grievances are not addressed, however, the destructive movements can gain credibility by presenting themselves as the only alternatives to an unresponsive establishment.
20. Liberalism's problem is not freedom itself
The solution to this crisis cannot be a retreat from freedom. The freedoms associated with liberal democracy remain essential because freedom of expression, freedom of association, equality before the law, political participation, protection from arbitrary power, and individual autonomy provide the conditions under which citizens can challenge authority and correct political mistakes.
The problem arises when freedom is detached from the institutions and social relationships that allow people to exercise it meaningfully. A worker who technically possesses freedom of contract but has no bargaining power against a dominant employer does not experience that freedom in the same way as someone who has many employment alternatives. A citizen who technically possesses voting rights but feels that no political institution responds to their community may possess formal political equality while experiencing substantive political powerlessness.
Liberal democracy therefore needs to understand freedom not simply as the absence of interference but also as participation in a political and social order in which citizens have meaningful capacities to influence the conditions of their common life.
21. Democracy requires a balance between expertise and participation
The answer is not to reject experts in favour of uninformed majoritarianism. Complex societies require expertise, and democratic institutions themselves depend upon administrators, scientists, engineers, doctors, economists, lawyers, educators, and other specialists. The essential principle is that expertise must serve democratic self-government rather than replace it.
A democratic system should therefore create institutions through which technical knowledge is brought into conversation with lived experience. Citizens should have meaningful opportunities to question policies, deliberate about priorities, organize collectively, and hold experts accountable. Experts can explain what is technically possible and what consequences different choices are likely to produce, but democratic citizens must retain a meaningful role in determining which social objectives deserve priority.
This balance is particularly important in areas such as artificial intelligence, automation, climate transition, industrial restructuring, and digital governance, because technological decisions increasingly shape employment, education, privacy, public services, and political communication. The people whose lives are transformed by these technologies cannot be treated merely as recipients of decisions made elsewhere.
22. Rebuilding the connection between economic growth and political voice
Democratic renewal therefore requires a new connection between economic policy and political participation. The objective should not simply be to redistribute income after inequality has already been produced. It should also be to build institutions that give workers and communities greater influence over the processes that generate economic outcomes.
Historically, labour organizations played an important role because they did not merely transfer money from one group to another; they created organized political voice inside the economy. Workers could collectively negotiate wages, working conditions, employment practices, and other matters that directly affected their lives. In the contemporary economy, new forms of worker organization and representation may be necessary because employment has become more fragmented and technology has changed the relationship between workers and employers.
The underlying principle remains the same: economic institutions should not be treated as completely separate from democratic institutions, because people spend a substantial part of their lives inside workplaces and economic organizations. If democracy stops at the workplace door, citizens may experience a profound contradiction between their formal political equality and their everyday economic powerlessness.
23. Rebuilding communities rather than merely relocating individuals
A democratic response to economic transformation should also distinguish between helping individuals move and helping communities adapt. Geographic mobility can be beneficial, but it cannot be the only solution to regional decline. If the standard response to a declining town is simply to tell its younger residents to leave and acquire skills elsewhere, the policy may improve individual outcomes while accelerating the destruction of the community itself.
A more comprehensive approach would recognize the value of local institutions, public infrastructure, schools, health systems, transport, cultural organizations, small businesses, and local political associations. Investment in these institutions can help create places in which citizens once again experience themselves as participants in a shared social world rather than as isolated individuals trying to escape economic decline.
The importance of community became particularly visible during periods of economic crisis and public emergencies, when neighbourhood associations, local governments, voluntary organizations, schools, health institutions, and informal networks often became essential to social resilience. These institutions demonstrate that community is not an alternative to individual freedom; it can be one of the conditions that makes freedom socially sustainable.
24. Shared prosperity as a democratic necessity
Shared prosperity should therefore be treated not merely as a welfare objective but as a democratic objective. When people believe that economic progress benefits only a narrow section of society, they become less likely to regard the political system as a common project. Conversely, when citizens see that institutions allow them to share in the benefits of economic development, economic growth can strengthen democratic legitimacy.
This does not require eliminating markets. Markets can generate innovation, productivity, choice, and economic dynamism, but their outcomes depend upon institutional conditions. Competition policy, labour rights, taxation, education, infrastructure, social insurance, public health, and regulation can determine whether market-generated wealth is broadly distributed or increasingly concentrated.
The central democratic question is therefore not whether markets should exist but what institutional arrangements allow markets and democracy to reinforce rather than undermine each other.
25. The deeper principle: democracy must remain adaptive
The experience of the transition from industrial to postindustrial society reveals a general principle about democratic institutions: institutions that succeed under one historical structure cannot assume that their previous success guarantees future success. Economic technologies change, occupations change, social classes change, patterns of communication change, and forms of political organization change. Democracy must therefore possess the capacity to learn and adapt.
Adaptation does not mean abandoning principles. On the contrary, it requires recovering the underlying principles and finding new institutional forms through which they can operate under changed conditions. Self-government may require new forms of workplace participation and digital deliberation. Community may require new forms of local institution-building. Shared prosperity may require new approaches to automation, labour markets, education, taxation, and social protection.
The failure occurs when adaptation is confused with abandonment, so that instead of asking how liberal values can be preserved under new conditions, political elites simply accept the new social hierarchy as inevitable.
26. The two failures must be understood together
The distinction between omission and commission ultimately provides a powerful framework for understanding the entire crisis. Omission occurs when democratic institutions fail to respond adequately to citizens who are being harmed by economic and social transformation. Commission occurs when influential actors actively move away from values that were central to the earlier democratic settlement. These are different failures, but they can reinforce each other.
When governments fail to respond to declining communities, citizens become alienated. When educated elites become less committed to community and shared prosperity, they may become less sensitive to that alienation. When citizens become politically alienated, they may withdraw from traditional democratic institutions or turn toward anti-establishment movements. When those movements become stronger, liberal elites may become even more convinced that ordinary citizens are intolerant, uninformed, or politically dangerous. The resulting distrust can then deepen the original division.
The democratic crisis thus becomes a self-reinforcing cycle of distance in which citizens distrust elites, elites distrust citizens, institutions become less responsive, and political disagreement becomes increasingly interpreted through the language of social identity rather than the language of shared citizenship.
27. From “people versus elites” to a more serious democratic question
It is tempting to describe the crisis simply as a struggle between ordinary people and educated elites, but that formulation is inadequate. Many educated people are themselves economically insecure, and many citizens without higher education participate actively in liberal institutions and support democratic values. The more important issue is not education as a personal characteristic but the concentration of institutional power among people who share particular educational, occupational, geographical, and cultural experiences.
The democratic question is therefore not whether educated people should have influence. Of course they should, just as workers, entrepreneurs, farmers, professionals, community organizations, minorities, and other citizens should have influence. The question is whether any single social group becomes sufficiently dominant that other citizens lose meaningful access to the processes through which public priorities are established.
Democracy requires pluralism not because every citizen possesses identical knowledge but because no social group possesses a complete understanding of the common world.
28. Restoring the meaning of political voice
Political voice must consequently be understood as more than the right to vote every few years. Voting is essential, but democratic voice also requires opportunities for organization, association, deliberation, protest, public debate, workplace representation, local participation, and engagement with institutions that make consequential decisions.
The industrial period created some of these channels almost organically because workers lived together, worked together, organized together, and developed common institutions. The postindustrial world requires new channels because work is more fragmented, communities are more dispersed, and political communication increasingly occurs through digital platforms.
The challenge is to ensure that technological change does not merely provide more opportunities to speak while simultaneously making it harder for citizens to develop the stable organizations through which their voices can produce institutional consequences. A million isolated expressions of anger do not necessarily constitute democratic power; organized participation capable of influencing institutions is much closer to meaningful political voice.
29. A renewed liberal democracy must unite freedom and belonging
The central task is therefore not to choose between individual freedom and community, or between markets and social protection, or between expertise and popular participation. A durable liberal democracy must find ways of holding these apparently competing values together.
Individual freedom without community can produce isolation. Community without individual freedom can become coercive. Expertise without democratic accountability can become technocracy. Popular participation without respect for knowledge can become unstable. Markets without institutional constraints can generate concentrated power. Redistribution without economic dynamism can become unsustainable. The challenge is therefore institutional rather than ideological: how can different legitimate values be organized so that each protects the others rather than destroying them?
The historical success of liberal democracy suggests that this balance is possible, but it cannot be assumed to emerge automatically.
30. Conclusion: Democracy must once again become a shared project
The contemporary crisis of liberal democracy ultimately arises from a loss of connection between freedom and voice, growth and prosperity, expertise and self-government, individual advancement and community, and economic success and democratic inclusion. The transformation of the economy created genuine opportunities and enormous increases in productivity, knowledge, technology, and individual choice, but it also altered the distribution of economic and institutional power. The educated became increasingly influential, while many less-educated citizens experienced economic transformation as insecurity and loss. The political system often failed to respond adequately to those losses, creating a failure of omission, while influential sections of the liberal establishment increasingly weakened their commitment to self-government, community, and shared prosperity, creating a failure of commission.
The lesson is not that liberal democracy was an illusion, nor that its principles should be abandoned. The stronger lesson is that a successful political order must continually renew the social conditions that make its principles meaningful. Liberal democracy cannot survive indefinitely by defending only its formal procedures while allowing large numbers of citizens to experience themselves as economically dispensable, politically unheard, socially isolated, or institutionally irrelevant. Nor can it survive by allowing expertise and educational achievement to become substitutes for political equality.
A renewed liberal democracy would therefore have to recover a simple but demanding proposition: citizens are not merely individuals who possess rights; they are participants in a shared political world. Economic institutions must give them meaningful opportunities to shape the conditions of their work and livelihood, public institutions must respond to the communities in which they live, economic growth must create broadly distributed opportunities, and expertise must operate within rather than above democratic self-government.
The ultimate measure of a liberal democracy is consequently not whether it can produce highly successful individuals, technologically advanced industries, wealthy cities, or impressive economic statistics. Its deeper measure is whether ordinary citizens can experience the society as partly theirs, the institutions as responsive to them, the economy as offering them a meaningful future, and political participation as something capable of changing the conditions of their common life. When that experience disappears, liberal democracy may retain its constitutional form while losing the social foundation that gives the form its legitimacy. When that connection is restored, liberal democracy can once again become not merely a system for choosing governments but a shared project through which free and equal citizens govern a world they recognize as their own.
Liberal Democracy, Education, Social Engineering, and the Problem of “Improving” Citizens
Expanded explanation of Page 17 (last paragraph) to Page 19
1. Liberalism began with a difficult
tension between the educated elite and the less-educated majority, and this
tension contained a contradiction between liberal ideals and democratic ideals.
Acemoglu begins by pointing out that liberal philosophy has always faced a
delicate problem: liberal ideas were largely developed and articulated by
educated intellectuals, while liberal democracy ultimately claimed that
ordinary people, including those with little formal education, should also have
political rights and a voice in government. This creates a deeper contradiction
between two principles that are both important but do not automatically fit
together. Liberalism places great importance on individual freedom,
rational judgment, protection of minorities, constitutional limits, property
rights, freedom of thought, and the protection of individuals against arbitrary
power, whereas democracy places great importance on political equality and the
right of citizens to participate equally in determining who governs and what
public decisions are made. The contradiction appears when liberal
thinkers begin to believe that some citizens are more capable of exercising
political judgment than others because they possess greater education,
knowledge, rationality, or refinement. At that point, the liberal concern for
protecting freedom and rational government can begin to conflict with the
democratic principle that political authority ultimately belongs equally to
citizens.
2. The contradiction was particularly
strong because the people who formulated liberal ideals were themselves members
of educated and privileged groups.
The historical irony becomes particularly sharp when Acemoglu reminds us that
some of the philosophical roots of liberalism go back to ancient Greece and
Rome, where philosophers and educated elites lived within societies whose
economic privileges depended heavily upon slavery and other forms of unfree
labour. This does not mean that the idea of liberty itself was necessarily
meaningless, but it shows that the historical production of ideas about freedom
took place within societies where freedom was distributed very unequally. The
same structural problem appeared later in modern liberalism, because educated
intellectuals could sincerely believe in liberty while simultaneously believing
that the less educated masses were not yet sufficiently capable of exercising
political freedom responsibly. Thus, the liberal ideal of the
autonomous individual could coexist uneasily with the elitist belief that some
individuals were more capable of autonomy than others.
3. John Stuart Mill's fear of the
“tyranny of the majority” was therefore not simply an anti-democratic
prejudice; it identified a genuine problem within mass democracy.
John Stuart Mill worried that if political power were distributed equally among
everyone, the majority might use its numerical power to suppress minorities or
impose its prejudices upon society. His concern was not simply that ordinary
people might make occasional mistakes, but that an uninformed majority could collectively
exercise a kind of tyranny by forcing its preferences upon everyone else. This
helps explain why Mill supported greater political influence for educated
people. The underlying idea was that political judgment requires knowledge,
experience, and intellectual capacity, and therefore those who possess more
education might reasonably be given greater influence. In contemporary
democratic life, this apprehension is not entirely baseless, even
though Mill's proposed solution of giving greater political weight to educated
citizens is deeply problematic. Majorities can indeed become intolerant,
emotional, misinformed, or vulnerable to manipulation, and democratic
majorities have historically supported policies that restricted minorities,
persecuted unpopular groups, or accepted authoritarian measures. The rise of
mass propaganda, political misinformation, conspiracy theories, digitally
amplified outrage, and identity-based mobilisation shows that numerical
majorities do not automatically possess either wisdom or tolerance.
4. Modern history therefore provides
some evidence for Mill's diagnosis, although it does not establish that his
elitist remedy was correct.
The twentieth century demonstrated that democratic majorities can sometimes be
mobilised against liberal institutions themselves, while contemporary politics
has shown how fear, anger, misinformation, and polarisation can be rapidly
transformed into political power. Nazi Germany is an extreme historical example
of how mass political mobilisation, propaganda, nationalism, and institutional
weakness can destroy liberal constitutionalism, although its path to
dictatorship cannot be reduced simply to “majority rule.” More recently,
democratic societies have witnessed voters being influenced by misinformation,
emotionally manipulative political campaigns, algorithmically amplified
content, and highly polarised media environments. Mill therefore identified
something real: democracy does not automatically generate liberalism.
A majority can support restrictions upon minorities, and citizens can use
democratic institutions to empower leaders who subsequently weaken those very
institutions. But this does not prove that educated elites should rule. It
instead demonstrates why democracy needs constitutional rights, independent
institutions, free information, pluralism, critical education, and protections
for minorities alongside majority rule.
5. The real lesson from Mill may
therefore be that political equality cannot be sustained without an
architecture that helps citizens exercise judgment.
If citizens are formally equal but radically unequal in their access to
reliable information, education, time, institutional resources, and
opportunities for deliberation, then political equality can become merely
formal. One citizen may have access to universities, professional networks,
multiple sources of information, expert analysis, data, and sophisticated
technological tools, while another may receive most political information
through a narrow and emotionally manipulated information environment. Both may
possess one vote, but the conditions under which they form political judgments
are profoundly unequal. Mill's apprehension therefore remains relevant
because the quality of democratic judgment depends partly upon the
quality and distribution of knowledge available to citizens. The answer,
however, need not be greater political power for educated elites; it can
instead be the democratisation of education, information, expertise, and the
institutions through which knowledge is produced and distributed.
6. Early liberal thinkers such as
Voltaire and Fichte similarly recognised the enormous importance of education
and knowledge, and the contemporary algorithmic world has made their intuition
even more consequential.
Early liberal thinkers, including Voltaire and Johann Gottlieb Fichte, shared
the belief that education was extremely important and that an educated elite
could eventually emerge to occupy the leading positions in business,
government, bureaucracy, and civil society. Their basic intuition was that
knowledge creates the capacity to understand and govern complex social
arrangements. In their historical circumstances, this meant education through
books, schools, intellectual institutions, correspondence, print culture, and elite
academies. In the contemporary world, however, the power associated with
knowledge has become vastly greater because knowledge is no longer simply
something stored in books or possessed by individual scholars. It is
increasingly organised through databases, search engines, digital platforms,
algorithms, artificial intelligence systems, universities, research
institutions, corporations, governments, media organisations, and proprietary
information systems. The algorithmic world has therefore made the
relationship between education, knowledge, and power much more significant than
early liberals could have imagined.
7. Voltaire's emphasis on knowledge and
intellectual cultivation appears particularly relevant because the modern
citizen does not encounter “information” in a neutral space.
A citizen today may believe that access to the internet means access to
knowledge, but access to information is not identical to access to knowledge.
Search engines rank information, social-media platforms recommend information,
algorithms decide what becomes visible, corporations determine which databases
are accessible, publishers determine what is professionally disseminated,
universities determine what counts as recognised expertise, and governments
regulate or classify particular categories of information. The individual
therefore enters an already structured architecture of knowledge.
What one sees, what one does not see, what appears first, what appears
repeatedly, what is treated as authoritative, and what is pushed to the margins
are all influenced by institutional and technological arrangements. In this
sense, the basic insight of thinkers such as Voltaire — that education and
intellectual formation matter enormously for social and political life — has
not disappeared; it has become more powerful because the organisation of
knowledge itself has become a major source of social power.
8. The modern algorithmic environment
also reveals the unresolved tension between educating citizens and governing
what citizens know.
An algorithm does not necessarily tell people explicitly what they must
believe, yet it can influence what they encounter sufficiently to affect what
they eventually believe. If one person repeatedly receives information
confirming a particular political interpretation while another person receives
a completely different informational environment, their subsequent political
judgments may diverge even though both formally possess the same freedom of
expression and the same right to vote. Recommendation systems, personalised
search results, targeted advertising, political microtargeting, and
engagement-driven platforms can therefore produce forms of indirect influence
that are considerably more subtle than traditional propaganda. This does not
mean that algorithms mechanically determine human beliefs, because people
retain agency and can resist, question, compare, and reinterpret information.
It does mean, however, that control over the architecture through which
information reaches people has become a significant form of political power.
9. The architecture of knowledge has
consequently developed from a relatively simple system of schools, books,
libraries, universities, newspapers, and public institutions into a complex
system of production, certification, distribution, ranking, filtering, and
personalisation.
Historically, access to knowledge depended heavily upon physical proximity to
schools, libraries, universities, books, newspapers, and other institutions.
The expansion of mass education, public libraries, printing, broadcasting, and
later the internet dramatically widened access. This development appeared to
fulfil the democratic promise that knowledge could gradually cease to be the
exclusive property of elites. Yet the digital transformation has created a new
paradox because the quantity of available information has expanded enormously
while the difficulty of identifying reliable knowledge has also increased. A
citizen may now have access to millions of documents within seconds, but the
ability to distinguish evidence from misinformation, expertise from
manufactured authority, and independent information from commercially or
politically manipulated content has become increasingly important. The
problem has therefore shifted from simply possessing information to possessing
the capacity and institutional support necessary to interpret information.
10. This means that the ideas
associated with Mill, Voltaire, and other early liberals continue to operate
within contemporary liberal democracies, but often through institutions rather
than through openly stated political privilege.
Modern liberal democracies generally do not formally say that educated people
should have more votes than less-educated people, as Mill at times
contemplated. Political equality has largely become a constitutional principle.
Yet educated groups continue to exercise disproportionate influence because
they occupy many of the institutions that produce and organise knowledge.
Universities, research institutions, courts, bureaucracies, professional
organisations, think tanks, major media organisations, technology companies,
financial institutions, and policy networks are heavily dependent upon
specialised knowledge. Consequently, the old distinction between the educated
and the less educated has not disappeared; it has been transformed. The
educated elite may no longer possess formally superior political rights, but
they often possess superior capacity to define problems, generate information,
interpret evidence, design policies, establish professional standards, build
technologies, and determine which forms of knowledge receive institutional
recognition.
11. Greater access to knowledge has
therefore not necessarily eliminated the concentration of knowledge; in some
respects, it has produced a new form of concentration.
The internet initially appeared to promise an extraordinary democratisation of
knowledge because almost anyone could publish, search, communicate, and access
information. Yet the sheer scale of information has created new intermediaries
whose function is to organise that abundance. Search engines rank results,
platforms recommend content, publishers control distribution, academic
institutions control credentialing, technology companies control computational
infrastructure, and increasingly powerful artificial intelligence systems
mediate people's interaction with information. The paradox is therefore
that the more information society produces, the more important the
institutions that organise access to that information become. Knowledge may
be abundant while meaningful control over the production, ranking, validation,
aggregation, and distribution of knowledge remains concentrated.
12. Greater concentration of wealth,
technology, and political influence is therefore connected to the concentration
of knowledge itself.
This is an important extension of Acemoglu's argument. Wealth allows
institutions and individuals to acquire technology, employ experts, fund
research, purchase data, build platforms, influence media, and establish
powerful informational infrastructures. Technology, in turn, allows the
collection and processing of enormous quantities of information. Knowledge then
makes it possible to design better technologies, make more effective
investments, influence policy, and organise institutions. These forms of power
reinforce one another. A corporation that possesses capital can build
sophisticated technology; sophisticated technology can generate and analyse
enormous quantities of data; data can generate knowledge; knowledge can improve
commercial and political strategy; and that increased economic power can then
be used to acquire still more technological and informational capacity. The
concentration of wealth and technology is therefore not independent of the
concentration of knowledge; control over knowledge production and access can
become one of the mechanisms through which other forms of power reproduce
themselves.
13. Control over knowledge has
consequently become a deeper form of power than merely possessing information.
The crucial question is no longer simply, “Who knows?” but also “Who decides
what is worth knowing, who produces legitimate knowledge, who has the resources
to produce it, who controls its infrastructure, who can access it, and who
determines how it reaches the public?” A pharmaceutical company may possess
enormous scientific knowledge and proprietary research; a technology company
may possess vast amounts of behavioural data; a government may possess
classified information; a university may control recognised expertise; and a
digital platform may control the channels through which millions of people
encounter information. Each form of power operates partly through control over
knowledge. This means that the concentration of economic or technological power
can be reinforced by an informational structure that ordinary citizens cannot
easily see or challenge.
14. Liberalism's tensions therefore
become particularly serious when the institutions claiming to educate citizens
also acquire the power to determine the boundaries of legitimate knowledge.
Acemoglu's concern about social engineering becomes much more relevant in this
environment because social influence no longer requires direct coercion. A
government does not necessarily need to prohibit a particular idea if the
institutional environment makes that idea difficult to access, difficult to
amplify, or difficult to establish as credible. Similarly, a corporation does
not need to tell a citizen explicitly what to think if its technological
infrastructure determines which information becomes prominent and which remains
practically invisible. This does not mean that every act of filtering, ranking,
moderation, or expert selection is illegitimate, because modern societies
cannot function without some systems for organising information. The deeper
democratic question is who controls those systems, according to what
rules, with what transparency, and with what possibility of public challenge
and correction.
15. Liberalism's internal tension
becomes even more visible when we compare it with the power of wealthy and
authoritarian groups.
Acemoglu then makes an important comparison: the tensions within liberalism
surrounding the education of the masses were relatively small when compared
with the enormous challenge of confronting extremely powerful individuals and
institutions. Liberal societies have had to deal with authoritarian rulers,
immensely wealthy industrialists, and powerful economic actors whose resources
can allow them to influence politics and society far beyond what an ordinary
citizen can do. His reference to people as rich as Croesus, or at least as rich
as John D. Rockefeller, illustrates the extraordinary concentration of economic
power that liberal societies have historically faced. The central liberal
challenge therefore has two dimensions: democracy must prevent the majority
from oppressing minorities, but it must also prevent powerful minorities from
dominating the majority. This remains visible today when very wealthy
individuals, corporations, lobbying organisations, media owners, or large
technology companies acquire enormous capacity to influence political agendas
and public opinion.
16. The concentration of power
therefore cannot be understood only through money because economic power
increasingly operates through knowledge and technological infrastructure.
A very wealthy individual or corporation can exercise influence not merely
because they possess money but because money can be converted into institutions,
expertise, data, technology, media ownership, research capacity, political
access, and control over informational infrastructure. This creates a more
complicated form of inequality than the simple distinction between rich and
poor. Someone who controls a major technological platform may possess the
ability to influence the informational environment of millions of people
without directly controlling their political choices. Someone who controls
large datasets may know things about social behaviour that individual citizens
do not know about themselves. Someone who controls advanced research
infrastructure may determine which questions can be investigated and which
discoveries can be commercially developed. Knowledge thus becomes an
intermediary through which wealth, technology, and political influence are
converted into one another.
17. The deeper conflict concerns
tolerance and ignorance, because liberalism has to decide what to do with
people who reject liberal values.
Acemoglu says that the main conflict eventually centred on two interconnected
problems, namely tolerance and ignorance, with the question of inclusion
becoming especially important. Liberalism says that people should generally be
free to hold different opinions, beliefs, and ways of life, even when those
beliefs are unpopular or offensive to others. Yet what happens when some people
use their freedom to promote intolerance toward other groups? The liberal
dilemma becomes particularly difficult because liberalism wants to protect
freedom of expression while also protecting the freedom and dignity of those
who may become targets of intolerant movements. A contemporary example can be
seen in democratic societies debating whether extremist political speech should
simply be allowed as part of free expression or whether some forms of speech
should be restricted because they encourage discrimination, violence, or
exclusion. The problem has no easy solution because suppressing intolerant
ideas can itself create a danger of excessive political control.
18. The educated elite could therefore
arrive at a very different conclusion from the democratic ideal of equal
political voice.
Acemoglu explains that there were two competing responses to this problem. One
response was that everybody should possess freedom of expression and the
freedom to choose their own beliefs, even if some people were ignorant or
intolerant. The other response was that educated people were better equipped to
understand the social good and therefore deserved greater political influence.
The second position is particularly important because it can begin with a
seemingly reasonable observation — that knowledge matters — but gradually move
toward a much stronger conclusion, namely that those who possess more knowledge
should have greater authority over those who possess less. Once this happens,
democracy risks becoming paternalistic, with educated elites treating ordinary
citizens not as equal participants in collective self-government but as people
who need to be guided, corrected, or improved.
19. This is where the idea of “social
engineering” enters Acemoglu's argument.
Acemoglu uses the term social engineering to describe
deliberate efforts to shape the values and behaviour of a population,
especially when those efforts are undertaken forcefully and without sufficient
room for critical thinking or disagreement. Social engineering therefore means
more than ordinary persuasion. If a government, institution, educational
system, media organisation, corporation, or powerful social group tries to make
people adopt particular values and behaviours, it is engaging in a form of
social engineering. The crucial distinction is whether people are being
persuaded through open argument and debate or whether the desired beliefs are
being imposed upon them. For example, teaching democratic values in schools
through discussion, historical reasoning, and exposure to competing viewpoints
is different from designing education so that students are discouraged from
questioning officially approved beliefs.
20. Acemoglu stresses that social
engineering is not uniquely a feature of authoritarian regimes.
An important point in these pages is that liberal societies should not imagine
that social engineering is something only dictatorships do. Every political
order attempts, to some degree, to cultivate certain values among its citizens.
Governments teach national history in schools, societies establish civic
rituals, communities transmit moral traditions, and institutions reward some
forms of behaviour while discouraging others. Even liberal societies encourage
values such as tolerance, individual freedom, equality before the law, and
respect for democratic institutions. The difficulty arises when the attempt to
cultivate these values becomes coercive and leaves no legitimate space for
disagreement. Acemoglu's argument is therefore not that liberal societies
should never promote liberal values; rather, it is that they must constantly
ask how those values are being promoted and whether citizens
retain the freedom to question them.
21. Acemoglu goes back as far as Plato
to show that the idea of deliberately shaping citizens is extremely old.
He makes the striking observation that almost every political philosopher,
including Plato, recognised the importance of cultivating particular values
among citizens. Plato believed that the stability and flourishing of the
political order depended upon educating citizens according to particular moral
and political principles. His preferred model included strong state control
over education because he believed that education was too important to be left
entirely to individual choice. Acemoglu uses this historical example to
demonstrate that the desire to shape citizens is not something invented by
modern authoritarian governments. It is deeply embedded in political thinking
itself. The important question for liberalism is therefore whether citizens can
be educated toward shared principles without turning education into a mechanism
for controlling their minds.
22. Education is particularly powerful
because it does not merely transfer information; it can shape the kind of
person a society wants to produce.
Acemoglu's discussion of education becomes more significant because education
is one of the most effective instruments through which societies transmit
values from one generation to another. A school does not merely teach
mathematics, science, or language; it also teaches ideas about authority,
cooperation, competition, citizenship, responsibility, history, morality, and
social relationships. Religious institutions have historically performed a
similar function through rituals, moral teaching, community pressure, and
beliefs about rewards and punishments after death. Acemoglu's reference to Karl
Marx's description of religion as the “opium of the people” is therefore part
of a broader point: whether or not one accepts Marx's particular criticism of
religion, religion has historically been a powerful mechanism for shaping human
behaviour through moral instruction, rituals, communal expectations, and
beliefs about consequences after death. Education performs many of the same
functions, although through more secular and institutional means.
23. The problem becomes especially
serious when liberal societies themselves try to manufacture “liberal citizens.”
Acemoglu identifies this as a particularly difficult problem for liberalism
because liberals generally believe that different schools of thought should be
allowed to exist and should be open to public discussion. Yet underneath this
commitment there has often been another assumption: perhaps education can
gradually persuade intolerant people to become more tolerant and open-minded.
This sounds attractive because liberal democracy needs citizens who are capable
of living peacefully with disagreement. However, the moment liberal
institutions begin deliberately transforming people into the “right kind” of
citizen, the boundary between education and social engineering becomes
difficult to determine. For example, teaching children that people with different
religions or political opinions deserve equal rights can be understood as
democratic civic education, but suppressing every alternative interpretation of
history because it conflicts with the preferred political worldview would move
toward ideological conditioning.
24. This creates the central question:
how far may a liberal society go in trying to convince people?
Acemoglu asks a series of uncomfortable questions because there is no obvious
stopping point once the goal of “improving” citizens is accepted. If a liberal
society believes that intolerance is harmful, can it design the entire
education system to eliminate intolerant beliefs? If schools do this, can civil
society, media organisations, and corporations also promote the same values? If
a community itself supports intolerance, is it legitimate for wider society to
destroy or weaken its traditions and institutions? How much social pressure can
be placed upon people before persuasion becomes coercion? And when people
refuse to conform, is social exclusion, public condemnation, or ostracism
justified? These questions are important because the intention may be admirable
while the methods can still become illiberal.
25. Acemoglu therefore distinguishes
persuasion through democratic argument from social engineering through
imposition.
This is perhaps the most important conceptual distinction in these pages.
Liberalism can legitimately argue for certain values because liberal democracy
itself depends upon citizens being able to discuss moral and political
principles. If society argues that equality, tolerance, freedom of expression,
or equal citizenship are desirable, and people are invited to examine these
claims critically and debate them with others, this is fundamentally different
from imposing those values in such a way that disagreement becomes
unacceptable. The first approach treats citizens as reasoning participants; the
second treats them as objects to be shaped. For Acemoglu, therefore, the method
of promoting liberal values matters as much as the values themselves.
26. The same liberal principle can
therefore produce either democratic education or illiberal social engineering,
depending upon how it is practised.
Suppose a school teaches students that religious minorities should have equal
rights. If students are encouraged to examine historical examples, debate
objections, understand different perspectives, and reach conclusions through
reasoning, the process strengthens liberal citizenship because it develops
their capacity for judgment. But if students are simply told what they must
believe and are punished for questioning the approved position, the same
substantive value of tolerance can be promoted through an illiberal method.
This distinction is crucial because Acemoglu is not arguing that liberal
societies should become neutral about everything. Rather, he is asking whether
liberal values can be sustained without abandoning the freedom,
disagreement, and critical reasoning that make liberalism liberal in the first
place.
27. The architecture of knowledge
therefore becomes central to the question of whether liberal education remains
genuinely liberal.
If citizens are to participate as equals in democratic life, they need not
possess identical knowledge, but they need meaningful opportunities to acquire,
question, compare, and evaluate knowledge. This makes the organisation of
education, media, research, libraries, digital platforms, search systems, and
now artificial intelligence politically important. When access to knowledge is
broad, diverse, transparent, and contestable, citizens have greater opportunity
to exercise independent judgment. When knowledge production is concentrated,
when access is restricted by economic power, when information is heavily
personalised, or when a small number of institutions determine what becomes
visible and authoritative, formal political equality can coexist with
substantial informational inequality. The democratic citizen may retain
one vote, but the informational conditions surrounding that vote may be
profoundly unequal.
28. The concentration of knowledge can
consequently reproduce the very elite-mass distinction that liberal democracy
originally tried to overcome.
The modern educated elite need not openly declare that ordinary citizens are
inferior. Instead, inequality can emerge through differences in access to
universities, professional expertise, data, technology, research institutions,
networks, high-quality journalism, specialised information, and computational
resources. A highly educated professional can navigate complex institutional
systems with ease, while someone without those resources may depend upon
simplified interpretations supplied by others. This creates a subtle form of
dependence in which the citizen remains legally free but becomes increasingly
dependent upon institutions controlled by others for understanding the world in
which they are expected to make political decisions. In that sense, control
over knowledge can become a hidden foundation of unequal political capacity.
29. The historical problem identified
by Mill and Voltaire has therefore not disappeared; it has changed its
institutional form.
Mill asked whether people without sufficient knowledge could exercise political
power responsibly, while Voltaire and other thinkers emphasised education and
intellectual cultivation as foundations of social progress. Modern liberal
democracies have rejected the straightforward conclusion that educated people
should possess greater formal political rights, and that rejection represents a
major democratic achievement. Yet the underlying problem remains because
knowledge still affects power, and people who control the production and
distribution of knowledge still exercise disproportionate influence. The
algorithmic age has intensified this issue because knowledge is now
increasingly mediated through systems that can classify, rank, predict,
personalise, recommend, and sometimes generate information at enormous scale. The
old educated elite has therefore partly evolved into a wider
knowledge-producing and knowledge-controlling infrastructure.
30. The dilemmas surrounding
intolerance were always present in liberalism, but the challenge of adapting to
a postindustrial society while liberalism itself was in control was entirely
new.
Acemoglu ends this part by making an important historical distinction. The
question of whether liberal societies should tolerate intolerant people, and
whether citizens should be educated into becoming “better” liberal citizens,
existed from the beginning of liberalism. These were therefore not new problems
created by the twenty-first century. What was new was the challenge of adapting
liberal democracy to a postindustrial society while liberalism
itself was increasingly becoming the dominant political and social framework.
This prepared the ground for a new situation in which education, knowledge,
technology, services, professional expertise, information systems, and
increasingly sophisticated economic institutions would become central to social
organisation. The old liberal balance between educated elites and the masses
would therefore be tested under entirely new economic and social conditions.
31. The larger argument running through
these pages is that liberal democracy cannot survive simply by producing
“correct” citizens; it has to preserve citizens' capacity to think and
disagree.
Taken together, these pages show Acemoglu examining a deep contradiction inside
liberal democracy. Liberal societies need citizens who can tolerate difference,
respect others, understand democratic principles, and resist authoritarianism,
so some form of civic education and moral formation is unavoidable. At the same
time, liberalism cannot legitimately solve this problem by treating citizens as
passive material that educated elites, governments, schools, corporations,
media institutions, or technological systems can simply reshape according to
their preferred model. The deeper issue is that political freedom
requires not merely formal access to the vote or formal freedom of expression,
but meaningful access to the knowledge through which citizens understand the
world and exercise judgment. A liberal democracy must therefore
persuade without indoctrinating, educate without intellectually controlling,
cultivate shared principles without eliminating disagreement, and defend
tolerance without becoming intolerant in the process. In the contemporary
algorithmic world, this additionally requires attention to who produces knowledge,
who controls its infrastructure, who determines its accessibility and
visibility, and who possesses the technological capacity to organise the
informational environment of others. Otherwise, the concentration of wealth,
technology, expertise, and political influence can become anchored in a less
visible but extremely powerful concentration of control over knowledge
itself — over its production, validation, organisation, distribution, and
access.
Liberal Democracy, Knowledge, Education, and the Making of the Citizen
1. The fundamental tension between
liberalism and democracy lies in their different starting points concerning the
individual and political authority.
Liberalism and democracy eventually became closely associated with one another,
but they did not originate from exactly the same intellectual impulse.
Liberalism was principally concerned with protecting the individual from
arbitrary power and creating a political order in which freedom of thought,
conscience, expression, association, property, and personal choice could be
protected by law. Democracy, by contrast, rested more directly upon the
principle of political equality, according to which those who are subject to
political authority should have an equal opportunity to participate in determining
that authority. The tension arises when liberalism begins to ask whether every
citizen is equally capable of exercising political judgment. If knowledge,
education, rationality, and intellectual competence are treated as conditions
for responsible political participation, then the liberal desire for rational
and restrained government can begin to conflict with the democratic insistence
that political power should not depend upon educational status. The
contradiction therefore is not between freedom and democracy in a simple sense,
but between the liberal tendency to privilege competent judgment and
the democratic principle of equal political standing.
2. This contradiction has existed
because liberal ideals were historically articulated largely by educated and
socially privileged groups.
The language of freedom, reason, individual autonomy, and constitutional
government was often developed by intellectuals who possessed educational and
social advantages that were unavailable to large sections of the population.
The paradox is particularly visible when the intellectual history of freedom is
traced back to ancient Greece and Rome, where philosophical reflection
flourished alongside slavery and other forms of unfree labour. Political and
philosophical participation was therefore historically separated from universal
human equality. Even when modern liberalism began to speak in increasingly
universal terms, many of its thinkers continued to believe that education was
necessary for the proper exercise of freedom. The resulting problem was that
the person who claimed that every human being possessed the capacity for
self-government could simultaneously believe that only sufficiently educated
people were capable of exercising that capacity responsibly. Liberalism
consequently carried within itself an unresolved question: if people
are free, who has the authority to decide whether they are sufficiently
educated to use that freedom?
3. John Stuart Mill's fear of the
tyranny of the majority was therefore not entirely baseless, even though his
proposed remedy raises serious democratic problems.
John Stuart Mill was deeply concerned that political equality could produce a
situation in which the majority used its numerical strength to suppress
individuality, minorities, unconventional opinions, or unpopular ways of life.
His concern was that a majority could become socially oppressive even without
becoming formally dictatorial, because people might conform to prevailing
opinions simply because those opinions were dominant. Modern history provides
substantial evidence that this apprehension cannot simply be dismissed as
elitist anxiety. Majorities have supported discriminatory laws, religious
persecution, restrictions on minorities, censorship, nationalist movements, and
authoritarian leaders who subsequently weakened democratic institutions. In
contemporary societies, majorities can also be mobilised through fear, anger, misinformation,
conspiracy narratives, identity politics, and emotionally charged political
campaigns. The danger Mill identified was therefore real: democracy
does not automatically produce tolerance, wisdom, truth, or liberalism.
4. Yet the modern experience also
demonstrates why Mill's answer cannot simply be greater political authority for
the educated.
The fact that citizens can be misinformed does not establish that educated
elites are necessarily more trustworthy or more democratic. Highly educated people
have themselves supported colonialism, racial hierarchy, authoritarianism,
economic exploitation, eugenics, imperialism, and destructive political
ideologies. Education can increase the capacity to reason, but it can also
increase the capacity to rationalise one's own interests. Expertise can
illuminate a problem, but experts can also become socially insulated,
institutionally dependent, or intellectually homogeneous. The appropriate
democratic response to the problem identified by Mill is therefore not to
abandon political equality but to create institutions that improve the
conditions under which citizens exercise judgment. Independent journalism,
universal education, public libraries, transparent government, scientific
institutions, open debate, constitutional rights, pluralistic media, and
accessible public information can help transform political equality from a
merely formal principle into a more substantive capacity for participation.
5. The deeper lesson of Mill's
apprehension is that equal political rights require reasonably equal
opportunities to form political judgment.
Two citizens may possess exactly the same voting rights while living in
completely different informational worlds. One may have access to high-quality
education, books, diverse journalism, expert analysis, reliable statistics,
cultural institutions, and multiple perspectives, while another may depend upon
a narrow informational environment shaped by commercial incentives, political
propaganda, social pressure, or algorithmic recommendation. Both possess one
vote, but the conditions under which they interpret political reality are not
equal. This does not mean that democracy should establish an intellectual
hierarchy of citizens; rather, it means that the infrastructure through
which citizens acquire knowledge is itself a democratic institution.
Political equality therefore depends not merely upon distributing votes equally
but also upon creating conditions in which citizens can acquire, question,
compare, and interpret information without excessive dependence upon powerful
intermediaries.
6. The emphasis placed by Voltaire and
other Enlightenment thinkers on education and intellectual development becomes
particularly significant in this context.
Voltaire's faith in reason, criticism, learning, and intellectual emancipation
reflected the Enlightenment belief that societies could liberate themselves
from inherited superstition and arbitrary authority through the expansion of
knowledge. Other thinkers similarly regarded education as a foundation for
civic improvement and social progress. Their basic intuition has proved
remarkably durable because modern societies have become even more dependent
upon knowledge than the societies in which these ideas were formulated. The
difference is that knowledge today is not simply contained in books or
possessed by individual scholars. It is produced through universities,
laboratories, corporations, governments, research institutions, databases,
newspapers, television networks, digital platforms, search engines, and
artificial intelligence systems. The importance of knowledge has
therefore increased at precisely the moment when the mechanisms controlling its
production and circulation have become more complex.
7. The algorithmic world has made the
old relationship between knowledge and power far more consequential.
A citizen using a digital platform may experience the internet as an enormous
space of freedom because almost anything appears to be available. Yet the
existence of information does not mean that every person encounters the same
information. Search engines rank results, recommendation systems select
content, social platforms optimise visibility according to particular
objectives, advertising systems target individuals according to inferred characteristics,
and artificial intelligence systems increasingly mediate how information is
summarised and presented. The individual therefore does not encounter an
unstructured universe of knowledge but an organised informational
environment. What becomes visible, what remains invisible, what appears
repeatedly, what receives credibility, and what disappears from attention can
be influenced by technological systems that most citizens neither control nor
fully understand.
8. This does not mean that algorithms determine
what people believe, but it does mean that they can influence the conditions
under which beliefs are formed.
Human beings remain capable of questioning information, changing their minds,
seeking alternative sources, and resisting technological influence.
Nevertheless, the informational environment matters because people cannot
evaluate information that they never encounter. If one citizen repeatedly
receives information supporting a particular political interpretation while
another repeatedly receives information supporting an opposing interpretation,
their understanding of political reality may diverge before they even begin a
conscious political debate. The power of algorithmic systems therefore lies
less in commanding citizens what to believe than in structuring the
field within which belief formation takes place. This represents a new form
of influence because traditional censorship attempted to prevent people from
accessing certain information, whereas algorithmic systems can influence
behaviour through much subtler processes of ranking, recommendation,
repetition, personalisation, and attention management.
9. The architecture of knowledge has
consequently developed from institutions of storage into institutions of
selection and mediation.
Earlier societies were primarily concerned with producing and preserving
knowledge through schools, universities, libraries, books, archives,
newspapers, and professional institutions. Modern societies still depend upon
these institutions, but they have added an enormous technological layer in
which information is collected, classified, indexed, ranked, predicted,
filtered, personalised, and automatically generated. This has produced an
extraordinary expansion of access. A person with an internet connection can now
reach material that earlier generations could access only through universities,
major libraries, specialist institutions, or expensive publications. Yet this
extraordinary democratisation of access has produced a paradox because the
abundance of information makes the problem of selection more important. When
there are millions of possible sources, the institution that helps
determine which ten sources appear first can possess enormous influence over
what a citizen actually knows.
10. The problem has therefore shifted
from scarcity of information to the organisation of informational abundance.
In earlier periods, the central democratic problem was often that ordinary
people lacked access to books, education, newspapers, scientific knowledge, and
formal institutions of learning. The modern problem is increasingly different
because information is abundant while attention is scarce. Nobody can read
everything, examine every scientific study, compare every political claim, or
investigate every piece of information encountered online. Citizens must
therefore rely upon systems that select and organise information for them.
Search engines, editors, journalists, teachers, academics, professional
organisations, recommendation algorithms, influencers, and artificial intelligence
systems all perform some version of this selection function. The crucial
democratic question consequently becomes not merely whether information is
available, but who performs the selection, according to which criteria,
and with what possibility of correction or challenge.
11. The ideas associated with Mill and
Voltaire have therefore not disappeared from liberal democracies; they have
been institutionalised in more sophisticated forms.
Modern liberal democracies generally reject the explicit proposition that
educated people should possess more political rights than less-educated people.
Universal suffrage has established the principle that political citizenship
should not depend upon educational attainment. Yet the underlying recognition
that knowledge creates influence remains deeply embedded in modern
institutions. Educated professionals occupy a large proportion of positions in
government, universities, courts, research institutions, media organisations,
corporations, technology companies, financial institutions, and policy
organisations. Expertise is routinely used to determine which policies are
considered realistic, which evidence is considered credible, which risks
deserve attention, and which solutions are treated as technically possible. Thus,
although the formal political hierarchy has been removed, a knowledge
hierarchy continues to influence the practical distribution of power.
12. The concentration of knowledge is
particularly significant because knowledge has become increasingly connected to
wealth, technology, and institutional power.
Wealth enables institutions to employ experts, establish research centres,
purchase data, build technological infrastructure, finance publications,
acquire media organisations, develop artificial intelligence systems, and
influence public debate. Technology allows enormous quantities of information
to be collected and processed. Knowledge makes technology more powerful and
allows capital to be deployed more effectively. These relationships form a
reinforcing cycle in which wealth produces technological capacity,
technological capacity generates informational resources, informational
resources produce knowledge, and knowledge strengthens economic and
institutional power. The result is that wealth, technology, expertise,
and knowledge increasingly reinforce one another rather than existing as
separate forms of power.
13. Control over knowledge production
may therefore be one of the deepest foundations of contemporary power.
The decisive question is no longer simply who possesses information, because
information can often be obtained relatively cheaply. The more important
questions concern who possesses the resources to produce authoritative
knowledge, who controls the institutions that certify it, who owns the
technological infrastructure through which it circulates, who determines what
data are collected, who has access to that data, who can process it, and who
has the ability to transform information into decisions. A technology company
with enormous behavioural data possesses a different form of power from a
company that merely possesses financial capital. A university with
internationally recognised research capacity possesses a different form of
influence from an institution without such recognition. A government possessing
extensive administrative data has a different informational capacity from
citizens who are merely the subjects of that data. Control over
knowledge therefore becomes a means through which other forms of power can be
accumulated and reproduced.
14. Greater concentration of wealth and
technology can consequently become anchored in control over the production and
accessibility of knowledge itself.
When the same institutions possess financial resources, technological
infrastructure, specialised expertise, enormous datasets, and privileged access
to decision-makers, their influence can become self-reinforcing. They can
produce knowledge that supports further technological development, use
technology to collect more information, use that information to produce better
predictions and strategies, and use the resulting economic advantages to expand
their technological and informational capacity. This creates a form of
cumulative power in which the most important inequality may not always be
visible as ownership of money or property. It may appear instead as unequal
capacity to know, to produce knowledge, to interpret knowledge, and to
determine who else gets access to it.
15. The concentration of knowledge also
creates a new version of the old distinction between the educated elite and the
less-educated masses.
The distinction is no longer simply between people who can read and people who
cannot, or between university graduates and those without formal education. It
increasingly concerns the ability to navigate complex systems of information.
Some people possess the education, professional networks, technological tools,
data, institutional access, and time necessary to investigate complicated
questions independently. Others must depend upon simplified interpretations
produced by institutions they cannot easily evaluate. A citizen may therefore
be legally free and formally equal while remaining epistemically dependent upon
institutions controlled by others. The democratic challenge becomes
particularly serious when this dependence is invisible, because citizens may
experience the information they receive as spontaneous and neutral even though
it has passed through numerous institutional and technological filters.
16. This is where the old liberal
concern about educating citizens begins to merge with the modern problem of
controlling the informational environment.
A society may sincerely believe that citizens should become more tolerant,
rational, informed, and democratic. It may therefore design educational
programmes, public campaigns, media systems, institutional standards, and
digital environments intended to encourage those values. Such efforts can serve
democracy when they expand citizens' capacity to think critically and
participate equally. They become problematic when they move from enabling
judgment to controlling judgment. The difference is fundamental. Education
gives a person more capacity to examine competing possibilities, whereas
indoctrination narrows the possibilities that the person is permitted to
consider. Democratic knowledge must therefore expand the citizen's capacity for
judgment rather than merely producing agreement with predetermined conclusions.
17. The deeper problem concerns
tolerance because liberal democracy must protect citizens who disagree with
prevailing beliefs while also protecting the conditions of democratic
coexistence.
A liberal society cannot simply permit the majority to suppress every unpopular
idea, because freedom of thought and expression require room for disagreement.
At the same time, a democratic society cannot remain indifferent when political
movements use freedom to deny the equal freedom of others. This creates the
difficult question of where legitimate disagreement ends and destructive
intolerance begins. Contemporary debates about hate speech, extremist
movements, religious intolerance, political censorship, and online
radicalisation demonstrate how difficult this boundary can be. The problem
becomes even more complicated when governments or private platforms claim that
restrictions are necessary to protect democratic values. The
institution that decides which speech is too dangerous to circulate inevitably
acquires significant power over the boundaries of public thought.
18. The question of social engineering
therefore applies to liberal societies as much as to authoritarian societies,
although the mechanisms can be very different.
Every society attempts to transmit values to the next generation. Families
teach moral expectations, schools teach civic principles, religious communities
transmit traditions, governments teach national histories, and institutions
reward some forms of conduct while discouraging others. The existence of such
social formation is unavoidable because no society can function without some
shared norms. The problem begins when citizens are treated not as participants
capable of questioning those norms but as objects whose attitudes must be
manufactured. In an authoritarian society this may occur through censorship,
coercion, propaganda, and direct political control. In a liberal society it can
occur more subtly through educational systems, cultural institutions, media
environments, corporate practices, social pressure, and increasingly
algorithmic systems that shape what people encounter.
19. Education is therefore both a
foundation of freedom and a potential instrument of control.
Education can liberate people from ignorance by giving them language,
historical awareness, scientific understanding, analytical skills, and the
ability to question authority. At the same time, education can be used to
reproduce a particular social order by defining which histories are remembered,
which interpretations are legitimate, which identities are valued, and which
questions are considered unacceptable. This is why education cannot be judged
solely by the quantity of information transmitted. The more important question
is whether education develops the capacity to examine the information
itself. A student who memorises the officially accepted answer may possess
information without possessing intellectual independence, whereas a student who
understands competing interpretations and can evaluate evidence possesses a
more substantive form of intellectual freedom.
20. The same distinction applies to the
modern media and technological environment.
A society may provide enormous quantities of information while simultaneously
weakening citizens' capacity to distinguish reliable knowledge from
manipulation. The problem is therefore not solved simply by giving people more
content. Citizens need institutions that make evidence traceable, disagreements
visible, corrections possible, and sources accountable. A healthy informational
environment should allow people to understand why a claim is considered
credible, what evidence supports it, what competing interpretations exist, and
how the conclusion could be challenged. This is especially important in an
algorithmic environment because automated systems can produce highly convincing
information without necessarily making the basis of their selection, ranking,
or generation transparent to the person receiving it.
21. The central distinction is
therefore between persuasion that strengthens agency and social engineering
that weakens it.
A democratic society must inevitably persuade citizens of certain principles
because constitutional democracy itself rests upon commitments such as
political equality, freedom, dignity, tolerance, and the peaceful resolution of
disagreement. There is nothing inherently illiberal about arguing for these
values. The problem begins when the process of persuasion eliminates the
possibility of questioning them. Democratic persuasion says, in effect, that
citizens should examine reasons and decide; social engineering says that
citizens should be shaped into the desired form. The first treats people as
political agents, while the second treats them as material to be
organised. The difference is not simply what values are promoted but
whether citizens retain meaningful freedom to examine, challenge, reject,
reinterpret, and reconstruct those values.
22. A genuinely democratic architecture
of knowledge must therefore distribute not only information but also the
capacity to question information.
If knowledge is concentrated in a small number of institutions, democracy
becomes dependent upon the judgment of those institutions. If knowledge is
completely fragmented, democracy becomes vulnerable to misinformation and
manipulation. The democratic challenge is therefore to create an environment in
which knowledge is sufficiently open to be contested but sufficiently
structured to remain intelligible and reliable. Public education, independent
research, libraries, transparent government data, pluralistic media, open
scientific debate, freedom of expression, and accountable technological systems
can all contribute to this balance. The objective should not be to eliminate
expertise, because complex societies necessarily require expertise; rather, it
should be to prevent expertise from becoming an unaccountable source of
political authority.
23. The problem identified by the
classical liberal thinkers has therefore become a problem of institutional
design in the twenty-first century.
The question is no longer simply whether educated people should have greater
political influence than ordinary citizens. Modern democracies have largely
answered that question by affirming political equality. The more difficult
contemporary question is how political equality can remain meaningful when
citizens encounter radically unequal informational environments and when the
institutions that produce and distribute knowledge are themselves unequally
controlled. The old concern about the ignorant majority has consequently been transformed
into a broader concern about the conditions under which citizens become
informed or misinformed. The democratic task is not to replace the judgment
of ordinary citizens with the judgment of elites, but to construct institutions
that allow citizens to exercise judgment with greater independence.
24. The most important democratic
struggle may therefore increasingly be a struggle over the architecture of
knowledge itself.
The future of liberal democracy will depend not only upon elections,
constitutions, political parties, courts, and parliaments but also upon who
controls the systems through which citizens understand their shared world.
Whoever possesses the capacity to produce knowledge, certify knowledge,
organise knowledge, distribute knowledge, personalise knowledge, and restrict
access to knowledge possesses a form of power that can influence political life
without necessarily appearing as political power. This makes knowledge
infrastructure a fundamental component of democratic infrastructure. A citizen
cannot meaningfully govern themselves if the informational world from which
they form their judgments is controlled by institutions that remain beyond
meaningful public scrutiny.
25. The central challenge is therefore
to reconcile the liberal recognition of individual freedom with the democratic
requirement of equal political agency.
Liberal democracy cannot survive by assuming that citizens are naturally
informed, rational, tolerant, and immune to manipulation, because history
demonstrates otherwise. Nor can it survive by concluding that educated elites,
experts, corporations, governments, or technological systems should therefore
decide what citizens ought to know and believe. The more sustainable path lies
between these extremes, through institutions that expand education without
indoctrination, expertise without domination, information without manipulation,
technological innovation without informational monopoly, and persuasion without
coercion. The ultimate purpose of democratic education should not be to
manufacture better citizens according to a predetermined model, but to create
citizens who possess greater capacity to judge for themselves while remaining
capable of living with others who judge differently.
26. The deepest lesson is that freedom
requires more than the absence of coercion; it requires meaningful access to
the conditions of independent judgment.
A person cannot exercise political freedom fully if they are formally free to
speak but systematically deprived of the knowledge necessary to understand the
consequences of political choices. Nor is freedom fully secured merely because
information is technically available if its visibility, credibility, and
accessibility are determined by powerful institutions. Political equality
therefore requires an accompanying commitment to informational and epistemic
conditions that allow citizens to participate as agents rather than as
audiences. The democratic ideal is ultimately not a society in which everyone
knows the same things or believes the same things, but a society in which people
have sufficiently open and plural conditions of knowledge to form, revise,
defend, and contest their judgments as free and equal participants in a shared
political world.
References and Notes
The discussion above develops independently from the argument of any single author, but the immediate historical reference for the questions concerning educated elites, majority rule, tolerance, and social engineering is Daron Acemoglu's What Happened to Liberal Democracy?, especially the discussion on pages 17–19. The historical concern about the tyranny of the majority is associated particularly with John Stuart Mill, while the emphasis on reason, education, intellectual emancipation, and the role of educated elites can be connected to Voltaire and other Enlightenment thinkers. The older philosophical tradition concerning the deliberate formation of citizens can be traced to Plato, while the relationship between ideology, religion, education, and social formation also connects with Karl Marx. The contemporary extension concerning algorithms, information infrastructure, data, technological mediation, and the concentration of knowledge is an independent development of the underlying problem into the conditions of the digital and algorithmic age.
Liberal Democracy, Knowledge, Education, and the Making of the Citizen
From Political Equality to Epistemic Equality, from the Right to Judge to the Right to Answer
1. The problem begins with an unresolved tension between liberalism and democracy
Liberalism and democracy eventually became inseparable in the modern political imagination, but they did not begin from the same principle. Liberalism was principally concerned with protecting the individual from arbitrary power and creating a political order in which thought, conscience, expression, association, property and personal choice could exist under the protection of law. Democracy began from a different proposition, namely that those who are subject to political authority should possess an equal standing in determining that authority. The tension becomes visible when liberalism asks whether all citizens are equally capable of political judgment. If education, knowledge, rationality or competence are treated as necessary conditions for responsible participation, then the liberal desire for competent government can begin to conflict with the democratic principle that political standing cannot depend upon educational status. The deepest contradiction is therefore not between freedom and democracy, but between the desire to identify competent judgment and the democratic refusal to make citizenship conditional upon being judged competent by someone else.
This tension becomes particularly important today because modern societies have become vastly more complex, and because the people who possess specialized knowledge increasingly occupy the institutions through which decisions are made. The problem is no longer simply who gets to vote. It is increasingly a question of who defines the facts within which citizens vote, who classifies citizens for administrative purposes, who decides which information deserves attention, who determines what counts as expertise, and whether the person being described by an institution has any meaningful ability to answer that description.
2. Liberal democracy therefore contains two different ideas of equality
Political equality does not mean that all citizens possess equal knowledge about every subject. A physician may know more about medicine than a farmer, an engineer may know more about structural safety than a shopkeeper, and an economist may understand monetary policy better than most citizens. Democracy does not require pretending otherwise. What political equality means is something different: difference in knowledge does not automatically become difference in political worth.
This distinction is fundamental because the possession of superior knowledge in one field does not necessarily confer superior authority over the purposes for which that knowledge is used. An engineer can determine whether a bridge is structurally safe, but the engineer does not thereby acquire the right to decide whether a community should be displaced to build it. A public-health expert can explain the likely consequences of an epidemic-control measure, but expertise in epidemiology does not automatically answer the social question of how the burdens of that measure should be distributed. Expertise can establish facts and consequences, but democratic judgment must still determine how competing human interests are to be reconciled. The danger begins when an epistemic difference is silently converted into a political hierarchy, so that knowing more about something becomes a justification for having more authority over those who must live with the consequences.
3. The historical paradox is that liberal ideas were largely developed by educated and privileged men
The language of freedom, reason, autonomy and constitutional government was developed within societies in which education and political participation were highly unequal. Philosophical reflection in the ancient world could coexist with slavery, and sophisticated political thought could coexist with the exclusion of women, labourers, foreigners and subordinated populations. Modern liberalism expanded the language of universal rights, but many of its influential thinkers nevertheless retained the assumption that education and civilization determined the quality of political judgment.
This created a question that liberalism never completely resolved. If freedom is universal, who has the authority to decide whether a person is sufficiently educated, rational or civilized to exercise that freedom? The moment someone else acquires that authority, equality becomes conditional, because the citizen is no longer simply a political subject possessing equal standing but becomes someone whose capacity for citizenship is assessed by another person. The historical movement toward universal suffrage can therefore be understood as more than an expansion of the electorate. It was also a rejection of the proposition that political competence should be certified by a superior social class before political equality can be granted.
4. Mill identified a genuine democratic danger, but his proposed solution contains the problem within itself
John Stuart Mill's fear of the tyranny of the majority cannot simply be dismissed. A majority can suppress minorities, impose conformity, punish unpopular opinions and restrict individuality without becoming formally dictatorial. Social pressure can be as oppressive as legal coercion, and majorities can be moved by fear, prejudice, misinformation, anger and identity. History provides abundant examples in which majorities have supported discriminatory laws, censorship, religious persecution or political movements that subsequently weakened democratic institutions themselves.
The difficulty begins when the legitimate observation that citizens can be mistaken becomes the argument that some citizens should possess greater political weight because they are judged to be better educated. Mill's proposal for plural voting is particularly revealing because it attempts to preserve democracy while introducing an unequal distribution of political influence according to education. The intention may be paternalistic rather than authoritarian, but the underlying assumption remains that some citizens are sufficiently competent to deserve greater political weight than others. This is why paternalistic democracy is a better description of the position than “patriarchist democracy.” The central issue is not primarily male authority over women or household authority over dependants. It is epistemic paternalism, in which people are permitted to participate politically while a supposedly more competent group is given greater influence for their own good and the good of society.
5. Mill becomes particularly important when his democratic and imperial positions are considered together
The problem becomes more serious when Mill's views on political representation are considered alongside his arguments about societies that had not yet reached what he regarded as the stage of civilization necessary for self-government. The connection should not be simplified into the claim that his arguments on domestic representation and imperial government were literally identical, because they operated in different contexts. But they reveal a common willingness to treat political capacity as something that can be assessed by a superior authority and then used to justify unequal political agency.
That is precisely the danger of paternalistic democracy. It does not necessarily deny that the other person is human, rational or valuable. It says that another person may be allowed to decide when your judgment is mature enough to count. The political problem is therefore not solved by making the paternalist more benevolent. The problem lies in the position from which the paternalist judges, because the very act of determining another person's readiness for political agency places the judge above the person being judged.
6. Education does not automatically protect democracy because educated people can become highly effective servants of domination
The history of the twentieth century makes this limitation impossible to ignore. Martin Heidegger was an exceptionally influential philosopher and became rector of Freiburg University under the Nazi regime. Carl Schmitt was a major legal theorist whose work provided intellectual support for authoritarian conceptions of sovereignty and emergency power and who became an important jurist under the Nazi regime. Their cases demonstrate something that democratic theory must take seriously: education, intellectual sophistication and professional achievement do not automatically produce democratic judgment.
The lesson is not that scholarship is dangerous or that intelligence has no value. It is that intelligence can be placed in the service of radically different political ends. A highly educated person can rationalize domination more effectively than an uneducated person, while expertise can expose injustice but can also provide the language through which injustice is made respectable. The question therefore cannot simply be whether citizens are educated. It must be what kind of intellectual formation their education produces and whether it gives them the capacity to question the purposes to which their knowledge is being put.
7. The Indian experience makes the problem still deeper because knowledge itself could be monopolized
The history of caste introduces an additional dimension that cannot be reduced to the European history of educated elites. In the Indian social order, access to learning was historically structured by birth, and hereditary hierarchy could be intellectually defended from within learned traditions. This meant that knowledge was not merely unequally distributed. The distribution of knowledge itself could become part of the mechanism through which hierarchy was reproduced.
Ambedkar's importance in this context lies precisely in his insistence that caste could not be explained merely as popular prejudice or social habit. The system had intellectual, religious and institutional foundations, and the monopoly of learning helped sustain the authority of those who benefited from it. The Indian example therefore demonstrates a more fundamental proposition: controlling who may acquire knowledge is itself an exercise of political power. The sequence becomes circular when those who control knowledge use that knowledge to justify why others should not possess it. Exclusion from knowledge produces a knowledge monopoly; the monopoly produces authority; authority legitimizes exclusion; and exclusion reproduces the monopoly. The problem is therefore not simply unequal education. It is the possibility of constructing a social order in which educational inequality becomes a justification for political inequality.
8. Education and intellectual formation must therefore be distinguished
Education cannot be reduced to the accumulation of information, qualifications and technical competence. A person may possess several degrees, remember an enormous number of facts, master complicated procedures and perform extremely difficult professional tasks while remaining intellectually dependent upon the authority that taught them what to believe. Such a person may be highly trained without being intellectually independent.
The democratic purpose of education is therefore not simply to produce people who know the accepted answer. It is to develop people capable of asking why that answer is accepted, what evidence supports it, what assumptions lie beneath it, who benefits from it, what alternative interpretations exist and whether the conclusion survives criticism. The educated citizen should be capable of examining even the framework through which they have been educated. Education without questioning can become trained obedience, education without exposure to competing interpretations can become intellectual enclosure, and education without the capacity to revise one's own position can become a more sophisticated form of dogmatism. The purpose of education in a democracy is not to produce agreement; it is to produce independent judgment capable of participating in disagreement.
9. Independent judgment is therefore more important to democracy than educational credentials alone
The distinction between information and judgment becomes crucial here. Information tells a person what is claimed. Knowledge provides some understanding of why the claim may be true. Judgment requires the capacity to compare competing claims, evaluate evidence, recognize uncertainty, understand consequences and revise one's position.
A student who can reproduce a textbook's conclusion but cannot explain why competing explanations were rejected has acquired information without full intellectual independence. A citizen who can listen to an argument, identify its assumptions, test its evidence, recognize its strengths and weaknesses and change their mind when warranted possesses something much closer to democratic judgment. This means that democratic education should not be measured only by literacy rates, years of schooling, degrees or examination scores. These are important, but they are incomplete indicators. A democracy requires citizens who can question authority without assuming that authority is always wrong, trust expertise without surrendering judgment, disagree without treating disagreement as treason, and change their position without experiencing intellectual change as personal defeat.
10. Arendt exposes the failure of judgment inside highly educated institutions
Hannah Arendt's work provides another important warning because it challenges the assumption that serious wrongdoing must arise from ignorance or extraordinary evil personalities. Her reflections on totalitarianism and the Eichmann case directed attention toward the failure of thinking and judgment within organized systems. A person can be competent, educated, efficient and professionally successful while failing to examine the assumptions embedded in what they are doing.
The administrative official who implements an unjust order efficiently may know the rules perfectly. The scientist who refuses to consider how their discovery will be used may possess extraordinary scientific competence. The administrator who follows a classification without asking whether the classification accurately represents the person may be an excellent bureaucrat. The problem in each case is not lack of knowledge in the narrow sense. It is the inability or unwillingness to think from outside the institutional framework that has already defined the situation. This makes judgment a democratic virtue because democracy requires people who can interrupt the smooth functioning of an institution by asking whether the institution is functioning for the right purpose.
11. Sen provides a different route by shifting attention from formal rights to substantive capabilities
Amartya Sen's account of democracy as public reasoning is important because it refuses to treat elections as the complete meaning of democratic participation. Democracy involves discussion, argument, contestation and the expansion of people's substantive capabilities. The significance of this approach is that a formal right becomes meaningful only when people possess the actual conditions necessary to use it.
A person may have the right to vote but lack the time to understand competing policies. They may have the right to appeal an administrative decision but lack the money to travel to the relevant office. They may have freedom of expression but lack access to the institutions through which expression can influence public decisions. They may possess a smartphone containing vast amounts of information but lack the time, education or methodological ability to determine which information is reliable. The democratic answer is therefore not to give more political weight to people who already possess knowledge. It is to expand the conditions under which more people can acquire knowledge, deliberate with others and exercise judgment.
12. This becomes especially important in the postindustrial knowledge economy
The transformation from industrial to postindustrial society has altered the relationship between economic power, education and political influence. Industrial production required large numbers of workers, and workers often shared workplaces, neighbourhoods, occupational identities and common economic interests. Their concentration made collective organization possible, and labour organizations could convert economic dependence into political bargaining power.
The postindustrial economy relies increasingly on specialized knowledge, digital technologies, professional credentials, data, information systems and cognitive skills. Economic opportunity is therefore increasingly concentrated around those who possess forms of knowledge that the new economy rewards. Universities, technology firms, financial institutions, professional organizations, government agencies and specialized media organizations consequently acquire increasing importance. This does not mean that every educated person becomes wealthy or powerful, nor that every less-educated person becomes economically marginalized. The structural point is different. Educational credentials increasingly influence access not only to income but also to institutions, networks, cultural authority and political influence. The knowledge hierarchy therefore becomes an important component of the new social hierarchy.
13. Economic transformation can therefore create an educated elite without intending to create one
The educated elite of the contemporary world does not necessarily constitute a conspiratorial class. It can emerge from ordinary institutional processes. The economy rewards particular forms of knowledge; universities provide credentials for those forms of knowledge; employers use those credentials to allocate opportunities; professional institutions reproduce standards; governments recruit specialists; media organizations employ educated professionals; and technology platforms rely upon highly specialized technical expertise.
The same educational and occupational groups can therefore become influential across many institutions without having deliberately organized themselves as a ruling class. Their power emerges from their location within the institutional structure. The democratic concern is not that educated people have influence, because a complex society could not function otherwise. The concern is that the people who possess the knowledge required to operate institutions can gradually become the people who decide what counts as a reasonable political possibility in the first place.
14. The new hierarchy is therefore not simply a hierarchy of income but a hierarchy of knowledge
Modern democracies have largely rejected formal political distinctions based upon education. We no longer generally say that a graduate should possess two votes while a person without a degree should possess one. Universal suffrage formally rejects that principle.
Yet knowledge continues to produce influence through less visible channels. Experts decide which policy proposals are technically feasible. Professional institutions determine what counts as legitimate expertise. Universities determine which forms of knowledge acquire prestige. Media organizations select which issues deserve attention. Governments classify populations through administrative categories. Digital platforms rank information. Financial institutions determine which risks are acceptable. Technology companies construct systems through which millions of people encounter the world.
The formal political hierarchy may therefore have disappeared while a knowledge hierarchy has become embedded within institutions.
15. Information abundance has made selection more important rather than less important
The digital age initially appeared to promise the democratization of knowledge. A person with an internet connection can now access documents, lectures, research, archives and arguments that previously required entry into elite institutions. This is an extraordinary expansion of access.
But information abundance creates another problem. No person can meaningfully process the enormous quantity of information available to them. Attention becomes scarce precisely when information becomes abundant. The citizen therefore depends increasingly upon systems that select, rank, filter, summarize and personalize information. The democratic question consequently changes. It is no longer sufficient to ask whether information is available. We must ask who selects what becomes visible, according to which criteria, with what possibility of correction, and with what consequences for the citizen's ability to form an independent judgment.
The algorithm is not necessarily the enemy here. Editors, teachers, governments, search engines, social-media platforms, experts and citizens themselves all perform acts of selection. The important issue is that selection creates the informational environment within which judgment takes place.
16. The problem is therefore not simply information inequality but the unequal capacity to turn information into knowledge
Two citizens may possess access to the same digital information while possessing radically different capacities to use it. One may have time to investigate, compare sources, read methodological material, consult experts and examine competing interpretations. Another may work ten hours a day, care for children, face financial insecurity and encounter information primarily through short messages or social-media fragments.
The difference is not simply access to information. It is access to time, interpretive capacity, institutional support and opportunities for verification. This is why the democratization of information cannot be measured merely by the number of people who possess smartphones or internet connections. A democracy must ask whether citizens have the substantive capability to convert information into independent judgment. The digital citizen can be formally connected while remaining epistemically dependent.
17. Knowledge becomes political when institutions use it to classify human beings
The problem becomes still deeper when knowledge is not merely used to inform citizens but is used by institutions to define citizens. Modern administration depends upon records, classifications, categories, scores, databases and eligibility criteria. These instruments are necessary for large-scale government, but they also create a fundamental asymmetry: the institution possesses a description of the person, while the person may have little power to alter the description.
A person becomes poor because a survey places them below a threshold. A cultivator becomes eligible or ineligible because a land record recognizes or fails to recognize their relationship to land. A student becomes successful or unsuccessful because an examination assigns a score. A citizen becomes high-risk or low-risk because a system assigns a category. A welfare applicant becomes eligible or ineligible because a database matches or fails to match particular fields. The record is then treated as though it were the person. This is where the problem of knowledge becomes a problem of power.
18. The survey that decides who is poor illustrates the problem with unusual clarity
Consider the administrative practice of identifying a household as poor by converting its material circumstances into a series of measurable indicators. A survey may record the kind of roof the household possesses, the number of rooms, whether there is a fan, bicycle, television or telephone, whether the family owns land or cattle, and whether any member has a salaried occupation. Each individual observation may be entirely accurate. The roof exists, the fan exists, the bicycle exists, and the household owns exactly what the record says it owns.
Yet the resulting description can still be profoundly inadequate because the form may not ask how the household arrived at its present condition. A household may be poor because it has been landless for generations, because an inherited occupation ceased to provide a livelihood, because a member's illness consumed the family's savings, because a public project displaced its land, because compensation was delayed, because a promised scheme did not reach it, because a crop failed repeatedly, or because a combination of such events pushed it below the economic threshold. Another household may possess exactly the same material belongings while having arrived there through a completely different history. The two households can therefore receive the same score even though one condition is hereditary and the other is system-generated.
The administrative record is accurate about possessions but incapable of representing the causal history of deprivation. It can therefore transform poverty from a social history into a collection of objects. The household becomes poor because the data says it is poor, but the data may never ask why the household became poor, whether the deprivation is inherited, whether it has been produced by institutional failure, or whether a public intervention itself contributed to the condition. This distinction is crucial because two households with identical possessions can require completely different forms of public action. One may need long-term structural opportunity, another may need compensation, another may need access to health care, another may need recognition of an occupational or tenancy relationship, and another may need restoration of an entitlement wrongly denied. Datafication can make the household visible while simultaneously making its history invisible.
The problem is therefore not that the data is false. The problem is that the data is true only within the narrow reality that the form has been designed to see.
19. The cultivator who bears the risk but does not appear in the land record presents the same problem
The second example concerns the person who wishes to obtain crop insurance but does not own the agricultural land they cultivate. In a sharecropping or batai arrangement, the person who actually cultivates the land may provide the labour, purchase seed and other inputs, pay for irrigation, supervise cultivation and bear the economic consequences if the crop fails, while the formal land record continues to identify someone else as the owner.
The contradiction becomes especially sharp when access to insurance is organized around the ownership record rather than around the person who actually bears the agricultural risk. The cultivator may therefore be the person who most needs insurance and yet the person least visible to the administrative system through which insurance is accessed.
The difficulty is not necessarily that the policy deliberately excludes the cultivator. It can arise because the policy is designed around a legally legible category, while the actual agricultural economy contains relationships that are socially and economically real but administratively invisible. The landowner may appear in the record even though they do not cultivate the crop, while the bataidar who bears the risk may possess no documentary relationship through which the scheme can recognize them.
The result is a striking separation between the person to whom the law attaches the land and the person to whom the economy attaches the risk. This example shows why eligibility and accessibility must be distinguished. A scheme may be generous in its formal intention and yet inaccessible to the person for whom the need is greatest because the institutional door has been constructed around a record rather than around the actual activity. The problem is therefore not merely one of welfare design. It is a problem of knowledge: the state knows the landowner because the land record contains the landowner, but it does not necessarily know the cultivator because the institutional record has no place for the relationship through which cultivation actually occurs.
20. The ordinary experience of identity verification reveals the same structure
The third example is smaller and more ordinary, and for that reason it shows the structure perhaps more clearly than a large welfare programme. Consider the experience of applying for or obtaining a SIM card when the identity-verification system does not properly recognize the applicant. A person may stand before the official with documents and with the lived certainty of who they are, while the institutional system displays an entry that does not match the person.
The system does not necessarily conclude that the person is lying. It may simply conclude that the person cannot be matched to the record. The institutional problem is therefore not necessarily fraud detection but the inability of the system to accommodate the person whose identity does not fit the form in the expected manner.
At that moment the person encounters a profound asymmetry. The institution sees the record as authoritative because the institution operates through the record. The individual sees the record as incomplete or mistaken because the individual possesses a history that the record cannot contain. Yet if there is no meaningful procedure through which the person can place that history into the system, the institutional description becomes more powerful than the person it describes.
The clerk may not be the source of the problem. The clerk may simply be reading what the system permits them to see. The deeper problem is that there is no institutional space in which the person can answer the description. The personal experience matters precisely because it reveals how a seemingly insignificant administrative failure can reproduce the same structure found in poverty identification and crop insurance. The person does not necessarily need another rule. They need a route through which the institution can hear the explanation that its record cannot see.
21. These examples reveal what can be called “abstraction without return”
A common structure connects the poverty survey, the land record, identity verification, algorithmic classification and many other administrative processes. A person enters an institution. The institution converts the person into information. The information travels upward into a decision. The decision returns to the person. But the person's own explanation does not necessarily travel back into the record.
This can be described as abstraction without return, meaning that the person is abstracted into data, but the data does not remain open to the person whose life it represents. The citizen becomes an object of knowledge without becoming a participant in the production and correction of that knowledge.
This is more than a bureaucratic inconvenience. If an institutional description determines access to food, insurance, education, employment, identity, mobility or political participation, then the inability to correct the description becomes a limitation upon agency itself. The democratic question therefore changes from “Is the citizen eligible?” to a prior question: “Does the citizen have the ability to participate in the institutional production of the facts upon which eligibility will be decided?”
22. This is where Foucault becomes useful, but he must not be reduced to the claim that all knowledge is domination
Foucault's analysis of power and knowledge helps explain why institutions such as schools, hospitals, prisons, examinations and administrative offices do not merely apply knowledge that already exists. They also produce categories, records, norms and classifications through which people become knowable and governable.
The examination is an especially revealing example because it does several things simultaneously. It measures the individual, produces a record, compares the individual with others, establishes a norm and gives the institution a basis for action. The student becomes an object of knowledge through the process that is supposed to evaluate them.
Yet it would be a mistake to conclude that knowledge is therefore inherently oppressive. Scientific knowledge can expose environmental destruction. Statistics can reveal inequality. Historical scholarship can recover suppressed experiences. Records can establish that a person exists when the state previously ignored them. A land record can exclude a cultivator, but a properly designed land record can also protect them. The problem is therefore not knowledge itself. The problem is knowledge that becomes authoritative without becoming answerable.
23. Expertise can therefore be necessary and still become democratically inadequate
A modern society cannot determine the safety of a nuclear reactor by majority vote. Citizens cannot collectively calculate every epidemiological model, bridge load, banking risk or climate projection. Expertise exists because reality imposes constraints upon human preference. A bridge either carries its load or it does not. A virus behaves according to biological processes whether or not citizens agree with the relevant scientific explanation.
A democratic critique of technocracy must therefore not become a rejection of expertise. The proper question is more precise: what authority does expertise legitimately possess, and what does the citizen retain the right to decide? An expert may legitimately determine whether a particular bridge design is structurally sound. That does not give the expert the right to determine whether the community should accept the social costs of the project without political deliberation. A doctor may possess superior medical knowledge, but that does not eliminate the patient's agency. A climate scientist may explain the consequences of different energy policies, but democratic institutions must still decide how the costs and benefits are distributed. The distinction is between technical authority over means and democratic authority over purposes, values and distribution.
24. The failure occurs when technical rationality mistakes the measurable objective for the whole human situation
Real-world experience repeatedly demonstrates this danger. Agricultural modernization in Punjab and Haryana dramatically increased agricultural productivity, while the same development model subsequently became associated with groundwater depletion, changing cropping patterns and environmental stress in the regions where it had been most successful. Urban resettlement programmes in Delhi have provided formal housing to relocated households while, in some cases, placing them far from employment, schools, transport and the informal networks through which livelihoods were sustained. The nationwide lockdown announced in March 2020 was based upon an urgent public-health rationale, yet its extremely short notice imposed extraordinary costs upon people whose livelihoods depended upon daily movement and daily wages, producing the mass movement of migrant workers that followed. Competitive examination systems can produce measurable rankings and standardized outcomes while simultaneously generating an enormous coaching industry and imposing intense pressures upon students competing for a small number of seats.
In each case, the expertise can be genuine. The problem is not necessarily that the expert calculation is wrong. The problem is that the calculation has defined the relevant reality too narrowly. A technically successful intervention can therefore be socially unsuccessful because the people who designed it measured what could easily be measured and omitted what was difficult to measure.
25. This is the point at which “lived experience” becomes knowledge rather than anecdote
The response to technical expertise should not be romantic populism in which every personal experience automatically defeats scientific evidence. Lived experience can also be mistaken, incomplete and shaped by prejudice. But lived experience possesses a kind of knowledge that technical systems frequently lack: it reveals consequences that are invisible from the position of the designer.
The person who receives the welfare decision knows what the classification does to their household. The cultivator knows who actually bears the agricultural risk. The relocated family knows whether the new settlement permits them to maintain employment. The worker knows what an algorithmically determined work schedule does to daily life. The student knows what an examination regime does to the structure of learning.
This does not mean that lived experience should replace expertise. It means that expertise should be required to encounter lived experience before it claims to have described the whole situation.
26. The citizen therefore requires a right to answer the institutional description
This leads to a principle that should be placed at the centre of democratic administration: every consequential institutional description of a person should be answerable by the person it describes.
If a state classifies someone as poor, the person should be able to explain circumstances that the classification does not capture. If a welfare system rejects an application, the person should receive a reason that can be understood and contested. If a database declares that identity cannot be verified, the person should have a meaningful way to demonstrate why the record is wrong. If an automated system produces a consequential decision, an identifiable human authority should be capable of reviewing it.
This is not a demand that every citizen become an expert programmer, statistician, lawyer or economist. It is a demand that expert systems leave an intelligible institutional path through which the non-expert citizen can answer them.
27. Five institutional conditions follow from this principle
First, the criteria by which a consequential decision will be made should be publicly known before the decision is taken rather than reconstructed afterwards as a justification for an outcome. A citizen cannot meaningfully contest a rule that becomes visible only after they have been excluded by it.
Second, the decision should be communicated in writing and, as far as reasonably possible, in a language the applicant can understand, identifying the rule applied, the relevant facts and the institutional authority responsible for the decision. Accountability cannot exist where the citizen does not know what decision was made or who made it.
Third, the person should have the right to place their own account upon the record. This is the most important requirement because it changes the record from a description produced exclusively by the institution into a record that can incorporate the experience of the person described. The citizen should not merely be allowed to submit another document; they should possess the right to add a relevant account of the circumstances that the institutional form fails to capture.
Fourth, there should be an identifiable human authority capable of reviewing and, where justified, overriding an automated or standardized outcome. Human review is meaningful only if the human being possesses actual authority rather than merely the ability to repeat what the system has already decided.
Fifth, institutions should publish patterns of rejection, exclusion and error and subject them to independent scrutiny. Individual mistakes become democratic problems when the institution cannot determine whether they are isolated incidents or systematic patterns. These requirements do not abolish expertise. They make expertise answerable.
28. A right that is expensive to exercise is not an equally usable right
The question of appeal demonstrates why formal rights are insufficient. A person who wishes to challenge an administrative decision may first need to discover that the decision exists, understand the reason for it, travel to an office, lose a day's wages, obtain copies of documents, find assistance in completing forms and repeat the process if the first attempt fails.
For a wealthy person, the cost may be inconvenient. For a poor household, the cost may exceed the value of the entitlement being contested.
The right formally exists in both cases, but the capability to use it does not. This is precisely where Sen's distinction between formal rights and substantive capabilities becomes important. A right that cannot practically be exercised is a weaker democratic right than its legal wording suggests. Accessibility is therefore not a minor administrative question. It is part of democratic equality.
29. Accessibility must therefore be treated as an institutional resource
There is an uncomfortable consequence to this argument. Meaningful accessibility requires staff, time and institutional attention. It cannot be created simply by placing another digital form online.
If a citizen must explain their circumstances, someone must have time to hear the explanation. If a record must be corrected, someone must possess the authority to correct it. If an appeal must be meaningful, someone must investigate it. If an automated decision requires human review, the human reviewer must possess both time and authority.
The state therefore cannot honestly promise perfect accessibility while continuously reducing the personnel required to provide it. The real cost of democratic accessibility is often paid in human attention rather than software. A system that saves administrative time by removing human discretion may simultaneously transfer the cost of error to the citizen. The poor citizen then becomes the unpaid worker correcting the state's database.
30. The new democratic divide is consequently a divide in time, capacity and institutional access
The most important social division is not simply between educated and uneducated people. It is between people who possess the education, time, resources, contacts and institutional confidence necessary to investigate and contest complicated systems and people who must accept the interpretation produced by institutions they cannot independently evaluate.
This produces a new form of dependence. A citizen may be legally free, formally equal and politically enfranchised while depending upon others for the description of the world within which that freedom is exercised. The dependence becomes particularly dangerous when it is invisible. A person does not experience themselves as being governed by a theory of knowledge. They simply encounter a form, a score, a search result, a database, an eligibility decision or an administrative refusal. The political hierarchy has therefore moved into the machinery of everyday life.
31. The old paternalism has not disappeared; it has changed its institutional form
The educated no longer generally receive additional votes merely because they possess degrees. But the underlying paternalistic impulse can survive through institutions that presume that experts know what citizens need while citizens possess only limited authority to question the framework itself.
This is a more subtle form of paternalism because it does not announce itself as political inequality. It appears as efficiency, standardization, professional competence, evidence-based policy, algorithmic accuracy or administrative rationality. These values are not themselves objectionable. The danger lies in allowing them to become self-authenticating sources of authority.
An expert says that the system is accurate because the model was designed correctly. The institution says the model is legitimate because experts designed it. The citizen's contrary experience is treated as anecdotal because it does not fit the model. The system therefore becomes incapable of learning from the person it governs. That is paternalism without a paternalist standing visibly before the citizen.
32. Democracy requires not only the right to judge but the right to be heard when one is judged
This may be the deepest extension of the argument.
Classical democratic theory asks whether citizens possess the right to judge their rulers. Modern administrative democracy must add another question: do citizens possess the right to answer the judgments institutions make about them?
The first concerns political participation, whereas the second concerns administrative agency. A citizen votes on who governs the country, but they also encounter thousands of smaller institutional judgments concerning identity, eligibility, employment, education, taxation, welfare, credit, mobility and access. If those judgments cannot be questioned, democratic participation at the national level cannot fully compensate for powerlessness at the institutional level. Democracy must therefore operate not only at the level of elections but at the points where institutional descriptions become consequences in people's lives.
33. This also changes the meaning of freedom
Freedom cannot be understood only as protection from direct interference. A person can be formally free while being trapped inside an institutional description they cannot change.
The person who is classified incorrectly, excluded from a scheme, denied insurance because their tenancy is invisible, or rejected because an identity record does not match may possess every formal constitutional freedom while experiencing a profound absence of practical agency. Freedom therefore requires some capacity to correct the conditions under which institutions act upon you.
This is why answerability belongs within liberal freedom itself. The citizen should not merely be free to speak somewhere outside the institution. They should have a meaningful opportunity to speak into the decision that governs them.
34. The issue of dissent follows directly from this argument
Once a society accepts that citizens must be capable of questioning institutional descriptions, it must also protect disagreement about political knowledge. Governments have legitimate responsibilities to maintain public order and protect citizens from violence, but the category of dangerous opinion must not become so broad that criticism itself is treated as evidence of danger.
History demonstrates the problem. Anti-colonial movements were once described by imperial governments as threats to order. Labour movements were often treated as threats to property and social stability. Anti-caste movements were frequently portrayed as attacks upon established social order. Ideas that institutions classified as disruptive could later become central to democratic transformation.
The lesson is not that every dissenting idea is correct. It is that the institution cannot be the sole judge of whether criticism of the institution is legitimate.
35. The right to dissent must therefore protect even arguments with which we disagree
This principle becomes meaningful only when it is applied to unpopular positions. If freedom of assembly is defended only for those demanding something one supports, the principle has not actually been defended. If speech is protected only when its content is agreeable, the right has become a privilege of ideological conformity.
A democratic principle must survive the moment when it protects the person with whom we disagree. This is particularly important when governments invoke public order to restrict demonstrations. There are circumstances in which restrictions are justified, particularly where there is a credible threat of violence or serious disruption. But restrictions must be necessary, proportionate, reviewable and subject to legal challenge. A general prohibition that prevents assembly in advance can become problematic because the citizen is required to prove why they should be allowed to exercise a right that the Constitution presumptively protects.
The principle is therefore not that all restrictions are illegitimate. It is that restrictions on democratic agency must themselves be subject to democratic justification.
36. Persuasion and social engineering must be kept distinct
A democracy necessarily tries to persuade its citizens. Constitutional societies teach equality, dignity, tolerance, pluralism and peaceful disagreement because these principles are necessary for democratic coexistence. There is nothing inherently undemocratic about defending democratic values.
The line is crossed when persuasion ceases to treat the citizen as an agent capable of judgment and begins to treat the citizen as material that must be shaped into the correct political form. Persuasion treats the citizen as an agent who should encounter reasons, examine evidence, consider competing arguments and ultimately make an independent judgment, whereas social engineering treats the citizen less as an agent capable of forming and revising their own judgment and more as material whose attitudes, preferences or behaviour must be deliberately shaped toward a predetermined outcome. The distinction is therefore not simply between two techniques of communication, but between two conceptions of democratic citizenship, because the first accepts the continuing independence of the person being persuaded while the second becomes problematic precisely when the desired political or social outcome is regarded as sufficiently important to justify reducing that person's capacity to question the process through which they are being shaped.
37. Liberal democracy therefore needs a new conception of the educated citizen
The educated citizen should not be defined simply as a person with credentials. Nor should they be defined as a person who possesses the correct political opinions.
The educated democratic citizen is someone capable of independent judgment under conditions of disagreement. They can recognize expertise without surrendering agency. They can recognize uncertainty without becoming indifferent to evidence. They can criticize institutions without assuming that every institution is corrupt. They can change their mind without regarding revision as weakness. They can defend their own interests while recognizing the political standing of others.
This conception of education is much more demanding than credentialism, but it is also more democratic because it understands education as the development of the capacity to participate intelligently in a world of disagreement rather than as the acquisition of a socially approved collection of credentials and conclusions.
38. The task is not to eliminate knowledge hierarchies but to prevent them from becoming political hierarchies
A complex civilization will always contain differences in knowledge. There will always be specialists, professionals, teachers, researchers, administrators and experts whose knowledge in particular domains exceeds that of ordinary citizens. The democratic objective is therefore not epistemic equality in the sense that everyone must know the same things, because that is neither possible nor desirable.
The objective is epistemic equality of standing, meaning the principle that differences in specialized knowledge do not erase the citizen's right to question, understand, participate and answer decisions that affect them. Experts can legitimately possess greater knowledge in their fields, but this does not make them more of a citizen than the person who lacks that specialized knowledge and must nevertheless live with the consequences of the expert decision. Epistemic superiority in a particular field may justify technical authority within that field, but it cannot by itself justify a superior status as a political subject.
39. This provides a new meaning of democratic equality
Democratic equality should therefore be understood as having at least three interconnected dimensions. The first is political equality, through which citizens possess equal political standing. The second is substantive capability, through which citizens possess the actual means to exercise their rights. The third is epistemic answerability, through which institutions that produce knowledge about citizens remain open to correction by the citizens they describe.
Political equality protects the citizen's right to participate, substantive capability makes that participation usable, and epistemic answerability prevents institutions from becoming permanently authoritative over the people they govern. Together these dimensions produce a richer conception of democratic citizenship because they connect the formal equality of the ballot with the practical equality required in the institutions of everyday life.
40. The earlier crisis of shared prosperity and the newer crisis of knowledge are actually connected
Economic inequality cannot be separated from epistemic inequality. The person who must work every available hour has less time to investigate public policy. The household that cannot afford transportation has less capacity to challenge an administrative decision. The student who cannot afford supplementary education enters an examination system with fewer opportunities to convert information into performance. The worker without institutional representation has less ability to contest the knowledge produced by the employer about their productivity.
Economic inequality therefore affects the capacity to know, to question and to answer. This is why the earlier democratic concern with shared prosperity must remain part of the present argument. Self-government, community and shared prosperity are not separate from knowledge and education. They are conditions under which knowledge can become democratic rather than hierarchical.
41. Community matters because judgment is not produced by isolated individuals
Independent judgment does not mean solitary judgment. People acquire intellectual independence through conversation, disagreement, association, education and participation in institutions. A person who has nobody with whom to discuss a political claim is more dependent upon the informational environment supplied by powerful institutions.
Community therefore has an epistemic function. Associations, unions, voluntary organizations, local institutions, libraries, schools, public forums and civic organizations create spaces in which citizens can compare experiences and discover that what appears to be an individual problem may actually be a structural one. A worker who thinks they alone are experiencing unfair treatment may discover through collective organization that the problem is institutional. A family that believes it alone has been excluded from a welfare scheme may discover that hundreds of households face the same administrative barrier. Collective experience converts private confusion into public knowledge, because people begin to understand their circumstances not merely as isolated personal failures but as experiences that can be examined collectively.
42. This is why democratic institutions must create opportunities for citizens to learn from one another
Public reasoning cannot be reduced to experts explaining policy to citizens. It also requires citizens explaining their experiences to one another and to institutions.
The flow of knowledge must therefore be multidirectional. Knowledge must move from experts to citizens because citizens need reliable information, while knowledge must move from citizens to institutions because institutions need knowledge of lived consequences. Knowledge must also move among citizens because individuals need collective comparison to understand their own experiences, and knowledge must be capable of returning to the system in corrected form because otherwise the institution learns nothing from those it governs. This multidirectional movement of knowledge is the opposite of abstraction without return.
43. The democratic institution should therefore be conceived as a learning institution
A healthy institution should not merely classify citizens. It should learn from them.
A welfare programme should be able to discover which categories systematically exclude people who are substantively eligible. A school should be able to discover when examination methods are producing undesirable forms of learning. A health system should be able to identify where formal accessibility differs from actual accessibility. An agricultural programme should be able to discover when the person bearing the risk is absent from the official record.
The institution that cannot learn from the people it governs eventually becomes incapable of distinguishing its own model of reality from reality itself. Democratic accountability should therefore include institutional capacity to learn, because a system that cannot receive correction from the people it governs will eventually mistake the categories it has created for the social reality those categories were originally intended to represent.
44. The deepest danger is not that experts will know too much, but that institutions will stop listening
Experts are not the fundamental problem. Institutions that refuse to be corrected are. Knowledge becomes dangerous when it becomes closed to the experience of those whom it classifies. A sophisticated model can be corrected, a highly trained expert can change their mind, a database can be redesigned, and a policy can be revised, but none of these possibilities matters if the institution treats its own representation as final.
The democratic citizen must therefore possess more than freedom of expression. They must possess institutional answerability, meaning that the institutions exercising knowledge and authority over them must remain capable of receiving, evaluating and incorporating relevant correction.
45. The principle can finally be stated in one sentence
The democratic problem was never that some people know more than others, because differences in knowledge are an unavoidable and often valuable feature of complex societies. The democratic problem begins when those who know more acquire the authority to define those who know less, while those being defined lose the institutional power to answer the definition, because that is the point at which epistemic inequality becomes political inequality.
46. The making of the citizen therefore requires more than universal suffrage
Universal suffrage was a revolutionary achievement because it rejected the idea that political citizenship should depend upon wealth, birth, property or education. But universal suffrage alone cannot complete the democratic project.
The modern citizen encounters institutions that make decisions every day. They encounter databases, forms, examinations, algorithms, eligibility criteria, professional judgments, rankings, risk assessments and administrative classifications. Their relationship with these systems determines much of the actual freedom they experience. The democratic project must therefore move from the right to participate in choosing rulers toward the capacity to participate in the production and correction of the knowledge through which people are governed.
47. Liberal democracy must consequently recover its three older commitments while adding a fourth
Self-government remains essential because citizens must possess meaningful influence over the conditions of their common life. Community remains essential because citizens cannot sustain democracy as isolated individuals without relationships of trust, association and mutual recognition. Shared prosperity remains essential because extreme economic insecurity undermines the practical ability to participate as an equal citizen.
But these three commitments now require a fourth: answerable knowledge. Citizens must be able to know what institutions know about them, understand why consequential decisions are made, contribute information about their own circumstances, challenge classifications and obtain meaningful review. Without this fourth element, the other three remain vulnerable because political equality without substantive capability can become merely formal, community without informational independence can become susceptible to manipulation, and shared prosperity without institutional answerability can still leave citizens subject to classifications they cannot correct.
48. The final question is therefore not who is fit to govern, but who is permitted to participate in defining reality
Mill's question was whether all citizens were equally capable of political judgment. Modern democracy should ask a more fundamental question: who decides what the citizen is, who decides who is poor, who decides who is eligible, who decides who is qualified, who decides what counts as merit, who decides which information is credible, who decides which risks matter, who decides which dissent is dangerous, who decides which history is recorded, and, most importantly, can the person who is being defined answer the definition?
These questions connect the classical problem of liberal paternalism with the contemporary problems of administrative classification, algorithmic governance and knowledge inequality. They shift democratic theory from the question of who receives political authority to the equally important question of who possesses authority over the descriptions through which political and administrative institutions understand human beings.
49. The citizen must finally be more than an object of knowledge
A liberal democracy cannot remain satisfied with a system in which institutions know citizens while citizens do not know how institutions know them. Nor can it remain satisfied with a system in which citizens are free to speak but unable to alter the institutional descriptions that determine their access to rights and resources.
The citizen must be both subject and participant in the production of public knowledge. The person being surveyed must have some ability to explain the life behind the numbers, the cultivator must be able to establish the activity behind the land record, the applicant must be able to answer the database, the student must be able to question the assumptions built into education, the worker must be able to contest the metrics by which their productivity is judged, and the citizen must be able to challenge the institutional description of their political conduct. This is not a demand that institutions abandon standards. It is a demand that standards remain answerable to the people upon whom they operate.
50. Conclusion: from the right to vote to the right to answer
The history of liberal democracy can be understood as a long struggle against the authority of one person or group to determine the political status of another without their participation. The struggle began against arbitrary rulers, inherited privilege and exclusion from political membership. Universal suffrage extended political standing. Civil liberties protected thought and expression. Public education expanded access to knowledge. Social democracy connected political citizenship with economic security and shared prosperity.
But the contemporary world has created a new problem. Power increasingly operates through knowledge, expertise, classification, information systems, algorithms, professional institutions and administrative records. The citizen may possess equal political rights while remaining unequal in the ability to understand, challenge and correct the knowledge through which institutions act upon them.
This creates the possibility of a new paternalism, more subtle than Mill's plural voting. The citizen is not told that their vote counts less. Instead, their circumstances are defined by a form, their eligibility by a database, their competence by a credential, their risk by an algorithm, their poverty by a score, their identity by a record and their political conduct by an institutional classification. The hierarchy is therefore no longer necessarily visible in the ballot box. It is embedded in the machinery through which everyday life is administered.
The answer cannot be to distrust knowledge, reject expertise or romanticize ignorance. A democratic society needs knowledge more than ever. The answer is to democratize the conditions under which knowledge exercises authority. Education must cultivate independent judgment rather than merely transmit approved conclusions. Expertise must remain within democratic accountability rather than becoming a substitute for it. Institutions must distinguish technical authority from political authority. Citizens must possess substantive capabilities rather than merely formal rights. Records must be capable of being corrected by the people they describe. Administrative decisions must be intelligible and contestable. And systems that classify citizens must leave an institutional path through which citizens can answer the classification.
This finally brings us back to the ordinary person standing before a form. The form asks what the household owns but not how the household came to own it, the record identifies the landowner but not the cultivator who bears the risk, the database recognizes the entry but not necessarily the person standing before the counter, the examination records the answer but may never ask whether the student has learned how to question the question, and the algorithm selects the information but does not necessarily reveal the world it has excluded. In every case, the danger is the same: a representation of the person is produced elsewhere and then treated as more authoritative than the person themselves.
The democratic problem was therefore never that some people are unfit to judge. It is that the people being judged may not be present when the judgment is constructed, may not know how it was constructed, and may have no meaningful means of answering it. A mature liberal democracy must go beyond the principle that every citizen has one vote. It must establish the deeper principle that every citizen has a standing to answer the knowledge through which public institutions govern them, because that is where political equality becomes substantive, where education becomes democratic rather than merely credentialed, where expertise becomes accountable rather than paternalistic, where information becomes knowledge rather than manipulation, where administration becomes responsive rather than merely efficient, and where the citizen ceases to be merely an object of government and becomes, in the fullest sense, a participant in the making of the world in which they are governed.
Pages 19–21 — The Industrial Age, Shared Prosperity, and the Coming Postindustrial Transformation
These three pages are extremely important because Acemoglu is doing something more than simply describing the economic transition from an industrial to a postindustrial economy. He is trying to explain why liberal democracy was comparatively successful during the industrial age, why that success was not accidental, and why the economic transformation associated with the postindustrial age has created new difficulties for liberal democracy. His underlying question is: if liberal democracy once succeeded in combining economic growth, rising wages, political voice, public services, and social stability, why has that relationship become weaker in the contemporary economy?
1. What Acemoglu means by the “postindustrial age”
Acemoglu begins by defining the postindustrial age in a deliberately broad way. He is not referring merely to the replacement of factories by computers, automation, or digital technologies. The transformation is simultaneously economic, occupational, educational, social, and political. Manufacturing becomes less dominant, while health, education, administration, professional services, information, and knowledge-intensive occupations become increasingly important. At the same time, workplaces and society place greater emphasis on cognitive skills and college education.
This is a crucial distinction. If we understand the postindustrial age merely as “the age of computers,” we miss Acemoglu's deeper argument. The issue is not technology by itself but the changing relationship between technology, work, education, social status, political power, and economic opportunity. In the industrial age, large numbers of people could participate in production through relatively standardized forms of industrial labour, and workers could organize collectively around common working conditions and wages. In the postindustrial economy, productive activity increasingly depends upon specialized knowledge, education, information, managerial capacity, professional expertise, and cognitive skills. The structure through which people participate in the economy therefore changes, and this inevitably changes the social foundations upon which democracy operates.
2. Why did liberal democracies achieve “shared prosperity” in the industrial age?
Acemoglu's first major proposition is that liberal democracies achieved shared prosperity in the industrial age. The reason was not simply that industrialization generated economic growth. Industrial production itself required enormous numbers of workers. Factories needed labour; transportation systems needed workers; offices needed administrative staff; production required engineers, designers, managers, salespeople, and marketers. Because so many different activities depended upon human labour, economic expansion created a substantial demand for workers.
This produced an important political-economic relationship. When employers need large numbers of workers, workers acquire bargaining power. Their labour becomes economically valuable, and therefore their wages and working conditions become matters of economic and political importance. This does not automatically produce justice, because employers can still exploit workers, but it creates a structural possibility for workers to organize and demand a larger share of the prosperity generated by industrialization.
This is why Acemoglu's argument is different from the simplistic claim that capitalism naturally produces prosperity for everyone. It does not. The industrial economy produced enormous wealth, but whether that wealth became shared prosperity depended heavily upon institutions, regulation, organization, political participation, and bargaining power.
3. Democracy created an environment for knowledge accumulation
Acemoglu then makes an important connection between democracy and knowledge. Liberal democracy created what he calls a “propitious environment for building and sharing knowledge.” This includes scientific and technological knowledge, but also practical knowledge about how societies should organize themselves.
This second form of knowledge is particularly important. A society does not merely need to know how to manufacture more efficiently; it also needs to learn how to construct institutions capable of managing social change. How should labour relations be regulated? How should workers organize? How should public education be provided? How should health services be expanded? How should corporations be prevented from abusing their power? How should conflicts between labour and capital be negotiated?
Democratic societies possess mechanisms through which these questions can be contested, discussed, corrected, and institutionalized. Elections, legislatures, courts, unions, civil-society organizations, professional associations, universities, newspapers, and public debate all become mechanisms through which societies accumulate what we might call institutional knowledge. Democracy therefore contributes not merely by giving people a vote but by creating a social environment in which societies can experiment, learn, criticize existing arrangements, and adapt institutions to changing material conditions.
This point connects very strongly with the broader argument of the book: democracy is not merely a system for selecting rulers; it is also a system for collective learning and institutional adaptation.
4. The crucial role of labour organization
The next part of Acemoglu's argument is especially significant. One of democracy's key economic roles was to prevent companies and business associations from using their power to suppress wages or force workers into dangerous and unhealthy working conditions.
Notice the institutional mechanism here. Acemoglu does not say that democracy simply persuaded employers to become benevolent. Rather, democratic institutions made it possible to create rules that constrained private power. Workers could organize, unions could bargain, governments could regulate working conditions, and political movements could demand social legislation.
This is why regulation becomes central to his story. The market alone does not necessarily protect the weaker party in a relationship where one side possesses substantially greater economic power. A worker who individually negotiates with a powerful corporation may have very little bargaining capacity. Collective organization changes that relationship. The worker becomes part of a larger institutional actor capable of negotiating wages and working conditions.
The underlying principle can therefore be expressed as follows: liberal democracy made markets more compatible with social equality by placing political and legal constraints upon unequal economic power.
5. The Scandinavian model and the American New Deal
Acemoglu gives two particularly important examples of this democratic-market relationship. One is the social-democratic model that developed in Scandinavia from the 1930s onward, and the other is Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal in the United States.
The point of these examples is not that Sweden and the United States adopted identical institutions. They did not. Rather, they demonstrate two different ways in which democratic politics could respond to the tensions generated by industrial capitalism. Governments could allow markets to operate while simultaneously creating institutions that strengthened workers, expanded social protection, regulated corporations, and provided public goods.
This is what Acemoglu calls a democracy-market synergy. Democracy did not have to destroy markets in order to protect workers, and markets did not have to destroy democracy in order to generate growth. Under favourable institutional arrangements, the two could reinforce one another.
The result was a kind of social bargain: business could invest and make profits, while workers could receive higher wages, better conditions, social protection, and political voice. The bargain was never perfect, and Acemoglu explicitly warns us against imagining some harmonious industrial utopia. There were enormous inequalities, exclusions, racial hierarchies, gender inequalities, and differences between countries. But compared with earlier arrangements, democratic institutions created mechanisms through which the benefits of growth could become more broadly distributed.
6. The “Goldilocks problem” between labour and capital
Acemoglu's phrase “Goldilocks problem” is particularly useful. Democracy had to find a balance between labour and capital. Labour organizations needed sufficient strength so that they could not simply be crushed by employers, but they could not become so powerful that they prevented investment and economic expansion.
This is a subtle point because it prevents us from interpreting Acemoglu as arguing that stronger unions are always and everywhere better. His argument is institutional rather than absolute. The question is how much bargaining power is necessary to create a fair and productive economic relationship without destroying the incentives for investment and innovation.
The comparison between Sweden and the United States illustrates this. Sweden developed strong unions incorporated into a corporatist structure in which wages and working conditions could be negotiated at the industry level. In the United States, by contrast, unions eventually became much weaker in their bargaining position, particularly at the plant level after the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947. The two countries therefore demonstrate different institutional configurations of labour-capital relations.
The deeper lesson is that there is no automatic economic equilibrium between labour and capital. It has to be politically and institutionally constructed.
7. Technology was always a potential threat
Acemoglu then introduces a problem that becomes central to the transition toward the postindustrial economy: technological change can destabilize the relationship between economic growth and shared prosperity.
Technology can increase productivity, create new products, generate new industries, and improve living standards. But technological change can also automate tasks previously performed by workers. When this happens, economic growth does not necessarily translate into increased demand for the workers whose tasks have been automated.
This distinction is fundamental. Suppose a factory introduces machines that enable ten workers to produce what previously required one hundred workers. Society may become richer because production has become more efficient. But unless new occupations emerge or institutions redistribute the gains, the ninety displaced workers do not automatically share in that increased productivity.
Technology therefore creates a political question: who receives the benefits of increased productivity, and who bears the costs of technological displacement?
8. Why the United States and Europe were able to manage technological disruption
Acemoglu says that the United States and many European countries managed to “plod along,” partly through luck and partly because their democratic institutional environments ensured that technological changes were not strongly biased against workers and therefore did not destroy the foundations of shared prosperity.
The phrase “partly due to luck” is important because Acemoglu is resisting a triumphalist interpretation of democratic history. The success of liberal democracy was not simply the result of wise leaders deliberately designing perfect institutions. Historical circumstances, technological trajectories, political struggles, institutional compromises, and contingencies all mattered.
At the same time, democratic institutions mattered because they could influence the direction and consequences of technological change. Technology is not necessarily socially neutral. The same technological capacity can be developed and deployed in ways that complement workers or in ways that substitute for them. Therefore, the institutional question is not merely “How much technology do we have?” but also “What kind of technological change are our economic and political institutions encouraging?”
This becomes highly relevant to today's debate about artificial intelligence. AI can complement human capabilities by increasing productivity and creating new forms of work, but it can also be designed and deployed primarily to replace human labour, concentrate income, and increase the power of already dominant firms. The technology itself does not settle the social outcome.
9. Why Acemoglu contrasts democracies with nondemocratic regimes
Acemoglu next makes an important qualification. Nondemocratic regimes have sometimes produced economic growth. Therefore, one cannot prove the superiority of democracy simply by saying that dictatorships cannot generate economic development.
The Soviet Union is his particularly important example. The Soviet system achieved periods of substantial industrial and economic growth, but its economic performance was accompanied by repression, suffering, and enormous loss of life, rather than the kind of shared prosperity that Acemoglu associates with successful liberal democracy.
This distinction between growth and shared prosperity is one of the most important conceptual distinctions in these pages. A country can increase its GDP without creating freedom, security, dignity, political voice, or broadly distributed material improvement. Economic growth by itself therefore cannot be treated as proof of a successful political-economic system.
Acemoglu is effectively asking us to judge an economy by more than its aggregate output. We must ask who benefits, who has voice, who bears the costs, who can organize, who can challenge power, and whether people experience economic development as an expansion of their substantive possibilities.
10. Why the industrial age was particularly favourable to democratic voice
Acemoglu then makes a striking connection between the physical structure of industrial production and the political organization of democracy. Mass production concentrated large numbers of workers in cities and factories. This physical concentration facilitated communication, solidarity, organization, and collective action.
Workers repeatedly encountered one another. They shared similar working conditions, similar grievances, and often similar economic interests. The factory therefore became not only a place of production but also a place where collective political identity could emerge.
This is why Acemoglu says that repeated contact and solidarity became the basis of the labour movement. Workers learned to see their individual experiences as connected to the experiences of others. A worker suffering unsafe conditions could discover that hundreds of others were suffering the same problem. A demand for higher wages could become a collective demand rather than an individual complaint.
This is a profound point for understanding democracy. Democratic participation requires not merely formal rights but social conditions that enable people to recognize themselves as members of a common political community. Industrial society, despite all its inequalities and brutalities, unintentionally created some of those conditions through workplaces, cities, unions, neighbourhoods, and mass organizations.
11. Cities became schools of self-government
Industrialization also produced rapidly growing cities, and Acemoglu sees these cities as important democratic spaces. Cities created new pathways through which ordinary people could participate in local and national politics. They also housed political organizations and civil-society organizations.
In this sense, the industrial city became something like a school of self-government. People learned how to organize meetings, form associations, negotiate collective demands, elect representatives, publish newspapers, mobilize supporters, and engage with public authorities.
This is an important extension of the argument. Democracy does not live exclusively inside parliament. It is reproduced through everyday associational life. Unions, neighbourhood organizations, civic groups, professional associations, political parties, cooperatives, and other institutions teach people how to act collectively.
The industrial economy therefore produced not only factories and commodities but also organizational infrastructures for democracy.
12. Economic growth financed public services
The next part of the argument concerns the fiscal capacity created by industrial growth. As industrial production expanded, governments obtained more tax revenue. That made it financially possible to construct roads, infrastructure, schools, hospitals, and other public services.
This creates another feedback mechanism between economic development and democracy. Economic growth generates fiscal resources; democratic politics creates pressure for those resources to be converted into public goods; public goods such as education and healthcare increase people's capabilities; and improved capabilities allow more people to participate economically and politically.
Acemoglu is therefore describing a mutually reinforcing process in which economic growth, democratic pressure, public investment, education, health, and political participation can strengthen one another.
13. Why regulation was indispensable
The highlighted sentence on page 21 is particularly important: “Regulation was an important part of this bargain.” This sentence captures much of the argument of these pages.
Regulation protected the institutional space within which labour movements could flourish and prevented corporations from abusing their power over consumers. Regulation therefore did not necessarily represent an enemy of markets. Properly designed regulation could actually make markets politically and socially sustainable.
This is a crucial distinction. If powerful corporations are permitted to dominate workers, consumers, competitors, and sometimes even governments, markets can generate enormous private power that ultimately undermines democratic equality. Regulation can prevent that concentration of power from becoming destructive.
At the same time, regulation had another function: it helped make equal access to public services meaningful. If a government formally declares that education or healthcare is available to everyone but allows arbitrary discrimination, corruption, exclusion, or private domination to determine access, formal equality remains incomplete. Rules and due process therefore become necessary to convert political promises into actual institutional rights.
14. The deeper argument running through pages 19–21
The three pages can therefore be understood as one continuous argument rather than as separate observations. Industrial capitalism created enormous productive capacity, but liberal democracy helped convert that productive capacity into something closer to shared prosperity by giving workers political voice, permitting collective organization, regulating private power, financing public services, and creating institutions capable of adapting to social change.
The industrial age was therefore favourable to liberal democracy partly because the economic and social structure itself created conditions for collective organization. Workers were numerous, physically concentrated, dependent upon one another, and often engaged in similar forms of labour. Cities concentrated people and organizations. Industrial growth generated tax revenues. Unions created collective bargaining power. Democratic politics converted these pressures into legislation and public services.
But Acemoglu is simultaneously preparing us for the problem that comes next. The postindustrial economy weakens several of these foundations. Work becomes more individualized and specialized; manufacturing declines; routine labour can be automated; cognitive and educational advantages become increasingly valuable; professional and managerial groups become more important; and the common social experience that once connected large groups of workers becomes more fragmented.
The fundamental question consequently changes from “Can democracy distribute the fruits of industrial growth?” to “Can democracy create a new social and institutional bargain appropriate to an economy in which knowledge, education, technology, cognitive skills, and digital systems increasingly determine economic power?”
That is why the opening paragraph on the postindustrial economy is so important. Acemoglu is not simply saying that the economy has changed. He is saying that the social foundations that once made democracy capable of producing shared prosperity are themselves changing. The old democratic bargain was constructed around a particular economic and social structure, and the crisis of contemporary liberal democracy may partly reflect the fact that the institutions created for the industrial age have not adequately adapted to the postindustrial age.
The central idea of pages 19–21
The deepest message of these pages can therefore be stated this way: liberal democracy did not become legitimate merely because people were allowed to vote; it became broadly legitimate when democratic institutions succeeded in connecting political voice with economic security, worker organization, regulation, public services, education, and a relatively wide sharing of the gains from economic growth. The industrial age gave democracy unusually favourable social and economic conditions for constructing that bargain, but technological change and the emergence of the postindustrial economy are weakening those conditions. The contemporary crisis of liberal democracy must therefore be understood partly as a crisis of the old democratic-economic bargain and as a question of whether a new bargain can be constructed for the postindustrial age.
Pages 21–22 — Digital Technology, Inequality, and the Breakdown of the Industrial Democratic Bargain
These pages take the argument from the previous pages one decisive step further. On pages 19–21, Acemoglu explained why the industrial age created unusually favourable conditions for liberal democracy: industrial production required large numbers of workers, workers could organize, unions could bargain, governments could regulate corporations, economic growth generated tax revenues for public services, and democratic institutions could help distribute the gains of growth more broadly. At the end of page 21, however, he introduces the turning point in two words: “Then computers happened.” What follows is Acemoglu's explanation of how digital technology did not merely change the workplace, but reworked the entire economic and social bargain on which industrial liberal democracy had rested.
1. “Then computers happened” is a historical turning point
The sentence “Then computers happened” should not be read as a casual statement that computers were invented and therefore everything changed. Acemoglu is marking a structural transformation. The industrial economy had been organized around a particular relationship between human labour, capital, production, and political institutions. Digital technology altered that relationship.
The important point is that technology did not simply make existing workers more productive in an evenly distributed way. It changed which kinds of workers were valuable, which tasks could be automated, which skills employers demanded, and therefore which groups acquired economic power. Once this happened, the older industrial bargain between capital and labour began to weaken.
This is why the next sentence is so important: “The arrival of digital technologies reworked all facets of the bargain.” The “bargain” refers to the entire institutional arrangement described in the preceding pages, including wages, employment, worker organization, regulation, public services, political voice, and the distribution of economic gains.
2. Digital technology increased inequality
Acemoglu's immediate claim is that digital technologies unleashed a huge increase in inequality. His argument is not that every technological innovation necessarily increases inequality. Rather, the particular pattern of technological change that developed in advanced economies increasingly favoured workers possessing higher levels of education and cognitive skills while reducing the demand for many forms of routine and manual labour.
This is crucial because it means that technological change began to differentiate workers more sharply according to education and skill. During the industrial period, a person did not necessarily need a college degree or highly specialized cognitive expertise to obtain a reasonably secure and productive industrial job. In the emerging postindustrial economy, that became increasingly important.
The consequence was not simply that some people earned more than others. The deeper consequence was that the economic structure itself began producing different trajectories for different educational groups. Those possessing the skills demanded by the new economy could experience rising wages and opportunities, while those whose tasks were increasingly automated, outsourced, or rendered less valuable could experience stagnant wages, declining opportunities, or displacement.
This is why Acemoglu connects economic inequality to the crisis of liberal democracy. When economic growth increasingly benefits particular educational and occupational groups, the old idea that prosperity will broadly improve people's lives becomes harder to sustain.
3. The first transformation: computers changed what employers wanted
Acemoglu identifies three major changes brought by digital technology. The first was that computers entered workplaces and changed the nature of the skills employers demanded.
Employers increasingly began looking for workers with greater education and cognitive skills. In Acemoglu's deliberately provocative language, employers began going after “brains rather than brawn.”
This phrase captures the movement from an economy in which physical labour was central to an economy in which information processing, problem-solving, analytical ability, programming, professional expertise, communication, and other cognitive capabilities became increasingly valuable.
The consequence was a change in the economic meaning of education. Education had always mattered, but in the postindustrial economy it became much more strongly connected to access to high-value occupations. A university degree, specialized training, programming ability, legal expertise, managerial competence, engineering knowledge, or advanced professional skills could provide a substantial economic advantage.
Thus, education increasingly became not simply a means of personal development but an economic sorting mechanism.
4. “Brains rather than brawn” and the new hierarchy of labour
The phrase “brains rather than brawn” should therefore not be understood as saying that physical workers became useless. Physical labour continued to be necessary. The point is that the relative economic value of different kinds of human labour changed.
Consider the difference between an industrial production line and a modern digitally integrated production system. The older system could employ hundreds or thousands of workers performing standardized physical tasks. The newer system can use computerized machinery, sensors, robotics, software, and data systems to perform or coordinate many of those tasks while requiring a smaller number of workers with specialized technical skills.
This creates an important asymmetry. The engineer designing or maintaining the automated system may become more valuable, while the worker whose repetitive task has been automated may become less valuable.
The same phenomenon appears outside factories. Banking, accounting, retail, transportation, administration, customer service, logistics, and many other sectors have experienced computerization. Tasks that once required large numbers of clerical or routine workers can increasingly be performed through software.
Therefore, the technological revolution changes not only how much labour is required but what kind of labour is economically rewarded.
5. The second transformation: automation
The second change is even more consequential. Digital technologies became a platform for an accelerated process of industrial automation.
Acemoglu mentions numerically controlled machinery, semiautomated and automated advanced tools, industrial robots, and computerized workplace technologies. The underlying process is straightforward: tasks that were previously performed by humans increasingly became capable of being performed by machines controlled by digital systems.
But here we have to make an important distinction. Acemoglu is not saying that automation necessarily destroys all employment. Technological innovation can create new occupations and new industries. The problem is that the workers displaced from old tasks do not automatically possess the skills required for the new tasks.
This creates what might be called a technological transition problem. A worker who has spent twenty years performing a particular manufacturing task cannot simply become a programmer because programming jobs have increased. The economy may create new opportunities while simultaneously destroying the worker's previous pathway into secure employment.
Therefore, the question is not merely whether technology creates jobs or destroys jobs in aggregate. The more important question is what happens to the particular people whose tasks disappear.
6. Why automation affected lower-educated workers disproportionately
Acemoglu says something especially important: while computers increased demand for cognitive skills, automation reduced the need for manual skills typically supplied by lower-education workers.
This creates a very different distributional effect from the technological progress of the earlier industrial period. In the industrial age, technological advancement could coexist with expanding demand for workers because increasing production required large numbers of people. In the newer economy, technology can increase production while reducing the number of people required to perform particular tasks.
This is one of the mechanisms through which technological progress can become labour-displacing rather than labour-complementing.
Workers with college and postgraduate degrees, particularly those possessing specialized cognitive skills such as programming, advanced legal expertise, engineering, medicine, finance, or management, could see their earnings increase. At the same time, opportunities and wages for blue-collar and manual workers could decline.
The resulting inequality is therefore not merely a consequence of some people working harder than others. It is partly structural. The economic system is assigning different values to different forms of human capability.
7. The distinction between “college graduates” and everyone else
One of the most important things to notice here is that Acemoglu is not simply celebrating education. He is describing a new hierarchy created by the postindustrial economy.
If an economy increasingly rewards cognitive skills, then those who already possess educational advantages become better positioned to capture the benefits of technological change. Those who lack such education face a double disadvantage: the jobs available to them may decline, while the occupations that replace them may require credentials or skills they do not possess.
This creates a feedback mechanism. Higher education gives access to better opportunities; better opportunities produce higher incomes; higher incomes provide greater access to further education and resources; and the advantages of educated groups can therefore become increasingly self-reinforcing.
At the same time, people without such educational advantages can experience declining economic security.
This is politically significant because economic inequality can become educational inequality, occupational inequality, social inequality, and eventually political inequality.
8. Automation was not the only cause: globalization mattered too
Acemoglu immediately prevents us from making another simplistic interpretation. He says that automation was not the only factor transforming the industrial structure of advanced economies. Globalization and the growing demand for services also played major roles.
This qualification is important. The decline of manufacturing employment cannot simply be explained by robots replacing workers. Global trade allowed firms in advanced economies to move some production to countries where labour was cheaper, while consumers increasingly purchased goods manufactured elsewhere.
Acemoglu gives examples such as textiles, apparel, toys, furniture, food products, and simple electronics. These industries faced intense competition from low-wage countries. Some domestic industries were therefore crushed by cheap imports, while others survived only by offshoring part of their production process.
Thus, workers could lose jobs or bargaining power through more than one mechanism: their tasks could be automated, their production could be moved abroad, or their industries could face competition from imported goods.
9. But Acemoglu does not treat globalization and automation as equally important
Despite recognizing globalization, Acemoglu makes an important empirical claim. He argues that digital automation, particularly through advanced industrial machinery and robots, accounts for the bulk of the changes in the U.S. wage structure.
This matters because it prevents the political discussion from becoming too easy. If inequality were caused primarily by globalization, the obvious response would be to restrict trade or impose barriers on imports. But if technological change itself is a major driver, then the policy challenge is much more complicated.
The issue becomes one of how technology is developed, what tasks it is designed to replace, what new tasks it creates, who receives the productivity gains, and how workers are enabled to participate in the new economy.
This is especially relevant today because artificial intelligence extends the same question beyond manual labour into increasingly cognitive domains. The historical pattern Acemoglu describes therefore provides a framework for asking whether AI will complement human abilities or primarily substitute for them.
10. The combined effect: education, automation, globalization
Acemoglu then brings the different mechanisms together. The postindustrial transformation involves three interconnected processes: rising demand for college-educated workers, automation of various manual and office tasks, and globalization and offshoring.
Together, these processes produced a massive increase in inequality.
The important word here is “together.” We should not imagine one single technological cause. Rather, the labour market was being reorganized from several directions simultaneously. High-skill workers were increasingly rewarded; routine workers were increasingly replaceable; manufacturing employment declined; some production moved abroad; and many traditional pathways into stable middle-class employment weakened.
The result was that the economic growth of the new era increasingly failed to resemble the shared prosperity of the earlier industrial democratic bargain.
11. “Shattering the shared-prosperity promise”
This is perhaps the most politically important phrase on page 22. Acemoglu says that these changes “shattered the shared-prosperity promise of liberal democracies.”
The promise was not necessarily a formal constitutional promise. It was a historical expectation that became associated with successful liberal democracy: economic growth would improve people's material lives; workers would gain from rising productivity; public institutions would protect citizens; and political participation would allow ordinary people to influence the distribution of economic gains.
When large sections of society begin experiencing stagnating wages, disappearing jobs, declining bargaining power, or reduced economic opportunity while highly educated groups experience rapid gains, that expectation becomes damaged.
People can then reasonably begin asking: If democracy and economic growth are supposed to work together, why does economic growth appear to be benefiting people like me less and less?
That question can become politically explosive.
12. Acemoglu's criticism of postindustrial elites
The next sentence adds another layer: Acemoglu says that the situation was exacerbated by the passivity of postindustrial elites in charting a new course that would not completely leave behind people with lower education.
This is a particularly important criticism because Acemoglu is not blaming technology alone. He is also blaming institutional and political failure.
The technological transformation was not necessarily destined to produce such severe inequality. Political institutions could have responded through better education, retraining, worker participation, labour-market institutions, stronger social protection, public investment, regional development, and other mechanisms.
The problem, in his view, was that the beneficiaries of the postindustrial economy did not sufficiently redesign the democratic bargain to accommodate those who were disadvantaged by the transition.
This is one of the places where Acemoglu's argument becomes explicitly political. The problem is not simply that the world changed; the problem is that democratic institutions failed to adapt adequately to the changed world.
13. The third transformation: the social power of college graduates
At the bottom of page 22, Acemoglu begins discussing the third change brought by computers, saying that it was equally fundamental although its effects were more variegated.
The continuation on the next page says that the digital age increased the numbers and social power of college graduates and ushered in the era of postindustrial politics.
This is extremely important because Acemoglu is now moving beyond economics into political sociology.
The digital economy did not merely make college graduates richer. It increased their social and political weight. As the economy increasingly depended upon their skills, their occupations, institutions, networks, values, and professional identities became more influential.
This means that the transformation of the economy also transformed who had cultural authority, political influence, and agenda-setting power.
14. The emergence of “postindustrial politics”
This is the bridge between these pages and the later argument of the book.
Industrial politics had been heavily shaped by workers, unions, manufacturing communities, class-based organizations, and struggles over wages and working conditions. Postindustrial politics increasingly reflects the interests, identities, values, and concerns of college-educated and professional groups.
That transformation can have profound consequences for liberal democracy. If political parties, media institutions, universities, professional organizations, bureaucracies, and cultural institutions increasingly reflect the worldview of highly educated groups, people who have lost economic and social status may begin to feel that the political system no longer represents them.
The resulting alienation can then become fertile ground for populism, anti-establishment politics, cultural backlash, distrust of institutions, and hostility toward liberal elites.
15. The hidden connection with your larger theme: education and democracy
There is a particularly important implication here for the argument you have been developing around education, critical thinking, public reasoning, and democratic participation.
Acemoglu is showing that education became increasingly valuable economically in the postindustrial economy. But that creates a danger if education is treated merely as a mechanism for producing economically successful individuals.
If education becomes primarily a credentialing system that separates “high-skill” people from “low-skill” people, it can inadvertently contribute to a new social hierarchy. The highly educated may come to see themselves as more competent, more informed, or more entitled to shape public affairs, while those with less formal education may increasingly feel excluded from the institutions that make collective decisions.
This means that the democratic meaning of education becomes more important precisely when the economic value of education is increasing. Education cannot merely produce cognitive skills for the labour market; a democracy also requires the capacity to question authority, debate openly, listen to opposing arguments, understand institutional complexity, distinguish evidence from propaganda, and recognize the equal political standing of people whose educational credentials may be very different.
Otherwise, the postindustrial economy can produce a dangerous combination: greater dependence upon education economically, greater inequality between educational groups, and greater political power for the highly educated.
16. The central transition across pages 19–22
If we connect pages 19–21 with pages 21–22, the whole argument becomes much clearer.
During the industrial age, labour was economically necessary, workers were concentrated together, unions could organize, governments could regulate, and economic growth created fiscal resources for public services. These conditions allowed liberal democracy to construct a relatively successful bargain between markets and society.
Digital technology then changed the structure of that bargain. Computers increased the value of cognitive skills, automation reduced demand for many routine and manual tasks, globalization weakened some manufacturing sectors, and the growing importance of higher education increased the economic and social power of college graduates.
The result was not simply technological modernization. It was a reorganization of economic power and social power.
And that is why these pages matter so much for the title of the chapter, “Liberal Democracy in Crisis.” Acemoglu is beginning to show that the crisis is not simply a crisis of political institutions considered in isolation. It is also a crisis produced by the changing relationship between technology, work, education, inequality, social status, economic power, and political representation.
The deepest point of pages 21–22
The deepest point can therefore be stated as follows: the industrial democratic bargain worked partly because industrial capitalism created broad demand for labour and because democratic institutions built mechanisms through which workers could organize, bargain, regulate economic power, and share in the gains of growth. Digital technology fundamentally altered that structure by rewarding cognitive and highly educated workers, automating many routine and manual tasks, interacting with globalization and offshoring, and thereby producing a sharp divergence in economic opportunity. The resulting inequality did not merely divide incomes; it began dividing society according to education, occupation, economic security, social status, and political influence. At the same time, the beneficiaries of the postindustrial economy acquired increasing social power, while the institutions of liberal democracy failed to construct an equally effective new bargain for those left behind. The crisis of liberal democracy therefore begins to appear as a crisis of adaptation: the economy changed faster than democratic institutions changed with it.
Pages 23–26 — Postindustrial Politics, Social Engineering, Regulation, and the Crisis of Liberal Democracy
These four pages form a single, closely connected argument. Acemoglu is explaining how the rise of the postindustrial economy changed the educated class, how that educated class became politically powerful, why it increasingly supported social engineering and regulation, and how both processes eventually contributed to a backlash against liberalism itself. The important point is that Acemoglu is not simply criticizing education, regulation, or progressive social values. His argument is more subtle: developments that initially had legitimate and even liberal purposes became distorted by the new postindustrial social structure, producing new forms of elite power and new forms of alienation among people who felt excluded from the emerging order.
1. The emergence of an “educated elite”
Acemoglu begins by qualifying the expression “educated elite.” He says that the term is often overused, but that it became increasingly meaningful in the postindustrial era because three interconnected processes transformed the social and political position of highly educated people.
The first process was simply the enormous expansion of higher education. Earlier, only a very small proportion of the population possessed college degrees. Therefore, being college educated itself placed a person in a relatively small and privileged social category. As mass higher education expanded, however, the number of graduates became enormous. In the United States, the expansion accelerated from the 1960s onward, particularly because the large baby-boom generations went through higher education in increasing numbers.
Acemoglu gives the striking comparison that fewer than 5 percent of Americans had college degrees in the 1940s, whereas today more than 40 percent of the workforce has a four-year college degree and more than 70 percent has some college education or an associate degree.
The political significance is crucial. A group that constitutes only a tiny percentage of society cannot easily become a mass political force, but a group representing a very large share of society can. Thus, the expansion of higher education did not merely produce more educated individuals; it transformed the educated population into a significant political constituency.
This is the first major transformation that Acemoglu wants us to understand: education ceased to be simply an individual qualification and became the basis of a large social and political group.
2. The second transformation: educated people move into positions of institutional power
The second process was even more important. Industrialization and then postindustrialization produced a rapidly increasing demand for college-educated specialists and professionals.
Modern economies became increasingly dependent upon people who possessed specialized knowledge. Managers ran large corporations, engineers designed increasingly complex technologies, doctors and health professionals operated sophisticated medical systems, lawyers handled increasingly complicated legal structures, civil servants administered expanding states, while professionals entered education, media, NGOs and other institutions.
Consequently, college graduates did not merely become numerous; they came to occupy many of the positions from which society itself was organized and governed.
This is a very important distinction. Acemoglu is not saying merely that educated people became better paid. He is saying that they increasingly acquired institutional authority.
A person who controls a specialized profession possesses a different kind of power from a person who merely possesses money. A software engineer, doctor, lawyer, economist, bureaucrat, academic, journalist or policy expert may influence how institutions function because society increasingly depends upon their specialized knowledge.
Thus, the postindustrial economy generated a new social relationship between knowledge and power. The more complicated society became, the more it needed people who could claim expertise in managing that complexity.
3. But the educated class did not remain economically equal
The third process was different from the first two. While the number and importance of college graduates increased, the educated class itself began to divide internally.
This is where Acemoglu introduces the distinction between “elite graduates” and the “mass college educated.”
Elite graduates possess highly valued specialized skills. These might include advanced programming, sophisticated quantitative knowledge, exceptional medical expertise, highly specialized legal knowledge or particularly strong social and managerial skills. Because the postindustrial economy places enormous economic value on these abilities, people possessing them can become exceptionally wealthy and influential.
Silicon Valley provides Acemoglu's clearest example. Highly successful technology entrepreneurs, scientists and engineers may belong to the educated class, but their economic position can be radically different from that of an ordinary college graduate.
This produces an important paradox: higher education expanded enormously, but the economic rewards of higher education did not expand equally.
A college degree therefore ceased to guarantee entry into the privileged part of the economy. There could be millions of graduates, but only a relatively small proportion possessed the particular skills that the new economy rewarded most heavily.
4. The rise of the “mass college educated”
This leads directly to the next page. Acemoglu calls the larger group the “mass college educated.” The expression is deliberately chosen because these people are numerous but do not necessarily possess the exceptionally valuable skills of the elite graduates.
Their expectations, however, were shaped by the expansion of higher education.
If society tells large numbers of young people that obtaining a college degree is the principal route to professional success, social status and economic security, they naturally develop expectations corresponding to that promise. But the economy cannot provide all of them with the salaries, prestige and social standing enjoyed by the most successful software engineers, lawyers, financiers, doctors or entrepreneurs.
The result is an expectation–reality gap.
Many graduates consequently find themselves working in relatively low-paid occupations for which their educational qualifications appear excessive. Acemoglu uses the image of the college-educated barista to illustrate this phenomenon.
The deeper issue is not simply that some graduates earn less money. It is that the educational system can create an expectation of upward mobility that the economic structure cannot fulfil for everyone.
5. The educated class therefore contains two very different wings
Acemoglu is careful not to treat the educated population as a homogeneous group. There can be major political disagreements between its different sections.
For example, elite graduates working in technology may have interests that differ substantially from left-leaning graduates working in NGOs or the civil service. The former may be deeply integrated into global markets and technological capitalism, whereas the latter may be more concerned with redistribution, social justice and public institutions.
So economically and politically, the educated class can be divided.
Yet Acemoglu identifies something that binds these otherwise different groups together: a common cultural outlook.
This becomes one of the central arguments of these pages.
6. The cultural common denominator
Despite their economic differences, the educated groups increasingly shared certain cultural values.
They tended to value diversity, individual autonomy, group-level identity, cosmopolitanism and globalization. They tended to view intolerance and ignorance negatively and tended to favour greater cultural openness.
This is important because Acemoglu is distinguishing between economic interests and cultural values.
An elite technology entrepreneur and a left-leaning NGO worker may disagree about taxation, welfare or economic redistribution, but they may nevertheless agree strongly about immigration, multiculturalism, diversity, individual autonomy and cosmopolitanism.
Thus, a kind of cultural coalition develops within the educated class.
7. Why these cultural values also suited elite economic interests
Acemoglu then introduces a more uncomfortable observation. These cultural values were not merely abstract moral preferences. In some cases, they were also compatible with the economic interests of elite graduates.
This is especially evident in sectors such as finance, medicine and, most dramatically, Silicon Valley.
These sectors operate within a highly globalized economy and frequently depend upon access to talented immigrants. Therefore, cosmopolitanism and openness to immigration can simultaneously be a cultural value and an economic advantage.
This does not mean that Acemoglu is accusing every educated liberal of hypocrisy. His argument is more structural. A set of cultural values can be sincerely held while also coinciding with the material interests of the people who hold them.
That distinction is extremely important for understanding his argument.
8. From cultural agreement to social engineering
Once this educated class became increasingly numerous, institutionally powerful and culturally influential, it began to support efforts to change society itself.
Acemoglu calls this process “social engineering.”
Here social engineering does not necessarily mean something sinister or authoritarian. It can include attempts to change social attitudes and behaviour through education, institutional rules, public policies, regulation, language norms and other mechanisms.
For example, if discrimination is regarded as a serious social problem, one response is not merely to wait for attitudes to change naturally. Governments, schools, corporations and other institutions may introduce rules and procedures intended to discourage discriminatory behaviour and encourage greater inclusion.
Similarly, if poverty, unsafe working conditions or environmental damage are considered unacceptable, regulation may be used to alter economic behaviour.
Acemoglu's point is that the growing educated class increasingly came to believe that social problems could and should be solved through deliberate institutional intervention.
9. Why social engineering is attractive to elites
Acemoglu gives a deeper historical explanation for why educated elites may find social engineering attractive.
If a society needs experts to determine what constitutes acceptable behaviour, acceptable language, appropriate policy or desirable social values, then expertise itself becomes a source of social authority.
Those who possess the relevant education can therefore acquire influence not simply because they have wealth but because society treats them as qualified to determine what should be done.
This creates a subtle form of power.
If I am merely wealthy, I possess economic resources. But if I am regarded as an expert on education, medicine, economics, law, social policy or appropriate social behaviour, I may acquire the authority to influence how other people ought to live.
Acemoglu points out that history contains many examples of such arrangements. Medieval Catholic clergy, Islamic scholars or ulema, Brahmins within the Hindu caste system and Chinese mandarins all occupied positions in which knowledge, social norms and institutional authority became intertwined.
The historical lesson is therefore broader than contemporary liberal politics: educated groups have often gained power by claiming authority over the values and norms of society.
10. The connection between social engineering and regulation
Page 25 then makes an important conceptual connection: social engineering and regulation are natural partners.
James C. Scott's analysis in Seeing Like a State is used to explain why.
A modern state cannot easily govern a society in all its enormous local complexity. Communities possess different customs, practices, informal rules, traditions and forms of knowledge. From the perspective of a central authority, this complexity makes society difficult to administer.
Scott's argument is that the state therefore tries to make society “legible.”
A useful analogy is a map. A detailed landscape contains innumerable local variations, but a simple map leaves many of them out so that the overall structure becomes easier to understand and administer.
Similarly, governments may simplify social reality into categories, rules and procedures.
11. The danger of making society “legible”
This simplification has practical advantages. A government cannot create a separate rule for every individual circumstance. Regulation therefore requires categories and standardized procedures.
But simplification also has a cost.
When local practices, customs and variations are ignored, the actual diversity of social life is reduced to a standardized model.
This is where social engineering becomes potentially problematic.
The social engineer may say: “This is the correct rule, and everyone should follow it.”
But communities are not identical. Their histories, traditions, needs and circumstances differ. A uniform regulatory framework can therefore unintentionally suppress local knowledge and local autonomy.
This is one of Acemoglu's central concerns: the desire to improve society can gradually become a desire to organize society according to a centrally determined model of what a good society should look like.
12. Why regulation originally had a deeply liberal purpose
Acemoglu is very careful not to reject regulation as such.
He explicitly acknowledges that liberals were correct in recognizing the enormous importance of regulation during much of the twentieth century.
Regulation helped restrict absolute economic and political power, protect workers and create safer and better working conditions.
Labour laws, workplace safety rules, consumer protection, environmental standards and other regulations could prevent powerful actors from imposing unacceptable costs on weaker members of society.
So regulation was not originally opposed to liberalism.
In many circumstances, regulation was one of the mechanisms through which liberalism protected freedom.
This distinction is essential.
13. Regulation and equality before the law
Acemoglu also identifies another legitimate liberal insight: procedures can promote equality before the law.
If everyone is required to follow the same clearly defined rules, then privileged individuals cannot simply demand exceptions for themselves.
The ideal is that the law should apply equally to the powerful and the powerless.
This is a fundamental liberal principle because arbitrary power is reduced when decisions are governed by predictable rules rather than personal privilege.
But Acemoglu says the educated postindustrial elite partly transformed this legitimate principle into a much broader confidence in regulation.
The reasoning gradually became:
If regulation solved important problems before, then more regulation should solve more problems.
That inference, according to Acemoglu, is where difficulties begin.
14. From legitimate protection to excessive regulation
The postindustrial educated elite increasingly came to believe that regulation was an appropriate tool for addressing discrimination, poverty, safety and social attitudes more generally.
Again, Acemoglu does not deny that these problems were real.
Discrimination was real. Poverty was real. Unsafe conditions were real. Intolerance was real.
The problem was the assumption that increasingly intensive regulation and social engineering were necessarily the best means of solving them.
Once regulation moves beyond preventing clear harms and begins attempting to reshape people's values, attitudes and behaviour, it enters a different territory.
It can begin to regulate not merely what people do, but indirectly what society should believe.
15. “Social engineering gained momentum” from the postindustrial transformation
This is perhaps the most important sentence on these pages.
Acemoglu says that social engineering did not emerge simply because educated liberals suddenly became authoritarian or intolerant. Rather, broader changes unleashed by the postindustrial economy gave social engineering momentum.
The expanding educated class had greater numbers.
It occupied more influential institutions.
It possessed increasingly specialized knowledge.
Its members shared important cultural values.
And the modern state possessed increasingly sophisticated regulatory mechanisms.
Together, these conditions created an environment in which social engineering could expand dramatically.
Thus, the social structure of postindustrial society amplified an existing tendency toward intervention.
16. From liberal intentions to illiberal consequences
Acemoglu's argument now becomes paradoxical.
Many educated liberals genuinely wanted to create a more tolerant, equal and inclusive society. They wanted minorities and immigrants to be treated fairly, wanted poverty reduced and wanted society to become more sustainable.
But good intentions do not guarantee liberal outcomes.
If the attempt to achieve these goals becomes increasingly intrusive, centralized and intolerant of disagreement, then the method can undermine the very values it claims to protect.
This is why Acemoglu says social engineering ultimately “betrayed liberal values.”
The betrayal occurs when a movement committed to autonomy, pluralism and individual freedom begins to believe that society must be corrected from above.
17. The crucial paradox: defending tolerance through intolerance
There is an especially important paradox embedded in Acemoglu's argument.
A liberal society must tolerate disagreement. But if a particular conception of tolerance itself becomes an imposed orthodoxy, then disagreement with that conception may be treated as morally illegitimate.
At that point, the society may say that it is defending tolerance while becoming increasingly intolerant toward people who reject its preferred cultural norms.
This is the deeper meaning of the reference to “thought policing.”
The issue is no longer simply whether a person violates the law. It becomes whether a person's speech, attitudes or beliefs conform to the accepted cultural standards established by influential institutions.
That can generate resentment among people who feel that they are not merely being governed but socially judged and culturally disciplined.
18. Why this produced a backlash
The final paragraph on page 26 connects all these developments to the broader crisis of liberal democracy.
The postindustrial economy did not create a single problem. It produced a chain of problems.
Automation and technological change weakened some traditional routes to broadly shared prosperity. The mass college-educated population experienced expectations that the economy could not universally fulfil. Elite graduates accumulated disproportionate wealth and influence. Cultural divisions widened. Regulation increasingly moved beyond protection toward intervention. Social engineering became more intrusive.
The result was a growing perception among some sections of society that the institutions of liberal democracy were no longer working for them.
This created fertile ground for political backlash.
19. “Regulation drifted away from those it was meant to protect”
This sentence is particularly important.
Regulation originally developed partly to protect weaker people from stronger economic actors. But Acemoglu argues that regulatory systems can eventually become so complicated and institutionally embedded that they cease to serve the people for whom they were originally designed.
Instead of protecting ordinary citizens, regulation can sometimes impose costs, restrictions or bureaucratic burdens upon them.
The irony is therefore profound: a system created to restrain powerful actors can itself become a source of power over ordinary people.
This does not mean that all regulation becomes harmful. It means that regulation must continually be judged by whether it actually serves the people and freedoms it was created to protect.
20. “Sins of omission” and “sins of commission”
Acemoglu concludes these pages with a particularly useful distinction.
The crisis of liberalism arose from both sins of omission and sins of commission.
A sin of omission means failing to do something that liberal democracy should have done. For example, failing to ensure sufficiently broad economic opportunities, failing to respond adequately to automation, failing to prevent growing inequality or failing to preserve pathways to shared prosperity.
A sin of commission, by contrast, means doing something that actively produces harmful consequences. Excessive regulation, intrusive social engineering or policies that unnecessarily undermine autonomy can belong to this category.
Thus, liberal democracy can fail in two opposite ways.
It can fail by doing too little, allowing economic and social inequalities to grow.
And it can fail by doing too much in the wrong way, imposing increasingly intrusive forms of regulation and social control.
This is why Acemoglu's criticism cannot be reduced to either “government is bad” or “government should do more.” His actual argument is about the quality, direction and institutional character of government intervention.
21. The whole argument in one causal chain
The four pages can therefore be understood as one continuous chain:
Postindustrialization → expansion of higher education → emergence of a mass educated population → enormous demand for specialized expertise → concentration of exceptional rewards among elite graduates → cultural convergence among educated groups → greater influence of educated elites over institutions → expansion of social engineering and regulation → increasing intrusion into social and cultural life → alienation and resentment among sections of society → backlash against liberalism.
The crucial point is that none of the individual steps is necessarily anti-liberal in itself. Mass education can be liberal. Expertise can be necessary. Regulation can protect freedom. Diversity can strengthen society. Social reform can correct injustice.
The problem arises when these elements combine in a particular postindustrial institutional structure in which a relatively influential educated class acquires the authority to define both economic and cultural norms for a much larger population.
22. The deepest idea in these pages
The deepest idea, in my reading, is that Acemoglu is asking us to distinguish between liberalism as protection of people's capacity to live their own lives and liberalism as an attempt by educated institutions to determine what a good life should look like.
The first requires institutions that protect people from arbitrary power, create fair opportunities, maintain equality before the law and allow individuals and communities substantial room for autonomy.
The second can become paternalistic. It assumes that those possessing superior education, expertise or cultural sophistication know what society ought to become and therefore have a legitimate authority to reshape the values and behaviour of others.
That is the point at which liberal democracy can begin to resemble what might be called a “paternalistic democracy” or “patriarchist democracy”: formally democratic, but increasingly governed by people who believe that their superior knowledge or moral understanding gives them a special right to guide, regulate and correct society.
The pages therefore provide an important bridge between economic transformation and political alienation. Acemoglu is showing that the current crisis of liberal democracy cannot be understood merely by looking at populist leaders or angry voters. One must also examine the transformation of the educated class, the changing structure of expertise, the distribution of economic rewards, the rise of cultural authority, and the gradual movement from protecting citizens' freedom to managing citizens' behaviour and values.
And that is why the last sentence is so important: postindustrialism and liberalism's own “sins of omission and commission” became intertwined. Liberal democracy was weakened partly because it failed to respond adequately to the economic transformations of postindustrial society, and partly because some of its responses became excessively intrusive and disconnected from the lived experience of large sections of the population.
Page 26 — Liberalism Is Worth Saving and Remaking
Page 26 is a turning point in Acemoglu’s argument. In the earlier pages, he has explained how liberal democracy became disconnected from shared prosperity, how regulation and social policy increasingly failed to protect those who needed protection, and how postindustrial changes generated a powerful backlash. On this page, instead of concluding that liberalism itself has failed and must be abandoned, Acemoglu makes the opposite argument: liberalism has gone wrong in important ways, but its basic idea is still worth preserving and rebuilding. He now begins to introduce the philosophical foundations of the new form of liberalism that he will develop in the next chapter.
1. The accumulated failures of liberalism
The first paragraph of page 26 completes the argument developed in the preceding pages. Acemoglu says that several things have gone wrong together. The economy has not followed the natural pathways toward shared prosperity and solidarity that liberal democracy had once promised. Regulation, which was supposed to protect ordinary people and weaker sections of society, gradually drifted away from those purposes. At the same time, social engineering became increasingly intense and began to move away from some of the foundational values of liberalism. These developments created resentment and eventually produced a strong political backlash.
The important point is that Acemoglu does not treat these failures as isolated accidents. He sees them as connected to the transformation from the industrial era to the postindustrial era. He therefore describes them as the result of both the “sins of omission and commission” of liberalism. In simple words, liberalism failed partly because it did things it should not have done, and partly because it failed to do things it should have done. This distinction becomes important for the rest of the book because Acemoglu is not simply defending the existing liberal order; he wants to identify where it went wrong and reconstruct it.
2. “Walk the Streets as Other Men”
The heading “Walk the Streets as Other Men” comes from the quotation from John Milton that Acemoglu discusses later. The idea behind the phrase is that people who possess power, status or authority should not become socially separated from ordinary members of society. They should be able to live among others, walk among them, speak with them freely and be treated as fellow human beings rather than as superior beings.
This becomes a useful symbol for Acemoglu's conception of liberalism. Liberal democracy should not create a society in which an educated, powerful or economically successful elite becomes increasingly distant from the rest of society. The political system must preserve a sense of common membership and equality among citizens.
3. Liberalism should not be abandoned
Acemoglu then asks a fundamental question: given all these failures, should we conclude that liberalism has simply run its course and that society should now look toward “postliberal” philosophies?
His answer is emphatically no. The central argument of the entire book, he says, is that liberalism is worth saving and remaking.
This is an important distinction. He is neither saying that everything currently existing under the name of liberal democracy is satisfactory nor saying that liberal democracy should be discarded. His position is that the core liberal project remains valuable, but it needs to be reconstructed so that it can again serve human freedom, community and shared prosperity.
In other words, the problem is not necessarily that liberalism is inherently incapable of producing a good society. The problem is that liberalism has developed in a direction that has weakened some of its own fundamental purposes.
4. A new theory of liberalism
Acemoglu says that the next chapter will develop a new theory of liberalism. He acknowledges that this theory occupies only one particular corner of the very large intellectual tradition called liberalism, and that he may even stretch that corner somewhat.
The important feature of his version is that it tries to combine two things that are often treated as opposites: the protection of individual rights and the importance of community.
He therefore does not want a liberalism that understands freedom simply as individuals being left alone. At the same time, he does not want a communitarian philosophy in which the community becomes so powerful that it can suppress individual freedom.
His objective is to bring individual freedom, community and shared prosperity into one framework.
5. The first foundation: fallibility
Acemoglu then gives four premises on which his theory rests. The first is fallibility.
Fallibility means that any human belief, proposition or piece of knowledge can be wrong. Nobody, including governments, experts, intellectuals, political movements or majorities, possesses unquestionable knowledge.
This is much more important than simply saying that people sometimes make mistakes. Acemoglu is making a philosophical claim about the nature of human knowledge itself. Because human beings can be wrong, society must create institutions that allow people to question existing beliefs, test alternatives, debate one another and correct mistakes.
This premise therefore provides one of the deepest foundations for freedom of expression and experimentation. If we cannot be certain that our present understanding is correct, we need an environment in which alternative ideas can be expressed and examined.
6. The second foundation: social learning in community
The second premise is social learning in community.
Acemoglu's argument here is that human beings do not produce useful knowledge only as isolated individuals. We learn from one another by sharing information and communicating within communities. These communities may overlap with one another and are built partly upon trust, shared history, common norms and shared interests.
So knowledge is not merely something that exists inside the mind of an individual expert. A large part of socially useful knowledge is produced collectively through interaction between people.
This is why community becomes so important in Acemoglu's liberalism. Community is not merely something emotionally comforting or culturally desirable. It has an epistemic function: people need functioning communities in order to communicate, learn from each other and generate useful collective knowledge.
7. The third foundation: gentle epistemic improvement
The third premise is what Acemoglu calls “gentle epistemic improvement.”
The idea is subtle. Acemoglu does not claim that society will automatically discover the truth quickly. Wrong ideas can spread, sometimes for long periods, and may even become politically dominant. Human beings are capable of believing and transmitting false ideas.
But he argues that there are nevertheless reasons to expect more useful knowledge and more accurate descriptions of reality to gain some advantage over time, particularly when societies permit debate, deliberation and social learning.
The word “gentle” is important. He is not presenting human history as a simple march toward truth. Rather, he believes that open discussion and collective learning can gradually improve society's understanding. Progress is therefore possible but neither automatic nor guaranteed.
This also explains why liberal institutions matter. If people are prevented from questioning authority, experimenting with alternatives or communicating with others, society loses some of its capacity to correct its own mistakes.
8. The fourth foundation: collective knowledge should improve human life
The fourth premise is the desirability of collective knowledge.
Acemoglu's point is not simply that knowledge is valuable because knowing more is intellectually satisfying. Knowledge becomes socially important when human beings can use it to improve their lives.
Collective knowledge can help societies change their technologies, social norms and institutions. Better knowledge can therefore contribute to better ways of organising economic life, political institutions and social relationships.
The four premises consequently form a chain: human beings can be wrong; therefore they need to learn from one another; collective learning can gradually improve knowledge; and improved knowledge can be used to improve human life.
9. From four premises to four pillars of liberal democracy
Acemoglu then makes the next major move. These four philosophical premises lead to several practical conclusions about how a liberal society should be organised. He calls these conclusions the “pillars” of liberal institutions and liberal democracy.
The first is the vitality of experimentation. If humans are fallible and knowledge improves through learning, society should allow people to try new things. Experimentation applies not only to technology but also to social and institutional arrangements. Society needs room for people and communities to discover better ways of doing things.
The second is nondomination and self-government. A liberal society must organise power so that no person or institution can arbitrarily control the lives of others, while people must also have a meaningful role in governing themselves.
The third is economic growth. Acemoglu places economic improvement directly within the liberal agenda. Improving material conditions and sharing that improvement are not secondary concerns; they are central to liberalism.
The fourth is soft communitarianism. Community should become an integral part of liberal democracy, but it must be balanced against the possibility that communities themselves can become oppressive and restrict individual freedom.
10. The deeper logic of the page
The most important thing to understand about page 26 is that Acemoglu is reconstructing the meaning of liberal democracy from the ground up.
He begins with a basic fact about human beings: we are fallible. From that comes the need for learning and experimentation. Because much learning occurs socially, community becomes important. Because knowledge should ultimately improve human life, economic and social progress become legitimate goals of liberal institutions. And because individuals and communities can both make mistakes or become powerful, society needs nondomination and self-government.
Thus, Acemoglu's liberalism is neither simply individualism nor simply communitarianism. It is an attempt to construct a system in which individual freedom, community, collective learning, experimentation and shared prosperity reinforce one another.
That is the conceptual bridge from the crisis described in the first part of the chapter to the positive theory that Acemoglu will develop from page 27 onward. Page 26 therefore does not yet give the full explanation of “nondomination,” “self-government,” or “soft communitarianism”; it introduces them as the major pillars, which the following pages will unpack.
Page 27 — From Freedom from Interference to Freedom from Domination
Page 27 continues exactly from where page 26 ended. On page 26, Acemoglu introduced the four major pillars of his reconstructed liberalism: experimentation, nondomination and self-government, economic growth, and soft communitarianism. Page 27 now explains these ideas more concretely, especially nondomination and self-government. The central question of this page is: What does it actually mean for a person to be free in a liberal society? Acemoglu argues that merely being left alone is not enough. A person must also be protected from arbitrary power and must have sufficient social and economic security to exercise meaningful freedom.
1. The four pillars are connected
Acemoglu first brings together the four pillars introduced on page 26. His version of liberalism wants to give both individuals and communities enough freedom and resources to experiment. Experimentation is important because society learns by trying different ways of doing things.
He then explains the role of the other pillars in this process. Nondomination and self-government are supposed to give people the security, freedom and political power necessary for experimentation. Economic growth and soft communitarianism, in turn, help society share the knowledge produced through experimentation and convert that knowledge into material and social improvement.
So these are not four completely separate ideas. They form a system. Freedom allows experimentation; experimentation produces knowledge; collective knowledge can produce economic and social improvement; and community and self-government help people participate in this process.
2. Nondomination is different from noninterference
The most important distinction on page 27 is between noninterference and nondomination.
Classical liberalism often understands freedom through the principle of noninterference. In simple terms, this means that the state or another private actor should not interfere with a person's thoughts and actions. If nobody is interfering with you, you are considered free.
Acemoglu thinks this understanding of freedom is incomplete. A person may technically be free from actual interference while still living under the threat of arbitrary power.
His concept of nondomination therefore asks a different question: Does someone have the arbitrary power to control or restrict my choices?
The difference is subtle but extremely important. Noninterference asks whether someone is actually interfering with you. Nondomination asks whether someone has the arbitrary ability to interfere with you.
3. An employer provides a simple example
Acemoglu gives an example that makes this distinction much clearer. Imagine an individual who has a job but knows that if they lose that job, they and their family could face hunger.
Technically, the employer may not be interfering with every decision that the worker makes. The worker may appear to have freedom. But because their economic survival depends so heavily on the employer, the employer possesses enormous power over them.
Such a person cannot easily experiment, take risks or make independent choices. They may be afraid to leave a bad job, challenge unfair treatment or try something new because the consequences could be catastrophic for their family.
Therefore, economic insecurity itself can create domination.
This is one of the most significant ideas in Acemoglu's argument. Freedom cannot be understood only in terms of whether somebody is formally allowed to do something. We must also ask whether the person possesses the real security and resources necessary to exercise that freedom.
4. Freedom requires some degree of economic security
This is why Acemoglu says that nondomination requires a certain amount of social and economic security.
If people are constantly threatened by unemployment, hunger, lack of healthcare or the absence of basic infrastructure, their formal rights may not translate into meaningful freedom.
For example, telling a person that they are free to leave their employer means something very different depending on whether that person has access to healthcare, public services, savings, alternative employment and basic social protection. Without such security, the formal freedom to choose may exist on paper while the person's actual range of choices remains severely restricted.
Therefore, Acemoglu's liberalism does not see redistribution and public services as necessarily hostile to freedom. He argues that some degree of redistribution and public provision of services such as health and infrastructure may actually be necessary to create a level playing field in which people can exercise freedom and participate in economic life.
5. Why redistribution can be a liberal idea
This is an important departure from a narrow understanding of liberalism.
If liberalism is interpreted only as “the government should not interfere”, then taxation, redistribution and public services may appear to be violations of individual freedom.
But Acemoglu's conception starts from nondomination. If poverty and insecurity leave people dependent upon powerful employers, wealthy individuals, institutions or social groups, then simply removing government intervention does not necessarily make them free.
In his framework, carefully designed public provision can instead increase people's effective freedom by reducing their vulnerability to arbitrary power.
Thus, Acemoglu is not arguing that the state should control people's lives. He is arguing that the state may need to provide certain conditions under which people can genuinely exercise their choices without being trapped by extreme dependency.
6. Nondomination leads directly to self-government
Acemoglu then makes an even deeper connection. Nondomination cannot exist without self-government.
Why?
Because human beings are always governed by something. Laws, institutions and social norms have power over people's lives. They determine what is permitted, what is prohibited and what is punished.
Therefore, even if a government does not arbitrarily interfere with a person in their everyday life, that person is still living within a system of rules that affects their choices.
The crucial question becomes: Did people have any meaningful role in determining those rules?
If they have no say whatsoever in what is prohibited, what is punished or how institutions operate, then they remain subject to the power of others. In that situation, Acemoglu argues, there is still domination.
7. What self-government means
Self-government therefore means that individuals and communities should have a meaningful role in governing themselves.
It does not mean that every person personally makes every law. Rather, it means that people should participate in the political and social processes through which the rules governing their lives are created and changed.
This is important because laws and institutions are not neutral forces floating above society. They shape people's lives. If people are completely excluded from decisions about these institutions, they become subjects of decisions made by others.
Self-government therefore gives liberal freedom a political dimension. Freedom is not simply having private space in which the state leaves you alone. It also involves having a voice in the collective arrangements under which you live.
8. Self-government protects against concentration of power
Acemoglu gives self-government another important role: it is a protection against the concentration of power.
Concentrated power is dangerous to nondomination because when too much power is placed in the hands of one individual, institution, political group or elite, that power can eventually be used arbitrarily.
Self-government distributes political agency more widely. It gives individuals and communities some capacity to influence the institutions that govern them.
Therefore, self-government is not simply a democratic ideal added to liberalism from outside. In Acemoglu's framework, it is necessary for liberal freedom itself.
9. Self-government also helps society learn
There is one more connection that is particularly important for understanding Acemoglu's overall theory.
Self-government is also essential for social learning.
When communities participate in governing themselves, they can try different institutional arrangements and different social norms. They can discover what works, what fails and what needs to be changed.
In other words, democracy becomes a form of collective experimentation.
This connects page 27 directly back to the four premises introduced on page 26. Humans are fallible, so they need to learn. Learning takes place through communication and community. Communities therefore need opportunities to experiment. Self-government provides one of the institutional mechanisms through which that experimentation can occur.
10. The central message of page 27
The deepest message of page 27 is that freedom is more demanding than simply being left alone.
A person may be free from direct interference and yet live under domination if another person or institution possesses arbitrary power over their choices. A worker who fears starvation after losing a job illustrates this problem. Similarly, a citizen may formally possess rights but still experience domination if they have no meaningful say in the laws and institutions that govern them.
Acemoglu therefore connects economic security, political participation and individual freedom. Basic social and economic security can reduce dependence and domination; self-government can prevent political domination; and both together create the conditions in which individuals and communities can experiment, learn and participate in shaping their own lives.
This is the major conceptual movement of page 27: liberal freedom moves from merely “nobody should interfere with me” toward “nobody should possess arbitrary power over me, and I should have a meaningful role in shaping the rules under which I live.” That idea prepares the ground for the continuation on page 28, where Acemoglu connects community, self-government, economic security and working-class concerns more explicitly.
Page 28 — Community, Freedom and the Idea of Working-Class Liberalism
Page 28 continues the argument of page 27, but now Acemoglu moves from the abstract ideas of nondomination and self-government toward their social and political meaning. His central concern is that liberal democracy must reconnect community, self-government, economic security and the interests of ordinary working people with individual freedom. He then introduces the term “working-class liberalism” for the practical form of liberalism he wants to see today.
1. Community and economic security are part of liberal freedom
Acemoglu begins page 28 by completing the thought from page 27: self-government allows communities to conduct their own institutional and normative experiments.
This is important because, for Acemoglu, a community is not simply a group of people who happen to live together. A functioning community can participate in deciding how its institutions and social norms should work. It can therefore become a place where people learn collectively and experiment with different ways of organising their common life.
From this, Acemoglu draws a broader conclusion. Community, self-government and economic security, together with other concerns traditionally associated with the working class, must be central to the kind of liberal democracy he is advocating.
This is a major shift from a narrow conception of liberalism in which individual rights are treated as sufficient. Acemoglu is saying that people cannot fully enjoy liberal freedom if they are socially isolated, economically insecure or excluded from the processes through which their communities are governed.
2. Why John Milton is important here
Acemoglu then refers to the English poet and republican thinker John Milton, quoting his description of what people who possess greatness or authority should be like.
The important idea in Milton's passage is that those who are powerful or elevated should not place themselves above ordinary people. They should live among them, walk the streets as they do, and be approachable and capable of speaking with them freely and familiarly.
This quotation fits very closely with Acemoglu's larger concern about the separation between elites and ordinary citizens.
The phrase “walk the streets as other men” therefore carries a larger political meaning. A healthy liberal democracy should not produce a ruling or educated class that becomes socially detached from the people whose lives its decisions affect.
The idea is not that everyone must become identical. Rather, it is that social status should not create a relationship of superiority and distance between citizens.
3. Acemoglu wants both a philosophy and a political movement
Acemoglu then makes his objective broader. He says that his hope is not merely to give liberalism a new philosophical justification. He also wants to influence liberalism in practice as a political movement.
This distinction matters.
He is not writing only a philosophical defence of liberalism. He wants his ideas to influence how liberal democratic politics is actually organised and what political priorities it adopts.
Therefore, the argument is moving from:
What should liberalism believe?
to:
What should liberal democratic politics actually do?
This is where the concept of working-class liberalism enters.
4. What Acemoglu means by “working-class liberalism”
Acemoglu calls the practical implementation of his version of liberalism in the present “working-class liberalism.”
The reason for this name is directly connected to what he sees as the current crisis of liberal democracy. He argues that many of liberalism's present failures are connected to its abandonment of the working class and its priorities.
Therefore, working-class liberalism is not simply a policy programme designed to win back voters. It is meant to correct something that has gone wrong in liberalism itself.
He identifies several characteristics of this approach: it has strong communal roots, it rejects social engineering, and it gives priority to shared prosperity, jobs and public services.
So the working class is important here not merely as an electoral constituency. It represents a set of concerns that Acemoglu believes liberalism has increasingly neglected: economic security, decent employment, functioning public services, community and participation in collective life.
5. Working-class liberalism is not merely an electoral concession
Acemoglu immediately makes an important clarification.
He says he is not proposing working-class liberalism simply as a concession that liberal democracy must make in order to prevent political backlash or persuade the working class to support it.
That would mean something like: liberalism has its own preferred philosophy, but because people are angry, liberal politicians should temporarily adopt working-class policies to regain their support.
Acemoglu's argument is much stronger.
He believes that liberalism itself will become stronger and more faithful to its fundamental justifications when it takes on this working-class character.
In other words, reconnecting liberalism with working-class concerns is not a departure from genuine liberalism. For Acemoglu, it is actually a way of recovering something that liberalism itself has lost.
6. Why community cannot simply replace liberalism
Acemoglu then introduces an equally important warning.
If liberalism has neglected community, one might conclude that the answer is simply to abandon liberalism and embrace a philosophy centred entirely on community.
He rejects that idea too.
He says that prioritising working-class and communitarian concerns without liberalism would not be equally attractive because there is a delicate relationship between community and freedom.
This is crucial. Acemoglu does not romanticise community.
Community can be extremely valuable because it provides a natural setting for self-government and information-sharing. People who belong to communities can trust one another, communicate, learn from one another and collectively decide how they want to organise aspects of their lives.
But the same community can also become a source of oppression.
7. Community can protect freedom, but it can also restrict freedom
This is one of the most important ideas on page 28.
A community can give people belonging, security, information and opportunities for self-government. But communities also develop customs, norms and expectations. These can become so powerful that they restrict the freedom of individual members.
In other words, the community that gives someone a sense of belonging can also tell that person:
“This is how you must live.”
When community expectations become rigid, they can prevent individuals from making their own choices or pursuing different ways of living.
Acemoglu therefore refuses to make either side absolute. Pure individualism can destroy the social foundations necessary for cooperation and learning, while unchecked communitarianism can turn the community into a cage.
The task of working-class liberalism is to hold these two concerns together.
8. The community must not become a “cage”
The continuation of this argument, visible at the beginning of the next page, makes Acemoglu's concern particularly clear. The virtue of working-class liberalism is to combine basic liberal values with working-class priorities so that communities do not become restrictive structures that damage the freedom of some of their own members.
This means that Acemoglu does not want community simply because it is community. He wants a liberal community—one in which people can participate in collective life while retaining meaningful individual freedom.
This is why the word “soft” in his earlier expression “soft communitarianism” is important. Community should matter greatly, but it must not acquire unlimited authority over the individual.
9. The deeper connection with page 27
Page 27 argued that nondomination requires self-government and economic security. Page 28 now adds another dimension: community.
The argument can therefore be understood as a progression.
A person needs protection from arbitrary power, which is nondomination. They need a meaningful role in shaping the rules that govern their lives, which is self-government. They need sufficient material security to exercise genuine choices, which is economic security. And they need functioning social relationships and communities through which they can communicate, learn and participate in collective life.
But none of these can simply be allowed to dominate the others. Community must support freedom rather than destroy it; economic security must expand people's choices rather than make them dependent on a paternalistic state; and self-government must prevent power from becoming concentrated.
10. The central message of page 28
The central message of page 28 is that Acemoglu wants to rescue liberalism by reconnecting it with the social world from which it has become increasingly separated.
For him, liberal democracy cannot survive merely by defending abstract individual rights while ignoring people's jobs, economic security, public services, communities and ability to participate in governing themselves.
At the same time, the answer cannot be to abandon individual freedom in favour of an all-powerful community. The community must be strong enough to provide solidarity and self-government, but not so strong that it suppresses the individual.
That is why Acemoglu's proposed working-class liberalism is a fusion: liberal rights + community + self-government + economic security + shared prosperity, while deliberately avoiding the coercive tendencies of social engineering. Page 29 will then take this argument one step further by explaining why liberalism must be remade urgently, because when liberalism fails, illiberal alternatives rush in.
Pages 29–32 — The Call to Remake Liberalism
Pages 29 to 32 bring the opening chapter to a close. Acemoglu now moves from diagnosing the crisis of liberalism to explaining why liberalism must nevertheless be defended and reconstructed. He first explains why the failure of liberalism creates space for illiberal forces, then gives the broad plan of the book, showing how the later chapters will establish his theory, examine liberalism's historical successes, analyse its postindustrial failures, and finally propose a renewed working-class liberalism suited to the age of algorithms and AI.
Page 29 — When Liberalism Fails, Illiberalism Rushes In
1. Liberalism's weakness creates an opening for its rivals
Page 29 begins by completing the argument from page 28. Acemoglu has just explained that working-class liberalism must combine liberal values with working-class priorities so that community does not become oppressive. He now makes the larger warning: when liberalism becomes weak, its rivals do not simply wait peacefully for people to rediscover liberalism. Illiberal movements move into the space created by liberalism's failures.
He observes that increasingly bold attacks are being directed against liberal establishments and against the vulnerable foundations of liberal democracy. In several countries, including the United States, these attacks have already achieved considerable success. According to Acemoglu, antiliberal forces begin to undermine precisely those institutions that protect liberal democracy: they restrict speech, weaken the rule of law, dismantle safeguards against the abuse of power, and revive different forms of hierarchy and inequality.
The important point is that Acemoglu is not treating the rise of illiberalism as something that has appeared from nowhere. The weakness of liberal democracy creates the political space in which its opponents can grow.
2. Why Acemoglu focuses on liberalism's crisis rather than on its enemies
Acemoglu makes a deliberate choice about what his book will study. He could have written primarily about the dangerous ideas and strategies of antiliberal movements. Instead, he says that he wants to focus on the crisis of liberalism itself.
His reasoning is important. He believes these destructive political currents are gaining strength partly because liberalism has become weak. Therefore, merely attacking the alternatives is not enough.
Suppose an illiberal movement is authoritarian, intolerant or hierarchical. Demonstrating that these features are bad does not automatically make liberal democracy attractive again. If people have legitimate reasons for being dissatisfied with the existing liberal order, then simply telling them that the alternative is worse will not solve the underlying problem.
Acemoglu therefore wants to ask a harder question: What has liberalism itself done wrong, and how can it be rebuilt?
3. Criticising liberalism is therefore part of defending liberalism
This is one of the subtle arguments of the page.
Acemoglu's criticism of liberalism should not be mistaken for hostility toward liberalism. He is criticising it because he wants to save it.
He argues that even when the available alternatives are much worse, liberalism must confront its own failures. Otherwise, it will become increasingly difficult for liberal democracy to resist the appeal of antiliberal alternatives.
So his strategy is not:
“Liberalism is bad, therefore replace it.”
It is closer to:
“Liberalism has failed in important ways; therefore understand those failures and remake liberalism so that it can once again fulfil its own purposes.”
4. The difficult task of working-class liberalism
Acemoglu admits that this reconstruction will not be easy. Creating working-class liberalism would already be difficult under favourable circumstances, but it becomes much harder in an environment characterised by political polarisation and declining trust in institutions and elites.
Yet he says that there is no alternative but to try.
His warning is stark. If liberalism does not remake itself, other political projects may fill the vacuum, including new oligarchies, authoritarianism, ethnonationalism, deep-rooted hierarchy, or renewed extreme progressive movements.
The exact forms may differ, but the underlying danger is the same: when liberal democracy fails to provide people with meaningful freedom, security, participation and shared prosperity, political energy can move toward systems that promise order, identity, equality or protection through much less liberal means.
Page 30 — The Two Core Arguments of the Book
1. Acemoglu now explains the architecture of the book
At the beginning of page 30, Acemoglu moves from the diagnosis of the crisis to the plan for the rest of the book.
He says the book has two central arguments.
The first argument concerns the virtues of his particular form of liberalism. He derives these virtues from the importance of experimentation and collective knowledge. This connects directly with the four premises he introduced on page 26: human beings are fallible, they learn socially, knowledge can gradually improve, and collective knowledge can be used to improve human life.
The second argument concerns the historical experience of liberal democracy: Acemoglu wants to explain why shared prosperity and effective liberal democratic governance became possible, particularly after World War II, and why these achievements subsequently weakened and came to an end during the postindustrial era.
2. The two arguments are inseparable
Acemoglu immediately says that these two arguments are interconnected.
This is important because the book is not simply a philosophical exercise. He does not want to construct an attractive theory of liberalism and leave it there. Nor does he want to tell a historical story without explaining what the story means for the future.
His argument is that liberalism worked remarkably well under certain historical conditions, but later lost its way as society entered the postindustrial era. Therefore, the historical evidence can help us understand both what liberalism was capable of achieving and what needs to be changed.
This is why defending liberalism remains worthwhile. It has failed in important ways, but Acemoglu believes it can still be rebuilt and contribute substantially to social good.
Page 30 — Chapter 2: Building the Theory of Liberalism
3. The next chapter establishes the philosophical foundations
Acemoglu explains that Chapter 2 will develop the theory of liberalism that he introduced on pages 26–28.
He will provide historical and empirical justification for the four premises: fallibility, social learning in community, gentle epistemic improvement and the desirability of collective knowledge.
But he will not simply assume that these principles fit together perfectly. He says that there are inevitable tensions and trade-offs among them.
This is significant because Acemoglu is not presenting liberal democracy as a system in which every good automatically reinforces every other good. Freedom, community, knowledge, self-government and other objectives can sometimes conflict.
A serious liberalism therefore has to recognise these tensions and find ways of managing them rather than pretending that they do not exist.
Page 30 — Chapter 3: Recovering Community within Liberalism
4. Community was not originally the enemy of liberalism
Chapter 3, Acemoglu explains, will challenge a common assumption: that community and liberalism are naturally opposed to each other.
He argues that ideas about community were actually important in early liberal thought.
This fits directly with his discussion on page 28. Liberalism did not necessarily begin as a philosophy of isolated individuals. Community, mutual relationships and collective self-government were part of earlier liberal thinking.
According to Acemoglu, these ideas were subsequently displaced by different intellectual developments. On the Left, ideas based on Rousseau's “general will” and social contracts became increasingly influential, while classical liberalism became dominant on the Right.
Chapter 3 will therefore try to recover a justification for a new social compact based not on an abstract society considered as a single general will, but on deliberation beginning from actual communities.
This is important for the whole project because Acemoglu wants democracy to be rooted in real social interaction and collective learning, rather than simply in an abstract relationship between an isolated individual and the state.
Page 30 — Chapter 4: Remembering What Liberalism Achieved
5. Liberalism was not merely a failure
Chapter 4 will recount the political and economic successes of liberalism.
Acemoglu argues that the emergence of limited government owes much to liberal values. He also argues that the economic growth and effective public services experienced by many countries during the decades following World War II were substantially connected to liberal institutions and ideas.
This historical examination is important because Acemoglu wants to prevent a simplistic interpretation of the current crisis.
The argument is not that liberal democracy never delivered anything substantial. Quite the opposite: it produced important political, economic and social achievements, and understanding those achievements is necessary if we want to understand how liberalism can be reconstructed.
He says he will examine comparative evidence concerning economic growth, education and health in countries that adopted liberal democratic institutions, while also giving more detailed attention to the experiences of Sweden and Norway. He will additionally examine cases in which well-designed regulation and government action successfully protected weaker or disadvantaged members of society.
This is especially important in the context of his earlier argument about regulation. The problem, therefore, is not simply government intervention versus no government intervention. The crucial question is whether institutions and regulations are properly designed and actually serve the purposes of protecting people and expanding their effective freedom.
Page 30–31 — Chapter 5: The Permanent Problems of Liberalism
6. Liberalism contains difficult dilemmas
Chapter 5 turns to what Acemoglu calls the “always-simmering dilemmas” of liberalism: inclusion, ignorance and intolerance.
These problems cannot simply be eliminated through a perfect institutional formula. Acemoglu argues that they involve unavoidable trade-offs between freedom and claims to self-government.
For example, allowing people maximum freedom may sometimes permit harmful or intolerant ideas to flourish, while restricting such ideas may itself threaten freedom. Similarly, democratic self-government can produce decisions that conflict with individual rights.
Therefore, Acemoglu does not promise a liberal democracy without contradictions. Instead, his theory is intended to help us identify these trade-offs and formulate practical responses.
This is another reason why the principle of fallibility from page 26 is so important. If human beings and institutions are fallible, then liberal democracy must be designed as a system capable of recognising and responding to its own mistakes and tensions.
Page 31 — Chapters 6–8: How Liberalism Failed After Gaining Power
7. The second half of the book changes direction
Chapters 6 through 8 begin the second major part of Acemoglu's argument. Here he investigates what he calls liberalism's failure to adjust to being in power.
This is a very important phrase.
Liberalism had historically developed partly as a movement against concentrated political power. But once liberal institutions became established and successful, liberalism itself became part of the governing order.
The question then became: Could liberalism preserve its own principles once it became powerful and institutionalised?
Acemoglu believes that it struggled to do so.
8. Chapter 6 — The transformation of the industrial economy
Chapter 6 examines how the economics of the industrial era changed with the arrival of digital technologies.
The central concern is the transformation of the economic structure itself. The industrial economy that had supported particular patterns of employment, production and social organisation did not remain unchanged.
The arrival of digital technologies contributed to a new economic environment, and Acemoglu wants to understand how this transformation affected liberal democracy.
The economic transformation therefore becomes one part of the explanation for why the earlier relationship between liberalism and shared prosperity weakened.
Page 31 — Chapter 7: Postindustrial Politics
9. Economic transformation produced political transformation
Chapter 7 takes the argument further. Acemoglu says that alongside postindustrial economics, there emerged a postindustrial politics.
One of his central claims is that college-educated groups became increasingly dominant while becoming increasingly separated from other sections of society.
This separation matters politically because liberal democracy requires more than formal elections. It requires a relationship between different social groups, a sense of common membership and institutions capable of representing different interests.
When an educated segment of society becomes increasingly dominant and detached from the rest, the result can be alienation, distrust and political backlash.
Acemoglu therefore connects the social separation of educated groups from the rest of society with the deeper crisis of liberal democracy.
Page 31 — Chapter 8: Social Engineering
10. Social engineering is not unique to one ideology
Chapter 8 examines social engineering, another major concept in Acemoglu's explanation of the crisis.
He makes an important general claim: social engineering exists in almost every political regime.
It is therefore not simply a characteristic of one particular political ideology. The more important question is who possesses the power to reshape society and in whose image.
Acemoglu argues that social engineering typically gives greater social power to the more educated members of society. Once they acquire this power, they can become the drivers of still more social engineering.
A feedback loop can therefore develop. Greater influence allows educated groups to reshape institutions and social arrangements; their belief in their own enlightenment can then strengthen their confidence that they should continue reshaping society.
This helps explain why postindustrial social engineering became so powerful and why it eventually generated a backlash.
Page 31 — Chapter 9: Liberalism in the Age of Algorithms
11. Social media did not create the crisis
Chapter 9 asks whether Acemoglu's version of liberalism is appropriate for the age of algorithms.
He makes an important distinction regarding social media. He does not believe that the failures of liberalism can simply be blamed on social media platforms. The underlying problems existed before Facebook and Twitter.
However, social media can amplify those problems.
The reason is particularly important in light of Acemoglu's emphasis on community and social learning. Social media can make it more difficult to build communities based on trust, both within communities and between different communities.
If liberal democracy depends partly on people being able to communicate, learn from one another and develop shared understandings, then technological systems that fragment social relationships can weaken one of its important foundations.
12. Why regulation of social media enters the argument
Acemoglu therefore believes there is a strong case for regulating social media.
But this does not mean abandoning freedom of expression. The challenge is precisely to find forms of regulation that are consistent with freedom of expression.
This anticipates Chapter 10, where he will address how such regulation might be designed.
The important conceptual point is that regulation here is not presented as the opposite of liberalism. If certain institutional arrangements undermine the conditions necessary for free and constructive social learning, then carefully designed regulation may actually be required to protect the social foundations of liberal democracy.
Page 31–32 — Artificial Intelligence and Collective Knowledge
13. AI creates a different and more complicated problem
Acemoglu says that the implications of AI are more complex.
The first question is whether AI could eventually become so intelligent that it can perform everything humans can do. If that happened, one might conclude that there would no longer be much purpose in maintaining specifically human collective knowledge.
Acemoglu rejects this conclusion. He argues that such superintelligence is neither realistic nor likely within the foreseeable future. More importantly, even if powerful AI does develop, it would not eliminate the need for human adaptation and social learning.
This is crucial for his broader theory. Human beings will still need to decide how technologies should be used, how institutions should respond to them, what social norms should govern them, and what kinds of lives and societies they want to create.
Therefore, even extremely powerful AI does not automatically make human collective learning irrelevant.
14. AI can damage experimentation and communication
Acemoglu then identifies a more immediate concern. AI could potentially damage the very processes that his theory considers essential: experimentation, communication and the accumulation of useful collective knowledge.
If AI systems become heavily concentrated or if people increasingly rely upon systems that mediate information and decision-making, the social processes through which people independently experiment, communicate and learn could be weakened.
This is why Acemoglu sees possible reasons for regulating AI within a liberal society.
But once again, regulation is not presented simply as technological restriction. The deeper purpose is to ensure that technological development remains compatible with the social processes necessary for human freedom, experimentation and collective knowledge.
15. AI can also become complementary to human knowledge
Acemoglu does not present AI only as a threat.
He also sees the possibility that, if AI is steered correctly, it could complement human efforts to expand collective knowledge and rebuild shared prosperity.
This is consistent with the overall philosophy of the book. Technology is neither automatically liberating nor automatically destructive. Its consequences depend partly upon how societies organise and govern it.
The question therefore becomes not simply, “Is AI good or bad?” but rather, “What institutional arrangements can ensure that AI strengthens rather than undermines human experimentation, collective learning and shared prosperity?”
Page 32 — Chapter 10: Rebuilding Liberalism
16. The final proposal — working-class liberalism
Chapter 10 brings the argument toward its practical conclusion.
Acemoglu proposes rebuilding liberalism around three major characteristics: it should be without social engineering, it should have communal foundations, and it should have a strong commitment to shared prosperity.
He calls this reconstructed version working-class liberalism.
This is the practical form of the liberalism he has been developing throughout these pages. It is intended to restore the connection between liberal rights and the social and economic conditions that make those rights meaningful.
17. Fallibility must become a genuine institutional principle
The renewed liberalism must begin with a genuine appreciation of the fallibility of human endeavours.
This connects directly back to page 26. If every human belief and institution can be wrong, then no political group, expert class, government or ideological movement should be treated as possessing unquestionable knowledge.
This creates a strong justification for experimentation, debate, dissent and institutional correction.
18. Freedom of expression and choice remain central
Acemoglu also insists upon the value of freedom of expression and choice.
This is important because working-class liberalism is not intended to become an authoritarian communitarianism. Community cannot be allowed to eliminate individual choice, just as economic redistribution cannot become unlimited state control.
Individual freedom remains one of the foundational values of the reconstructed liberal order.
19. Growth and jobs are part of freedom
Acemoglu then makes explicit something that has been developing throughout these pages: shared economic growth and jobs are central to effective freedom.
This is a particularly important departure from a purely formal understanding of liberal rights.
If people technically possess rights but lack employment, economic security, public services or the material resources necessary to exercise meaningful choices, then their freedom is incomplete.
Therefore, economic growth is not merely an economic objective placed alongside liberalism. For Acemoglu, shared prosperity is one of the conditions through which freedom becomes effective in people's actual lives.
20. Community and self-government must be restored
Finally, the renewed liberalism must have a robust emphasis on community and self-government.
This brings together almost the entire argument of pages 26–32.
Human beings are fallible, so they need social learning. Social learning requires communication and relationships within communities. Communities need opportunities for self-government and experimentation. Individuals need protection from arbitrary power. They also need economic security and shared prosperity to make their freedom meaningful.
Thus, the liberalism Acemoglu proposes is not simply about protecting individuals from the state. It is about creating a social and political environment in which individuals and communities can participate in shaping their own lives while remaining protected from domination.
Page 32 — How Acemoglu Wants the Book to Be Read
21. The book has different possible entry points
At the very end of page 32, Acemoglu explains that the book can be read in different ways depending upon what the reader wants.
He says that the structure of the book represents his view of the most complete account of liberalism's successes and failures and of how liberalism can be reimagined and remade around a coherent conception of the common good.
For readers primarily interested in understanding the historical successes and failures of liberalism, he suggests that Chapters 2 and 3 can be skipped initially and the reader can move directly to Chapter 4.
For readers primarily concerned with the current crisis, he says they may begin with Chapter 6 and return later to Chapters 2 through 5 to understand the theoretical ideas behind his recommendations and the ways in which those ideas contributed to liberalism's earlier successes.
This final passage tells us something about how Acemoglu understands his own project. The book is deliberately structured around two interconnected levels: first, a philosophical theory explaining why his form of liberalism is desirable; second, a historical and empirical explanation of how liberal democracy succeeded, why it later failed, and how it can be reconstructed.
The Overall Movement from Page 29 to Page 32
The movement across these final pages is therefore quite systematic.
Acemoglu begins on page 29 with a warning: when liberalism fails, illiberal forces gain an opportunity. He then explains on page 30 that the book will defend liberalism by combining philosophical reasoning with historical evidence. Chapters 2–5 establish the philosophical foundations, recover the role of community, demonstrate liberalism's historical achievements and examine its permanent dilemmas. Chapters 6–8 then explain how liberalism became disconnected from the transformed economic and political realities of the postindustrial era and how social engineering contributed to the backlash. Chapter 9 brings the argument into the technological present, examining social media, algorithms and AI. Finally, Chapter 10 proposes the reconstruction of liberalism as working-class liberalism, grounded in fallibility, freedom of expression and choice, shared growth and jobs, community and self-government.
The deepest message of these pages is therefore not simply “liberal democracy is in crisis.” Acemoglu's argument is more demanding: liberal democracy is in crisis because liberalism has become disconnected from some of the conditions that made liberal freedom meaningful in the first place. It has weakened its relationship with community, economic security, working-class interests, shared prosperity and genuine participation in self-government. At the same time, it has allowed forms of social engineering and elite separation to grow. The answer, therefore, is neither to defend the existing system uncritically nor to abandon liberalism for an illiberal alternative. The answer is to remake liberalism so that individual freedom, community, self-government, experimentation, collective knowledge and shared prosperity once again become parts of the same democratic project.
Comments
Post a Comment